• Welcome to the brand new Chookpen Forum! Please take a chance to look around, browse and check things out. If something looks out of place, missing, broken of you encounter any errors or obvious bugs please reach out to a moderator.

My solution to the current player signings / November 1

Mar 30, 2026
72
88
18
Been thinking about this - here is what i think would be a better solution for all parties in terms of player signings.

Current status:
Players want to know what they are doing in the future - hence can sign a year into their last contract
Fans generally dislike the above due to watching a player at their club for a year, committed to another club
Clubs i assume dislike the above also as it takes longer to realign salary cap / solve a position problem etc
Media love the speculation
Managers and RLPA win regardless!

My proposed solution for players entering the last year of their contract;
Players / Agents can talk to other clubs in the last, lets say 18 months of their contract - but cannot sign, or say anything publicly (unless current club gives permission)
November 1 - players can sign with a new club
If a player signs for a new club - that club picks up the players existing contract and the player must move immediately to the new club.

For example - Say Sam Walker is on $800K now, and the Bulldogs agree to sign him from 2028 for $1.2M. Sam plays for the Bulldogs next year on $800K

I think this is a win for the player - their future employment remains as secure as before
Fans happy cause no player at their club thats committed elsewhere
Existing club - it will be a small transition period, but it will be like the EPL where players rarely see out the final year of their contract as they are sold for a transfer fee. Similar here - and remember, whilst the player is on contract, that club can extend whenever they want - it just brings discussions forward.

Finally - November 1 could become like a transfer deadline day in other sports - where player movements are announced all over the place. Currently Nov 1 is a build up, and really nothing happened

This system remains in place til say Round 3. Then its again available for a fortnight around say rounds 11-12 as a transfer window

just an idea - i am sure it will get shot down - but just an idea!
 
We are not the epl or nba where players are earning 10’s of millions and clubs have billions… a player can’t be expected to just up and go to Perth or New Zealand or png immediately especially with a family. The RLPA would never agree to it. And let’s be real everyone is negotiating before November 1. I don’t see it as that big an issue the good clubs like us have good plans and it adds a bit of excitement to the off season
 
  • Like
Reactions: ismXXII
Thats the thing - player could be talking to their new club months prior to November 1 - so they can plan it. It is also the players choice to where they sign - if the money is there (no its not EPL money, but it is a well paid gig) they can make that call.

I think the whole logistics of moving interstate for a NRL player is a bit over played in terms of the number of players and ignores the support the player gets from the new club in terms of moving - its pretty straight forward these days. Clubs have direct relationships that helps with housing, schooling etc
 
Having worked in a bank for many years where you could be told on Monday that you are being transferred to another town and will be starting in 2 weeks, this whole 'they need time to move their family' is a load of rubbish. Perth and PNG, slightly different, but they certainly don't need 12 months.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Red.
a player can’t be expected to just up and go to Perth or New Zealand or png immediately especially with a family. The RLPA would never agree to it.
That's a furphy IMHO. When you are talking about the kind of pay packet most blokes get moving interstate or overseas at a moments notice happens all the time in the corporate world. Also doesn't seem to be a problem when a player wants to move mid season for family reasons.
 
That's a furphy IMHO. When you are talking about the kind of pay packet most blokes get moving interstate or overseas at a moments notice happens all the time in the corporate world. Also doesn't seem to be a problem when a player wants to move mid season for family reasons.
absolutely it is BS. Just what the RLPA has used as leverage, and people believe it. People, think its ok say in Soccer cause they get paid so much in the EPL and other top tier leagues, but there is so many leagues around the world where players dont earn millions, and they get moved from country to country all the time - its the career they are in.

my other gripe - i read this morning Harry Grant saying they should play less games...... they are all about to get a 25-50% pay rise due to the salary cap and want to play less! i know its a brutal sport, but honestly, dont expect more money for less games
 
absolutely it is BS. Just what the RLPA has used as leverage, and people believe it. People, think its ok say in Soccer cause they get paid so much in the EPL and other top tier leagues, but there is so many leagues around the world where players dont earn millions, and they get moved from country to country all the time - its the career they are in.

my other gripe - i read this morning Harry Grant saying they should play less games...... they are all about to get a 25-50% pay rise due to the salary cap and want to play less! i know its a brutal sport, but honestly, dont expect more money for less games
Yeah Harry Grant has become a big whinger.
 
I dont gett why people care? Where a player is playing in a years time does not affect anyone.....the only thing people really care about is whether the team is a chance to win the comp, be competative or whether they have good prospects on the horizon. Did the fact Mark or Angus etc were going elsewhere diminish your engagement with the comp this year? If anything I think it inspired the players to go harder knowing they were not going to be here next season.
I get that people who follow rubbish teams may become disillussioned, but thats got a lot more to dow ith poor management etc than a player moving in a years time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: player 1
I dont gett why people care? Where a player is playing in a years time does not affect anyone.....the only thing people really care about is whether the team is a chance to win the comp, be competative or whether they have good prospects on the horizon. Did the fact Mark or Angus etc were going elsewhere diminish your engagement with the comp this year? If anything I think it inspired the players to go harder knowing they were not going to be here next season.
I get that people who follow rubbish teams may become disillussioned, but thats got a lot more to dow ith poor management etc than a player moving in a years time.
Very good point. Both Marky and Angus were always leaving us at the end of this year and what happened? Angus played out of his skin when he returned and likely swung the odds in our favour. Marky definitely swung the odds in our favour and without him there's a high chance we don't bag the premiership.

