Not my cup of tea, but these are interesting times. I’ve said it in other threads, what I value most in politics is stability rather than personality cults. Stability is boring until it’s taken away. That’s part of why Howard and Costello were politically successful. Whatever people thought of them, they projected predictability and competence.
As for whether PHON could govern the country, one of my concerns is organisational competence. Leaving policy aside, the reports emerging about the party’s financial reporting and governance raise questions. I appreciate the Guardian is a left-leaning publication and everyone deserves due process, but if even part of these allegations prove accurate, they are serious matters.
Source:
https://www.theguardian.com/austral...financial-reports-returns-fair-trading-ntwnfb
More broadly, PHON still strikes me as a protest movement built around opposition to immigration rather than a fully developed governing party. It’s one thing to identify a single grievance narrative and another to demonstrate that you have the people, processes and breadth of policy needed to run a country.
To me, this resembles what happened in the ACT after the bushfires boosted support for the Greens. Protest parties often perform well when there is public frustration with the status quo. The challenge comes when they try to transition from campaigning against things to governing and making trade-offs.
For the Coalition, I think their issue is still unresolved the tension between its moderate and conservative wings. Turnbull ran into it and every Liberal leader since has had to navigate it. The Nationals have moved further right, PHON is competing for similar voters and many conservative voters would rather back PHON than a moderate Liberal or teal independent. Until that underlying dynamic changes, the same internal battles are likely to continue.