• Welcome to the brand new Chookpen Forum! Please take a chance to look around, browse and check things out. If something looks out of place, missing, broken of you encounter any errors or obvious bugs please reach out to a moderator.

Who will replace Walker if he's given an early release???

Whatever if hes gone then we aren't the type of club to fall in a heap.

We just won the title and are mostly in finals so a decent half like Dearden would see that as a massive lure.

Maybe there were background whispers or Nathan or Dearden as possible signings who the heck knows what goes down in the background.

We'll be OK cause the clubs in good hands.
 
Don't care if Sam goes; I think he has gotten ahead of himself. As many have said - this scenario has Mitchell written all over it. And look how that has turned out!

Sam's good on his day and has won a few Ashton-Collier medals (ANZAC) and performed well at SOO (to a point) but is he worth the coin he is asking?
My answer is no. He is still susceptible in defense; he will never be a strong defender as he doesn't have (and never will have) the build and will never have a strong kicking game. I don't think he will ever be an organizing half either - his strength is off the cuff football. That may be good for a highlights reel but that will only get you so far.

And as Eddie has said, I too am sick of hearing the terms "Walker steered" or "was influential" on delivering the Roosters a premiership.

What won us a premiership was a team effort and the fact (for once) we ended the season with a very healthy list.
And if it came down to specific players, I would say Whyte, Teddy, Marky N, Foketi, Toia and Spencer (for the short time he was on and he made a huge difference) were the standouts. And as much as I wasn't a rap for DCE coming to the club, credit where credit's due - he delivered on the big stage.
 
I like the size of Matt Burton. A Burton Savala halves paring would be great defensively. Bulldogs haven't used him properly.
 
There is someone down the Albion Park–Oak Flats way whom Coach Robinson often praised.

The return of the crowd favourite Andrew Hutchison would be a fairy-tale like return.

They have had success with veteran halves before including this season.
Andrew’s Eagles lost this year’s GF to Kiama Knights by a lot
I think Hutch is safe at the Rail
 
For those that are interested, watch and listen to this video (just the first 4 minutes) :unsure:


Seriously, this sounds like less of the management's fault and more about Walker and his family having a big commercial influence. Either way, this is a decent watch/listen especially the metrics/stats being thrown around.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bates and HDTONE
Tom deardon js a very good 7
My first pick would be Cleary or Katoa
Strange is a great 6, great ball runner and defender
Wouldn’t be able to partner Hugo and strange though
 
Really? Rodwell who got absolutely toweled up in his last first grade game or Sandon Smith who is the 14 for the Knights over Nathan Cleary the most successful halfback of the modern era?
Agree with the last part, but very harsh on Rodwell. Both times Rodwell played he played in a significantly under strength roosters side. Even in the souffs game he was involved in 2-3 of our tries.
 
  • Like
Reactions: G Rooster
IMO deardon or we stick with youth either way TIT or TIN …. Full disclosure I was starting to doubt but once again they brought me back 😀
 
For those that are interested, watch and listen to this video (just the first 4 minutes) :unsure:


Seriously, this sounds like less of the management's fault and more about Walker and his family having a big commercial influence. Either way, this is a decent watch/listen especially the metrics/stats being thrown around.
Yeah it was a good listen. Thanks for posting
 
  • Like
Reactions: DP1990
I can't see us getting Deardon, he would want a huge contract and the Cowboys would want to be compensated. I think we will go with what we got and use the money to bolster our squad.
 
This time last year we were trying to work out where Savala fitted in the team. Many "experts" had him leaving for another club.

Now he's virutally a certain starter in the halves for 2027 and beyond.
 
I can't see us getting Deardon, he would want a huge contract and the Cowboys would want to be compensated. I think we will go with what we got and use the money to bolster our squad.
Only reason i think Deardon is a shot - he has a child now, and the bub / mum are in Sydney. Any new father would want to be with their child at this time - you dont get that time back

so its possible i suppose - one thing i would say, as Walker is on contract for another year, if we let him go for 27 - there should be a player swap (and depending who, money thrown one way or another)

so my shortlist to swap with the clubs he has been mentioned with would be;
Cowboys - Deardon
Dogs - Burton - him and Hugo would be interesting - no team would beat us in kick metres!
Souths - Campbell Graham
Storm - Stefano or Coates
Titans - Bai
Broncos - Unsure - just not Ezra!

Obviously some of these there would be a player plus $$ - but there are options that the club could use to leverage a deal
 
Last edited:
I can't see us getting Deardon, he would want a huge contract and the Cowboys would want to be compensated. I think we will go with what we got and use the money to bolster our squad.
Under his contract he is paid 12% of the Cowboys Salary Cap - contracted to 2029.

He won't giving that up unless signing a similar deal with another club in Sydney.
 
  • Like
Reactions: G Rooster
Only reason i think Deardon is a shot - he has a child now, and the bub / mum are in Sydney. Any new father would want to be with their child at this time - you dont get that time back

so its possible i suppose - one thing i would say, as Walker is on contract for another year, if we let him go for 27 - there should be a player swap (and depending who, money thrown one way or another)

so my shortlist to swap with the clubs he has been mentioned with would be;
Cowboys - Deardon
Dogs - Burton - him and Hugo would be interesting - no team would beat us in kick metres!
Souths - Campbell Graham
Storm - Stefano or Oates
Titans - Bai
Broncos - Unsure - just not Ezra!

Obviously some of these there would be a player plus $$ - but there are options that the club could use to leverage a deal
Couldn't stomach Sammy going to the Dogs or Souffs. Just the idea of Gus gloating about scoring Walker...couldn't stomach that.

.Mind you they'd probably play him at hooker the way they shuffle blokes outta position in that club

The Burton experiment in the halves never worked there so they're not paying him $1m to play centre.
 
Im flabbergasted that no one's mentioned Katoa. He was supposed to be the heir to Cleary at Penrith. I can see why. His contract expires at the end of 2028.