Rate the Top 10 current 5/8s

[Cockadoodledoo]

No, I am not into the crack pipe.

I like the kid, he played really well the season before and even before he got dumped last season he had some really good games.

These are some stats from some losing games.

9 runs, 69 mts, 3 tackle busts, 22 tackles, 1 line break

12 runs, 57mts, 3 tackle busts, 23 tackles, 1 try assist

5 runs, 50mts, 4 tackles busts, 43 tackles, 2 line breaks, 1 off load.

He didn't play many games and I thought he was unfairly blamed in their run of losses.

How do they compare to Carney in say 2010?

Salaries have to come into it as well..

[Guest]

Finally I agree with someone knowledgeable in wally. Hoe are you mate stop doing stats.

As for the Nevilles how could you leave out mateo...

Hoe is, Wall-e.

[Guest]

IMO, the best 3 5/8s in the game are NOT aussies....1. Marshall, 2. Foran, 3. Widdop

Pathetic situation for Australian football. Who is the best aussie 5/8....based on last years form and only considering blokes who play 5/8 for their clubs, you would have to say Maloney? A far cry from Lewis, Kenny, Fittler, Daley, Lockyer, etc.

[Guest]

How do they compare to Carney in say 2010?

Salaries have to come into it as well..

I will see what I can come up with for Carney, Anasta, Mortimer when playing 5 / 8 over the last few seasons

I'm not sure about salaries though perhaps someone else can add to it.

I'm not sure who Hoe is.

[Cockadoodledoo]

I will see what I can come up with for Carney, Anasta, Mortimer when playing 5 / 8 over the last few seasons

I'm not sure about salaries though perhaps someone else can add to it.

I'm not sure who Hoe is.

too funny

[Ray Stehr]

If you're fair dinkum you'd have Carney at 1. At his best he's better than Marshall. If he fires up against us he'll tear us to shreds.

[melon....]

I will see what I can come up with for Carney, Anasta, Mortimer when playing 5 / 8 over the last few seasons

I'm not sure about salaries though perhaps someone else can add to it.

I'm not sure who Hoe is.

Try "How". Spell check!

As in "How are you Walter?"

[Guest]

lol I'm slow on the uptake.

[Guest]

As for the Nevilles how could you leave out mateo...

Nah cos I consider mateo a back rower same as that knucklehead glass ya in the face Bird n anyway it was just an opinion n as i have stated before opinions are just like arseholes, everyone has one.

[Guest]

Nah cos I consider mateo a back rower same as that knucklehead glass ya in the face Bird n anyway it was just an opinion n as i have stated before opinions are just like arseholes, everyone has one.

Some bigger than others.

[Guest]

Finally I agree with someone knowledgeable in wally. Hoe are you mate stop doing stats.

As for the Nevilles how could you leave out mateo...

Ahhhhhhhhhh, Wall-e is Wally!!

Welcome back statsman!!

[Guest]

1 Marshall
2 Widdop
3 Gidley
4 Foran
5 Carney
6 Mateo
7 Maloney
8 Anasta
9 Mullen
10 Soward

The top 2 for mine are streets ahead of the rest

My only reservation on Widdop is the quality of the 1, 7 and 9 he plays with. Finch won a comp playing at 6 with that spine.