• Welcome to the brand new Chookpen Forum! Please take a chance to look around, browse and check things out. If something looks out of place, missing, broken of you encounter any errors or obvious bugs please reach out to a moderator.

Manu Return

I noticed a few of the English supporters were questioning Herbie’s ability to set up wingers, saying he’s a bit of a hog with the ball and cuts back infield too often.

Not sure if they were referring solely to the England vs Tonga game or to Dolphins games as well?
I wouldn't judge his set up plays on that game. Don't think that three quarter line has played much footy together at all. I get the speculation about him wearing the No: 1 though, looks to suit. Has the quality to be good anywhere though.
 
Surely Manu is being targetted for a wing spot. He won't get picked above the current centers and wing is where we are light on.

I think he would be an asset on and off the field
 
Smash the like button if you think Manu was a passenger and just went through the motions in his last season at the Roosters. (2024)
Had no power in his legs to accelerate like he once could in his last season or even two with us. His hammies and calfs were gone, A few light years in Rugby though may have allowed time to fix those issues
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bates
Smash the like button if you think Manu was a passenger and just went through the motions in his last season at the Roosters. (2024)
100%. No hate for the guy but I reckon he looked a bit burned out. Almost like he'd achieved everything there was to achieve and was ready to move onto his next challenge.

Similar story for RTS. Wouldn't say either had bad attitudes or whatever, they just looked switched off. IDK... like my ex from my year 10 formal! She dumped me a month before (tickets already paid + dress purchased) so we went along as 'friends'. We didn't fight or anything (made good conversation at the table and her parents were super excited that she got to dress up and stuff... she was actually pretty excited about that & getting her hair done). But like IDK. It was a dead rubber as I wasn't gonna win her back and being polite to her (which I'm very good at) felt like an act.

Sorta had that fear with Marky Mark as I don't like carrying players who've signed anywhere. However, he took his game to the next level and seemed to be enjoying his footy. MASSIVE respect to him for doing that as I question whether he'd be up for another round if we'd been able to keep him.

Have got a theory that players of that calibre can get bored and there's a point at which you can't force them to bleed for you. As such, recycling players can be part of keeping the roster fresh.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bates
100%. No hate for the guy but I reckon he looked a bit burned out. Almost like he'd achieved everything there was to achieve and was ready to move onto his next challenge.

Similar story for RTS. Wouldn't say either had bad attitudes or whatever, they just looked switched off. IDK... like my ex from my year 10 formal! She dumped me a month before (tickets already paid + dress purchased) so we went along as 'friends'. We didn't fight or anything (made good conversation at the table and her parents were super excited that she got to dress up and stuff... she was actually pretty excited about that & getting her hair done). But like IDK. It was a dead rubber as I wasn't gonna win her back and being polite to her (which I'm very good at) felt like an act.

Sorta had that fear with Marky Mark as I don't like carrying players who've signed anywhere. However, he took his game to the next level and seemed to be enjoying his footy. MASSIVE respect to him for doing that as I question whether he'd be up for another round if we'd been able to keep him.

Have got a theory that players of that calibre can get bored and there's a point at which you can't force them to bleed for you. As such, recycling players can be part of keeping the roster fresh.
I believe this is short for I dont know, and on both counts I know for a fact you dont. The above is nothing more than an opinion that is well off the mark.
 
I suspect we are looking at Joey to further bolster our hooker ranks. Can never have too many.
Quite.
Can never have too many of any position really...having two first grade teams was ideal, before the salary cap.
Manu can also play FB, we struggled when Teddy was injured.
ITWT.
 
Just my opinion but I think Casey McClean and Bradman Best are better than Herbie.
McClean is definitely in the conversation.

Best not so much after the GF. Biggest game of the year and he offered nothing.
 
Just my opinion but I think Casey McClean and Bradman Best are better than Herbie.
Bradman Best is too one dimensional and goes quiet for mine. Casey McLean is fantastic and I could see him becoming the #1 centre in the game given his age but I think Herbie has them both covered at this very moment. I'd put Toia up there aswell personally.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Superdag@
Just my opinion but I think Casey McClean and Bradman Best are better than Herbie.
For me I rate Paul Alamoti above McClean but I also rate McClean.
Alamoti is more aggressive & has a more solid build plus he's a great goal kicker.
 
Joey would become our strike weapon coming off the bench wherever TRobbo believes he could add value or fill a gap due to injury.

We know he's very capable 1 to 5 but i reckon, if Manu is prepared to play tough he could make a fist playing in the backrow, much like Angus did in the semi's.
Fully fit, he's explosive and agile.
 
I don't think we need him. His best positions were fullback and centre which we're already well stocked in. Right wing will go to Garrick leaving a spot on the left but we'll hopefully be developing one of Roache, Ramsey, Talau or Rex for that left wing spot for the entire pre-season and the first half of the 2027 NRL season as well, seems pointless to remove a long term left wing option for someone who will play half a season and then leave to line up against us next year.

Manu obviously was not a 6 and even if he was he plays too similar to Walker anyway, a utility bench option seems like a waste of his ability and then impacts Ioelu's development as well who should play his first full season from the bench with an eye on becoming the long term number 9 once Robson finishes up here.

The only way he should come here is if all four of the potential left wing options fail to make the position their own or if someone goes down to a season ending injury in our backline early in the season. Obviously he'd become very handy if Tedesco, Smith, Toia or Garrick went down but depth is the only place I really see him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bondi.man