phil rothfield

[Guest]

Stop reading the ****ing idiot's dumb idiotic dribble.

he could write about the whole Roosters under20s team being signed by Cronulla tomorrow, and i wouldnt give a shit what he says. Stop reading the pissed idiot, and he loses.

we know he's a loser...lets keep him as one.

This time I agree with Melon. We should adopt Bob Carr's policy. No, we shouldn't sell our souls to Macquarie Bank, I mean we treat that person from the Daily Telegraph like he treated his opposition leaders. With respect but we never name him.

[Kramer]

Rothfield had been fed by one from within.
Suffice to say, when one is forced to play out of position, one may take matters into ones own hands.
Some photos appear to be of a professional nature and not shot from a mobile phone.
This is an opinion only and should not be construed as inside information.

[mightyrooster]

Stop reading the ****ing idiot's dumb idiotic dribble.

he could write about the whole Roosters under20s team being signed by Cronulla tomorrow, and i wouldnt give a shit what he says. Stop reading the pissed idiot, and he loses.

we know he's a loser...lets keep him as one.

I know you're right. The only reason I read his blog yesterday was to see just how hypocritical he would get. He amazed even my expectations with the extent of his about face. I know I shouldn't have done it because it just got me so angry like I knew it would. But someone has got to put the questions to him, to support our club, even if it's futile and you know he's not going to bother printing them. Right??

[TheBigFella]

Are Sportsbet taking any on Carney not being naughty ?

Whats that saying about those that dont learn from history ?

yes they are....

The question was "Will Carney still be contracted to the Sharks at the end of 2012?"

The odds were
Yes $1
No $4.

No i'm not joking. it is a fair dinkum deal.

[Guest]

yes they are....

The question was "Will Carney still be contracted to the Sharks at the end of 2012?"

The odds were
Yes $1
No $4.

Interesting odds, wonder what the bookies know.

[Guest]

You could have made the same point with much better taste. I find it very inappropriate.

I find 99% of the shit you write as ridiculous garbage....yet you keep typing away.

[Cockadoodledoo]

I find 99% of the shit you write as ridiculous garbage....yet you keep typing away.

I have no idea who she is but the posts of hers I have read are some of the most well thought out posts I have read here.

[Guest]

Everyone is entitled to an opinion doo...

[John Corey]

Why does Buzz refuse to Post my question in his blog? I have sent it enough times.

Buzz how can you possibly say you are not a hypocrite? As a Roosters fan I hope Carney finally grows up (he is actually 25 though- not a kid) and plays good footy, even if it is with the worst performing team in football, your beloved Sharks. Answer me this Buzz, If Carney had of signed with the Cowboys, or the Dragons etc, instead of your Sharks, would you have been so supportive of him in the media over the last week? Are you man enough to admit that you would not have been? I do not think so.

I'm still waiting for a response.

[Guest]

I find 99% of the shit you write as ridiculous garbage....yet you keep typing away.

Point noted.

I wasn't challenging his opinion, just the way he made it.

This may be an internet forum, but I don't say anything here that I wouldn't say out aloud. People are generally respect the dead, mindful of racism and don't make sexist comments in the real world, but going by posts here many don't apply the same standards to what the write with guise of anonymity. You may think that's okay, but I don't and that's my opinion and sure, I made it known. It's a forum isn't it?

I have no idea who she is but the posts of hers I have read are some of the most well thought out posts I have read here.

Thankyou

[Guest]

Are Sportsbet taking any on Carney not being naughty ?

Whats that saying about those that dont learn from history ?

I did see that they were offering odds if he would last the season out. Something like $1.35 for yes and $4 for no.

[Guest]

Fair point Cindy, but i have no sympathy for filthy junkies. Dead or not.

[rooster_booster]

Fair point Cindy, but i have no sympathy for filthy junkies. Dead or not.

Usually I don't agree with you, but honestly there is no place for political correctness on an internet board. As long as it isn't overtly racist or sexist, fair game.

Good post guy

[bondi-boy]

SIX months ago I wanted Todd Carney sent to jail. Today I'm celebrating his arrival at the Cronulla Sharks. Hypocrite? No way.

Hypocrite? YES way!!!

[Guest]

Phil Rothfield is paid to write that stuff. Much like Julia Gillard is paid to be our prime minister.