• Welcome to the brand new Chookpen Forum! Please take a chance to look around, browse and check things out. If something looks out of place, missing, broken of you encounter any errors or obvious bugs please reach out to a moderator.

From Stardom to Reserve Grade?

How would you feel if the Broncos reached out to the Chooks & said we'll take Sammy & we'll give you Ezra?
We need an organising halfback that has good/great playmaking skills to suit our style/playing system.

Ezra is a running five eighth and a very good one.

Sammy will go to the Broncos and we'll need to chip in for next season Imo. 1 year deal.
 
I cant see that happening but we'll know soon enough.
I dont think Sam & his parents would want him near Gus.
Gus plays mind games & Ciraldo to me knows that if he doest agree with Gus he will be punted so its like he's on egg shells all the time.
If Sam wants 1.5 mil & they get rid of Burton who you say is on 800k where do they get the other 700k from?
Sam is only on $1m next year. Which it seems that Burton is also.. what a co-inky-dink. Swapsy
 
Not gonna lie, it'd be pretty amusing seeing Sam absolutely carve up NSW Cup for a game or two but I agree with what others have said in that it'd be a bit silly of the club to do that. If you're going to pay him and have him in the cap then might as well have him play.

We need an organising halfback that has good/great playmaking skills to suit our style/playing system.

Ezra is a running five eighth and a very good one.

Sammy will go to the Broncos and we'll need to chip in for next season Imo. 1 year deal.

Isn't the organising half with good playmaking skills the role that many have said Hugo is to take now? That means ideally we'd have someone opposite of that to pair up with him.

Ezra & Hugo would be an interesting halves combination. I'd feel a bit ripped off trading Walker for Ezra though tbh. Walker is better by quite a distance.
 
Not gonna lie, it'd be pretty amusing seeing Sam absolutely carve up NSW Cup for a game or two but I agree with what others have said in that it'd be a bit silly of the club to do that. If you're going to pay him and have him in the cap then might as well have him play.



Isn't the organising half with good playmaking skills the role that many have said Hugo is to take now? That means ideally we'd have someone opposite of that to pair up with him.

Ezra & Hugo would be an interesting halves combination. I'd feel a bit ripped off trading Walker for Ezra though tbh. Walker is better by quite a distance.
I wouldn't trade Sammy for Ezra however if I had to pick a halves pairing from the following 3 players (Mam, Savala, Rodwell) it would be

6. Mam
7. Rodwell

14. or 18. Savala

I like Hugo however rate his playmaking ability a 5/10
I'd rate his commitment/effort 10/10.
I'd rate his utility value 10/10