Weakest Marquee Player In The NRL

[Guest]

Here are the choices...guessing..but i wouldn't be far off..

Boncos Lockyer
Poodles Kickpoorly
Faiders Campese
Cowgirls Thurston
Titans Prince
Manly Watmough?..Brett Stewart?
Drizzle Smith,Inglis,Slater
Knights Gidley
Parra Hayne
Penrith 70/Litre
Sharks Tampon
Souffs Burgess
Saints ?????? Hornby?
Us Anasta
Warriors Brent Tate
Tigpies Benji



Anasta wins this easy for me..

Tampon & Hornby the only others close..

We need the cap space Anasta chews up..

His impotence in attack has become laughable..

And he is not a captains arsehole..

[stephenj]

nice guy but no way a captain, fitzy sheets on him for that! the captain must earn the teams respect, i doubt braith has done that?

[Guest]

Anasta without a doubt

[Kingbilly]

What are people all of a sudden thinking Brent Tate is good ?
The only thing he is good for is running around with a broom handle inserted right up his pooper. I am not saying Anasta is setting the world on fire (I am happy with his defense though) but to say Tate offers more is almost as stupid as calling for finch to come back

[Guest]

What are people all of a sudden thinking Brent Tate is good ?
The only thing he is good for is running around with a broom handle inserted right up his pooper. I am not saying Anasta is setting the world on fire (I am happy with his defense though) but to say Tate offers more is almost as stupid as calling for finch to come back

Kingbilly mate,i love your posts..

BUT..

Tate has SPEED....Anasta is a snail..

Tate has proven to be someone who can shine in the Test & Origin arena...Check out Anasta's form in these....

In my opinion anyone who rates Anasta above Tate is stupid...& deluded..

Anasta is a dud Kingbilly...

He was bought to WIN us football games...not save them with defence..

His attacking game is completely non-existant...

But he is a great guy off the field...& a great club man

He & his wage's are a millstone around this clubs neck..

And i know the club chose to pay him that money,but his game has stagnated to such a stage that he is a hinderance,not a help,during games..

Thanks for the last quarter of 2007 Anasta....& that's it!

[Guest]

anasta is better than gidley gidley is poop

[stephenj]

thay both have big hearts

[Guest]

Anasta > Tampon and Kimmorley

[Guest]

anasta is better than gidley gidley is poop

I guarantee that 99.999% of rugby league would disagree with that. Saying something like that just proves how stupid you are.

[Guest]

i guarantee your wrong there just go back to ya camper van

[stsae]

Sadly, Giddyup is a much better player than Bwaiff.

[Guest]

i guarantee your wrong there just go back to ya camper van

No I'm pretty sure i'm right. You are just making a bigger fool out of your self by saying shit like Anasta is better than Gidley. I don't mind Anasta personally, but to say he is better than Gidley is a pointless statement.

[Guest]

No I'm pretty sure i'm right. You are just making a bigger fool out of your self by saying shit like Anasta is better than Gidley. I don't mind Anasta personally, but to say he is better than Gidley is a pointless statement.

Are you on this forum purely to defend Gidley? Surely you have something better to do.

[Guest]

No I'm pretty sure i'm right. You are just making a bigger fool out of your self by saying shit like Anasta is better than Gidley. I don't mind Anasta personally, but to say he is better than Gidley is a pointless statement.

go out get signatures prove i am wrong it isnt pointless it is fact

[stephenj]

ok crawler gidley is better than braith atm, now piss off dont come back you twerp!