• Welcome to the brand new Chookpen Forum! Please take a chance to look around, browse and check things out. If something looks out of place, missing, broken of you encounter any errors or obvious bugs please reach out to a moderator.

Manu Return

Bradman Best is too one dimensional and goes quiet for mine. Casey McLean is fantastic and I could see him becoming the #1 centre in the game given his age but I think Herbie has them both covered at this very moment. I'd put Toia up there aswell personally.

Toia doesn't get the accolades he deserves. In the grand final he prevented several line breaks with one-hand grabs on Ponga and Best that few others would have had the strength to hang onto. Factoring attack and defense it is Herbie and Toia. Best has defensive issues at times. I agree McLean could become #1 in the near future.
 
I don't think we need him. His best positions were fullback and centre which we're already well stocked in. Right wing will go to Garrick leaving a spot on the left but we'll hopefully be developing one of Roache, Ramsey, Talau or Rex for that left wing spot for the entire pre-season and the first half of the 2027 NRL season as well, seems pointless to remove a long term left wing option for someone who will play half a season and then leave to line up against us next year.

Manu obviously was not a 6 and even if he was he plays too similar to Walker anyway, a utility bench option seems like a waste of his ability and then impacts Ioelu's development as well who should play his first full season from the bench with an eye on becoming the long term number 9 once Robson finishes up here.

The only way he should come here is if all four of the potential left wing options fail to make the position their own or if someone goes down to a season ending injury in our backline early in the season. Obviously he'd become very handy if Tedesco, Smith, Toia or Garrick went down but depth is the only place I really see him.
Yes, teaching him to become a champion winger this season, only to find him using it against us next season makes no sense to me...now you mention it.
 
I’m looking forward to watching roache a backline player as fast as roache will add another dimension to our attack if bobby creates a bit of space out wide it’s try time for roache pure speed nobody’s catching him
 
Herbie is an elite centre. To suggest otherwise is silly.
Imagine him in a setup like the roosters or even Penrith, like I said Elite!

I would welcome back Manu with open arms even if it is for less than half of the season.

Our depth in the outside backs isn’t premiership potential. He could be great cover for any injuries
 
I’m looking forward to watching roache a backline player as fast as roache will add another dimension to our attack if bobby creates a bit of space out wide it’s try time for roache pure speed nobody’s catching him
My speed dream of Rambo fullback and Pit Bull and T on the wings would be electric. 🏎

With a name like Dietrich Roache theres got to be a killer nick coming. Apparently he was known as Pit Bull in Rugby 7s, others called him Marlene. I suggested Cocky ( more friendly of extension of Cock 'Roache'.)

At least we know a diet rich in roaches makes you fast! 🪳
 
I don't wanna be a tool about it but yeah...

- When Manu left he was getting pretty robotic. Love the guy but IDK if he's the sorta player you'd want for 1/2 the season.

- Will cop shyte for this but I think Herbie's over-rated. Doesn't mean I think he's shyte but I'm yet to see amazing 'best centre... heck... best PLAYER... in the NRL' kinda form from him. On reputation he was expecting to easily control our backline during the preliminary final. Instead he was quite frankly a bit of a sieve in defence. Happy to accept it was a one off or that Robbo's tactics got the better of him on the day, but we have high standards. Is he in the same conversation as Toops, Marky Mark, Toia, Tedesco...etc? Like, truthfully?? Coz I think Toia's the better centre than him and would throw $$$ at Toia if it was between Bob and Herbie.
Good points Issy, I mentioned in another thread where the majority of posters believed this Herbie to be fullback theory for us in 28, bloke has never played fullback at this level I don’t care he played in juniors how long ago was that?
Even when hammer plays origin they bring in Trei Fuller or move Averillo to cover, I agree wholeheartedly that he isn’t the best centre in the game and struggles to set up his winger, he's great at the individual brilliance or cutting back infield running against tired forwards, offloading the ball, he goes ok under the high ball.

Bobby T, Bradman Best, Latrell Mitchell, Casey McLean, Stephen Chrichton and Billy Smith I would have anyone one of those guys ahead of Herbie.
That try Billy scores would only be scored by Latrell and maybe Best, pure strength and physicality from Bill and I love that about him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ismXXII
I’m looking forward to watching roache a backline player as fast as roache will add another dimension to our attack if bobby creates a bit of space out wide it’s try time for roache pure speed nobody’s catching him
Yeah he looks like a totally different style of player to Marky N. Nobody will be like him I guess.

He looks a bit like a fullback more than anything. Time will tell how well he goes.y

And if he does go well, keep him away from rugby union.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr Whippet
How old is Joey now. Love the bloke but lets get real. Besides hes producing boy band cuzzy bro Hip Hop.