Rate the Top 10 current 5/8s

[Guest]

1) Marshall
2) Foran
3) Hayne
4) Carney
5) Maloney
6) Widdop
7) Soward
8) Mullen
9) McCrone
10) Stig

That is my top 10 and I would have Anasta about No11. Then there is a whole bunch of nevilles including Kelly, Graham, J.Miller (who has potential), Burns, Zillman, Norman, Roberts, Keating, Sutton, McGuire, Thompson. I did not include Campese as he has been out injured too long.

Give us your lists and lets compare.

[Guest]

Braith is second after Benji.

And I would have Soward third.

You are being very kind to Carney.

He had a great 2010 but he was hopeless in 2011.

[Guest]

1) Marshall
2) Foran
3) Hayne
4) Carney
5) Maloney
6) Widdop
7) Soward
8) Mullen
9) McCrone
10) Stig

That is my top 10 and I would have Anasta about No11. Then there is a whole bunch of nevilles including Kelly, Graham, J.Miller (who has potential), Burns, Zillman, Norman, Roberts, Keating, Sutton, McGuire, Thompson. I did not include Campese as he has been out injured too long.

Give us your lists and lets compare.

hayne wont play 6; mullen will play 7 not 6; stig wont play first grade (gidley will be 5/8 with boyd coming into the side to play fullback); mccrone wont play 6 and arguably wont even be in first grade (campese to return from injury)

[Guest]

So what is your top 10 guys? I want to see everyones top 10 and see how much we all differ on opinions.

[Guest]

So what is your top 10 guys? I want to see everyones top 10 and see how much we all differ on opinions.

I totally agree with you that Benji is No. 1. A lot of Roosters supporters don't rate him. How you could not rate Benji is beyond me. He is truly one of the most electrifying players I have ever seen. It is really daylight between Benji and the next best 5/8 in my opinion.

[Guest]

I think you have been on the turps again troyh65.

After careful evaluation -

Benji, Gidley, Widdop, Mortimer, Anasta, Soward, Bird, Maloney, Mateo, Carney.

[Guest]

1) Marshall

2) Carney
Campese
Foran
Mullen - really a 5/8th
Pearce - really a 5/8th

7) Maloney
Widdop
Gillett
Soward

[Guest]

I think you have been on the turps again troyh65.

After careful evaluation -

Benji, Gidley, Widdop, Mortimer, Anasta, Soward, Bird, Maloney, Mateo, Carney.

Mortimer??? Surely you are taking the piss? Either that or you've been toking on the crack pipe.

[Guest]

Maloney; plyd/24,pts/206,tkls/534,arm/1904,hu200
Marshall; /// 25 / 211 / 221 / 1978 / 218
K foran; /// 26 / 32 / 414 / 1624 / 236
Widdop; /// 25 / 23 / 484 / 1790 / 197
Graham; /// 24 / 26 / 505 / 1452 / 178

Soward; /// 23 / 157 / 256 / 1159 / 112
Anasta; /// 24 / 91 / 436 / 1041 / 147
Locky; /// 22 / 16 / 375 / 839 / 129 very surprising 2011 stats;for what its worth. IMO i would go; benji, foran, locky, anasta,soward.

[chook 56]

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...TH_WIDDOP_.jpg

[Guest]

Mortimer??? Surely you are taking the piss? Either that or you've been toking on the crack pipe.

No, I am not into the crack pipe.

I like the kid, he played really well the season before and even before he got dumped last season he had some really good games.

These are some stats from some losing games.

9 runs, 69 mts, 3 tackle busts, 22 tackles, 1 line break

12 runs, 57mts, 3 tackle busts, 23 tackles, 1 try assist

5 runs, 50mts, 4 tackles busts, 43 tackles, 2 line breaks, 1 off load.

He didn't play many games and I thought he was unfairly blamed in their run of losses.

[Guest]

1 Marshall
2 Widdop
3 Gidley
4 Foran
5 Carney
6 Mateo
7 Maloney
8 Anasta
9 Mullen
10 Soward

The top 2 for mine are streets ahead of the rest

[Guest]

Maloney; plyd/24,pts/206,tkls/534,arm/1904,hu200
Marshall; /// 25 / 211 / 221 // 1978 / 218
K foran; /// 26 / 32 / 414 // 1624 / 236
Widdop; /// 25 / 23 / 484 // 1790 / 197
Graham; /// 24 / 26 / 505 // 1452 / 178

Soward; /// 23 / 157 / 256 // 1159 / 112
Anasta; /// 24 / 91 / 436 // 1041 / 147
Locky; /// 22 / 16 / 375 // 839 / 129 very surprising 2011 stats;for what its worth. IMO i would go; benji, foran, locky, anasta,soward.

I like the work Anasta does off the ball,organising and motivating players on the field.

[Guest]

1. Marshall
2. Foran
3. Soward
4. Maloney
5. Widdop
6. Mullen
7. Campese
8. Anasta
9. Carney
10. Sutton

[melon....]

Finally I agree with someone knowledgeable in wally. Hoe are you mate stop doing stats.

As for the Nevilles how could you leave out mateo...