With Sammy it's different - his return helped but we may have won it without him if he didn't return from injury.

Plus he and his management were stinky dragging things out and trying to squeeze some more money at the last minute. Until he did his ACL a couple of years ago he was doing exactly the same thing, but in the end was happy to take our money while we supported him for most of the following season on big coin, as his bargaining power plummeted.

Instead of seeing the big picture he and his management showed no appreciation for all the club did for him.

That's why it won't work having him around in 2027. He needs to disappear from our club ASAP.
 
Sammy didn't play like a halfback worth $1 mill a season when the Sharks pumped us in 2025. He was happy to collect overs for years and in the end his greed was his undoing.
 
That's a furphy IMHO. When you are talking about the kind of pay packet most blokes get moving interstate or overseas at a moments notice happens all the time in the corporate world. Also doesn't seem to be a problem when a player wants to move mid season for family reasons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Red.
I dont gett why people care? Where a player is playing in a years time does not affect anyone.....the only thing people really care about is whether the team is a chance to win the comp, be competative or whether they have good prospects on the horizon. Did the fact Mark or Angus etc were going elsewhere diminish your engagement with the comp this year? If anything I think it inspired the players to go harder knowing they were not going to be here next season.
I get that people who follow rubbish teams may become disillussioned, but thats got a lot more to dow ith poor management etc than a player moving in a years time.
Either do I.
Who we have playing for us in 2027, 2028 or 2029 doesnt bother me, I dont expect the Chooks to win the comp every year so who ever is playing or no longer with us is just part of following football.
 
I personally think changing code, or going to English Super league is a different thing than agreeing to go to another NRL rival. Maybe i am on an island with it, it just has never sat right with me - either way - for a player leaving or arriving at the club
 
Having worked in a bank for many years where you could be told on Monday that you are being transferred to another town and will be starting in 2 weeks, this whole 'they need time to move their family' is a load of rubbish. Perth and PNG, slightly different, but they certainly don't need 12 months.
If the player does not want to move to a new club at short notice they should not sign a contract with that club!
 
Having worked in a bank for many years where you could be told on Monday that you are being transferred to another town and will be starting in 2 weeks, this whole 'they need time to move their family' is a load of rubbish. Perth and PNG, slightly different, but they certainly don't need 12 months.
So banks treat their staff as well as their customers.
 
Sammy didn't play like a halfback worth $1 mill a season when the Sharks pumped us in 2025. He was happy to collect overs for years and in the end his greed was his undoing.
That Sharks game will always be the one that tells me that getting rid of him is the right decision.
 
Nothing wrong with November 1 free agency, as it works both ways: it provides financial security for players while allowing clubs to plan and manage their squads years in advance based on the salary cap in any given year.

If a club signed several high-profile players in the final year (2027) of their current contracts with other clubs, for 2028 and beyond, it would be very unlikely to be able to afford to accommodate those players under its 2027 salary cap. The club would therefore be forced to relinquish players from its existing 2027 squad to make room for the new signings a year earlier than budgeted.

Existing squad players at the club in 2027 do not have to leave and cannot be forced out. If they wish to stay, the club would still be required to pay them.

The RLPA needs to maintain this provision in the next CBA and beyond. Players’ rights must never be watered down or traded off.

It's a fair provision covering any number of scenarios relating to player relocations during their careers.
 
Last edited:
That's a furphy IMHO. When you are talking about the kind of pay packet most blokes get moving interstate or overseas at a moments notice happens all the time in the corporate world. Also doesn't seem to be a problem when a player wants to move mid season for family reasons.
A bit like the old line that seems to happen more lately - 'i need to move for family/personal reasons or I am homesick (aka get out of this contract)'. I think most times this is just a convenient excuse that player managers tell them to use so they can piss off somewhere else. I am pleased I dont remember it happening here at the Roosters though as our culture is so good (any maybe the 'Bondi' lifestyle).
 
I dont gett why people care? Where a player is playing in a years time does not affect anyone.....the only thing people really care about is whether the team is a chance to win the comp, be competative or whether they have good prospects on the horizon. Did the fact Mark or Angus etc were going elsewhere diminish your engagement with the comp this year? If anything I think it inspired the players to go harder knowing they were not going to be here next season.
I get that people who follow rubbish teams may become disillussioned, but thats got a lot more to dow ith poor management etc than a player moving in a years time.
I have to admit i was telling Joey Manu, JAS, Gus all to hurry up and fuck off when they were playing bad in their last years (obviously this was done through the TV not face to face).
I loved Joey and he was a saviour at times but not doubt he had switched off in that final year. JAS was just hot and cold and I was angry after we looked after him and gave him get out clauses every year. I have to say, Gus did come good after getting back from the injury and playing a role in the middle rotations and he wanted to go out on top with another ring.
So after arguing with myself i think it just comes down to the player (as Marky Mark showed by his character and performance which was first class).