• Welcome to the brand new Chookpen Forum! Please take a chance to look around, browse and check things out. If something looks out of place, missing, broken of you encounter any errors or obvious bugs please reach out to a moderator.

Herbie Farnworth. Done deal?

Herbie is keen for Sydney lifestyle, and what Easts offer on other post footy life. Not just money. However like Sam Who, greed may overtake his new mindset.
Crazy times.
So it's alright for old Nick to become a billionaire by doing deals favourable to him and not Sammy?
And in answer to your previous comment, so what if if he consulted his 20 year old girlfriend.
And in regard to Farnsworth, surely the club hasn't instigated a done deal before Nov. one.
 
So it's alright for old Nick to become a billionaire by doing deals favourable to him and not Sammy?
And in answer to your previous comment, so what if if he consulted his 20 year old girlfriend.
And in regard to Farnsworth, surely the club hasn't instigated a done deal before Nov. one.
For God's sake it's not about the money, it's the integrity of not sticking by his word.There was apparently a verbal agreement and he broke it.
 
So it's alright for old Nick to become a billionaire by doing deals favourable to him and not Sammy?
Absolutely 100% spot on.

If Sam faced a career threatening injury we would cut him without a second thought.

I don't think Sam is greedy. I do think he is ill advised.

If Sam played his whole career at the Roosters he would be looked after for life.
 
Absolutely 100% spot on.

If Sam faced a career threatening injury we would cut him without a second thought.

I don't think Sam is greedy. I do think he is ill advised.

If Sam played his whole career at the Roosters he would be looked after for life.
Not necessarily. Look at Cordner and Friend and look at how patient the club was with Billy Smith.
 
Absolutely 100% spot on.

If Sam faced a career threatening injury we would cut him without a second thought.

I don't think Sam is greedy. I do think he is ill advised.

If Sam played his whole career at the Roosters he would be looked after for life.
There is nothing wrong with money being the motivational factor, although you would want more from a Club Captain. East's obviously read Sam wrong, with the offer of Captaincy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr Whippet
I think he will re-sign with the Dolphins.
The Dophins are a powerhouse club & will definitely be considered a top 4 team in 2027.
Im tipping them or the Storm to win the comp next year.
Rumour is he definitely wants to return home to NSW. He’s a dragons junior.
 
So it's alright for old Nick to become a billionaire by doing deals favourable to him and not Sammy?
And in answer to your previous comment, so what if if he consulted his 20 year old girlfriend.
And in regard to Farnsworth, surely the club hasn't instigated a done deal before Nov. one.
Old NickP is old school. An agreement means something. Sam Who isnt wanted.
Clubs can speak to managers re- players, they can't offer contracts or talk $. That's the rules.
Sam Who had plenty of time to consult his tribe, Before he agreed.
Happy the fraud no longer dons the privileged Easts jumper. Bondi Beach won't miss him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lydon and Bates
Of all players mentioned, Stefano, Bostock and Farnsworth, Bostock would be my pick, and if Marky N came back maybe back end of 28, not too sure how all would fit, now that's a stacked side.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mightyrooster
Of all players mentioned, Stefano, Bostock and Farnsworth, Bostock would be my pick, and if Marky N came back maybe back end of 28, not too sure how all would fit, now that's a stacked side.
Bostock could be the better option between him and Herbie as Billy is more than capable of doing a job.

With Billy and Bostock you have 2 players in their preferred position. A specialist winger and a specialist centre.

We still need another prop. Preferably one that can can add impact off the bench and a experienced half. Brooks could be our only/best option in that department. Having another capable half unlocks Savala's utility value.
 
For God's sake it's not about the money, it's the integrity of not sticking by his word.There was apparently a verbal agreement and he broke it.
There is no evidence of any agreement, verbal or otherwise, and neither side has claimed there was. Nick pulled the deal for stalling, not broken promises.
 
There is no evidence of any agreement, verbal or otherwise, and neither side has claimed there was. Nick pulled the deal for stalling, not broken promises.
Did Sammy instruct his manager to ask for more money just before Nick called the deal off?