2 biggest games of Carney's career: 2010 gf and Origin debut

[Guest]

Tonight was a reality check of TC 2011 form...now maybe some here can move on and maybe take him off their avatar in his current team kit

[Guest]

Carney was very disapointing tonight Did nothing.

Pearce in my opinion wasnt that much better. Lets see Pearce penalised for offside going for a big hit Which then incited a fight which got one of our players sin binned From that they score a try Pearce turns it over late in the 1st half from that they socre

Carney though was very disappointing 2 games to go though

When the world ends lets blame it on Pearce. He made those mistakes, but he didn't force the fight and neither did he force the bad right side defensive read. Better find some other straws to clutch...

[Andrew Walker]

Tonight was a reality check of TC 2011 form...now maybe some here can move on and maybe take him off their avatar in his current team kit

1 game out of 30 odd

Very disapointing though

[Guest]

tate should have also been sin binned, once again blues got screwed. He set jennings, made numberous tackles and ran a good line to link with hayne and eventually jennings, which we nearly scored off.

He also put up the kick for the second try, did pretty much all of the general play kicking and had a bunch of great touches, fed Hayne and Jennings really well.

[The Brain]

Carney was very disapointing tonight Did nothing.

Pearce in my opinion wasnt that much better. Lets see Pearce penalised for offside going for a big hit Which then incited a fight which got one of our players sin binned From that they score a try Pearce turns it over late in the 1st half from that they socre

Carney though was very disappointing 2 games to go though

Pearce in my opinion did alright it was a shame he didnt have 5/8th to deed the bal no comparison in the two tonight.

[kurtsherlock6]

1 game out of 30 odd

Very disapointing though

Actually, his last 2 big games, 2010 GF & tonight he choked.

Thats 2 out of 2 by my count.

[Andrew Walker]

When the world ends lets blame it on Pearce. He made those mistakes, but he didn't force the fight and neither did he force the bad right side defensive read. Better find some other straws to clutch...

His offside penalty and ridiculous attempt on a big hit on a man twice his size Resulted in a penalty a brawl ensuing and a player sin binned Its not clutching at straws I ahve said Carney was disappointing However I disagree with the person who started the thread saying Perace showed true leadership qualities

Had the thraed just read Carney was poor or shit I would have agreed whole heartedly

[Headless Chook]

No maam Perhaps some people were out watching the game and didnt jump on the monent it finished

Do you ever go out at night ?

Good to see you here. Do I go out at night? Not on an Origin night I don't! Stay at home so I don't miss any thing!

[Guest]

1 game out of 30 odd

Very disapointing though

Didn't realise we were into round 30 of the NRL...not talking ancient history now mate

[Headless Chook]

His offside penalty and ridiculous attempt on a big hit on a man twice his size Resulted in a penalty a brawl ensuing and a player sin binned Its not clutching at straws I ahve said Carney was disappointing However I disagree with the person who started the thread saying Perace showed true leadership qualities

Had the thraed just read Carney was poor or shit I would have agreed whole heartedly

I agree with you....Carney was shit!

[Andrew Walker]

Actually, his last 2 big games, 2010 GF & tonight he choked.

Thats 2 out of 2 by my count.

I dont know why you are getting involved You have been a stauch advocate of it being a dum decision to sack Carney

Anything to be in the in crowd for the night on here I guess. Very sad

[Arties Pie]

Defence in Origin is different to club games, his game of running at tired forwards wont be as affective, alot more are 80 min players in Origin
and the defence just doesnt fall off anywhere near as much.

[kurtsherlock6]

I dont know why you are getting involved You have been a stauch advocate of it being a dum decision to sack Carney

Anything to be in the in crowd for the night on here I guess. Very sad

Um, if you read my other posts i actually said he shouldnt be dropped for game 2.

Anyway what have i said that you actually disagree with? Even you yourself said he was poor tonight.

[Andrew Walker]

Um I blame the referees for the 2010 gf not Todd Carney

[kurtsherlock6]

Um I blame the referees for the 2010 gf not Todd Carney

Where have i blamed Carney for the 2010 GF?? Bottom line is he had a fairly average game in 2010 GF.

Again what have i said that you actually disagree with??