• Welcome to the brand new Chookpen Forum! Please take a chance to look around, browse and check things out. If something looks out of place, missing, broken of you encounter any errors or obvious bugs please reach out to a moderator.

November 1.

I have often wondered how tough Spencer would be if the rules were the same as they were in the 70's, 80's & early 90's.
If he was playing against blokes like Les Davidson, Terry Randall, Blocker Roach & Les Boyd.
This no punching just shirt grabbing that it is today can make anyone seem a tough guy.
Yes he runs hard but how would he go up against real tough men that know how to throw them?
other than 'they were all tougher back then', there's no reason to believe Spencer doesn't know how to fight?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr Whippet
I have often wondered how tough Spencer would be if the rules were the same as they were in the 70's, 80's & early 90's.
If he was playing against blokes like Les Davidson, Terry Randall, Blocker Roach & Les Boyd.
This no punching just shirt grabbing that it is today can make anyone seem a tough guy.
Yes he runs hard but how would he go up against real tough men that know how to throw them?
His gas tank and temperament would be his downfall.
 
I don't think we'd be interested in Burton unless the club see it as an opportunity to move Sammy on. These opportunities could be limited.

He's an average five eighth. Good centre however we have Billy unless Billy moves to the wing, Burton left centre.

Burton has the biggest boot on the planet which will go wasted if he's playing in the centres.

Burton/Savala halves pairing won't work.It'd be like eating boiled rice with no sauce. Weet-bix without milk.

Burton/Rodwell wouldn't be fair on Savala who's been waiting patiently for an opportunity to play in the halves

Odd signing imo.
 
I would be shocked if we signed Burton especially for the money he wants. It would go down with all the dumb signings we have made the last few years.

The issue finding a swap for Sammy is if he really wants to sign with PNG and we have to find a gap year for him. I can't think of anyone who thinks their window is open next year who haven't got a suitable halfback.
 
I would be shocked if we signed Burton especially for the money he wants. It would go down with all the dumb signings we have made the last few years.

The issue finding a swap for Sammy is if he really wants to sign with PNG and we have to find a gap year for him. I can't think of anyone who thinks their window is open next year who haven't got a suitable halfback.
The other reason for a club to sign Sammy for 1 season is if the coach is under pressure and needs to turn things around quickly. I reckon Ryles jumped on Luai for this reason.

Do you think the window would open for Souffs if they signed Sammy? This would challenge Nick imo. Would he chip in just to move Sammy on?

Potential Souffs spine

1. Gray
6. C Walker
7. S Walker
9. Cheese
 
The other reason for a club to sign Sammy for 1 season is if the coach is under pressure and needs to turn things around quickly. I reckon Ryles jumped on Luai for this reason.

Do you think the window would open for Souffs if they signed Sammy? This would challenge Nick imo. Would he chip in just to move Sammy on?

Potential Souffs spine

1. Gray
6. C Walker
7. S Walker
9. Cheese
I can't see them winning anything with a spine like that.
 
I don't think we'd be interested in Burton unless the club see it as an opportunity to move Sammy on. These opportunities could be limited.

He's an average five eighth. Good centre however we have Billy unless Billy moves to the wing, Burton left centre.

Burton has the biggest boot on the planet which will go wasted if he's playing in the centres.

Burton/Savala halves pairing won't work.It'd be like eating boiled rice with no sauce. Weet-bix without milk.

Burton/Rodwell wouldn't be fair on Savala who's been waiting patiently for an opportunity to play in the halves

Odd signing imo.

Burton would be a good pick up for us. I'd disagree with you that he's average, he's a good enough 5/8 right now but whose to say he doesn't come to the Roosters, get behind a great pack and really become elite? He already has played for Australia & NSW which proves how good he can be.

The part I agree with you on is that Burton/Savala wouldn't really be the way to go. Burton needs an organising half with him in the halves and from what I've read here that'd be Rodwell. Burton/Rodwell could be a great long term option if we miss out on the likes of Munster and Cleary.

As for Hugo, I think his future is as an elite utility. He's big enough to play second row or lock and has probably trained there, he's obviously good enough to play centre, he can play in the halves and probably wouldn't go too bad at hooker either. That's where his future is I think, could even potentially be an Origin or Australian utility some day.
 
  • Like
Reactions: restlesschook
Burton would be a good pick up for us. I'd disagree with you that he's average, he's a good enough 5/8 right now but whose to say he doesn't come to the Roosters, get behind a great pack and really become elite? He already has played for Australia & NSW which proves how good he can be.

The part I agree with you on is that Burton/Savala wouldn't really be the way to go. Burton needs an organising half with him in the halves and from what I've read here that'd be Rodwell. Burton/Rodwell could be a great long term option if we miss out on the likes of Munster and Cleary.

As for Hugo, I think his future is as an elite utility. He's big enough to play second row or lock and has probably trained there, he's obviously good enough to play centre, he can play in the halves and probably wouldn't go too bad at hooker either. That's where his future is I think, could even potentially be an Origin or Australian utility some day.
If you ranked all of the games five eighths and included Burton in that list where would he sit?
 
Burton would be a good pick up for us. I'd disagree with you that he's average, he's a good enough 5/8 right now but whose to say he doesn't come to the Roosters, get behind a great pack and really become elite? He already has played for Australia & NSW which proves how good he can be.

The part I agree with you on is that Burton/Savala wouldn't really be the way to go. Burton needs an organising half with him in the halves and from what I've read here that'd be Rodwell. Burton/Rodwell could be a great long term option if we miss out on the likes of Munster and Cleary.

As for Hugo, I think his future is as an elite utility. He's big enough to play second row or lock and has probably trained there, he's obviously good enough to play centre, he can play in the halves and probably wouldn't go too bad at hooker either. That's where his future is I think, could even potentially be an Origin or Australian utility some day.
Agree with this. Burton/Savala doesn't sound best for either of them, but Burton/Rodwell piques the interest a bit. Hugo could stay on as a long-term centre or transition to 13 or 14. Burton's running game could be great behind our pack.

Savala has done absolutely enough to be in the team next year, but I don't necessarily think that he needs to be one of the halves.
 
Anyone that winds up like Spence and runs into a brick wall of defenders at full speed is pretty fearless if you ask me.
Craziest hit up I've witnessed and I really don't like him was Sam Burgess in the 2014 GF. Yuk just being honest :poop::poop::poop::poop::poop::poop::poop::poop: apologies if you're eating.
 
The other reason for a club to sign Sammy for 1 season is if the coach is under pressure and needs to turn things around quickly. I reckon Ryles jumped on Luai for this reason.

Do you think the window would open for Souffs if they signed Sammy? This would challenge Nick imo. Would he chip in just to move Sammy on?

Potential Souffs spine

1. Gray
6. C Walker
7. S Walker
9. Cheese
Madge is under pressure, 'desperate'.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: gragra
Interesting how there’s still so little action on the free agent market. Really feels like the World Cup is slowing things down albeit I think when the first domino falls it will speed up as players realise there aren’t unlimited options

It does make me wonder if we needed to put that artificial deadline on Sam though

Really hope we sign someone early to make it all seem worthwhile
 
If there were a bunch of signings on November 1 it would've been a dead giveaway that negotiations were being done prior, thus getting the clubs in to trouble.

From the clubs point of view, let's leave it a bit so the optics are that negotiations started on or after November 1.

Lucky they have the world cup as a distraction this year.