Todd carney

[Guest]

You said we defeated a gutted Cronulla-Sutherland team which sounds much like an excuse.

The loss of two of our premier front rowers including our best in Jared is massive for a game against Melbourne.

[Johnny.]

You said we defeated a gutted Cronulla-Sutherland team which sounds much like an excuse.

The loss of two of our premier front rowers including our best in Jared is massive for a game against Melbourne.

Again, your opinion, no matter how much I think it is wrong, is as valid as mine.

I'm moving on from this.

[Yak]

People will find every excuse to justify their argument. If we have to rely on two players to win games then the club is in serious shit.

I'm just looking at things from an unbiased position. This is not a Mortimer vs Pearce thing, it's a reality thing.

Yet if Cam Smith didn't play that game we would have won easily imo. And i could only imagine that would have been your reason that we beat them. Good players make a difference Johnny.

[Guest]

Again, your opinion, no matter how much I think it is wrong, is as valid as mine.

I'm moving on from this.

You seem to move on from people opinion pretty quickly when it is not the same as yours. Just another valid opinion.

[Guest]

People will find every excuse to justify their argument. If we have to rely on two players to win games then the club is in serious shit.

I'm just looking at things from an unbiased position. This is not a Mortimer vs Pearce thing, it's a reality thing.

Fair point Johnny, but given how much the storm actually rely on Smith.. Every team needs that X factor

[Guest]

Poor bastard. His skills are wasted at a club like cronulla. Even amongst a team of b-graders, his skills stood out.

I still have a soft spot for him and still love watching him play. Oh what could've been. I reckon he would've shone under a level headed coach like tr too.

As it is, I can only be happy that we were lucky enough to finally get rid of Anasta and pick up a champ like Maloney.

Unfortunately for the sharks Carney is not the player he was in 2010..

[Guest]

Unfortunately for the sharks Carney is not the player he was in 2010..

He doesn`t have Pearce beside him,making him look good.Maloney currently does...

[Guest]

I gave him a nice 'welcome back carney' as he walked up the tunnel at half time.
I hope he was glad to be back.

[Guest]

He doesn`t have Pearce beside him,making him look good.Maloney currently does...

You just rustled my Jimmy's..

[Guest]

Could not care less about the idiot. Can have a flashy game in attack sometimes, but can't defend to save himself.
Plus he hasn't changed his ways, its just the tele doesn't write about it anymore

Honestly once he came back from Atherton there really wasn't a huge deal wrong with "his ways" - 99% of it was blown massively out of proportion.

Certainly wouldn't put him up there with the NRL's worst these days.

[Guest]

And to add to it.....wonder how this Roosters squad would fair against the QLD SOO?

Thoughts?

Sat watching the replay yesterday with my old man, and he said the same thing. We would have been more ffective than the actual SSO team

[chook 56]

Sat watching the replay yesterday with my old man, and he said the same thing. We would have been more ffective than the actual SSO team

This is what I was thinking.

[Guest]

And to add to it.....wonder how this Roosters squad would fair against the QLD SOO?

Thoughts?

You do realise we would have SKD marking up against Inglis?!?!?

[chook 56]

you do realise we would have skd marking up against inglis?!?!?

shhhhhhhh!

[Guest]

You do realise we would have SKD marking up against Inglis?!?!?

If he threw himself at Inglis like a Bolas it might work.

Chook.