Who is your favourite Roosters Flop?

[Funky Chicken]

Paul Vautin
Braith Anasta
Willie Brown
Charlie Tonga
Brett Firman
Brett Finch
Mark Riddell
Jordan Tansey
Mark Edmonson
Nick Kouparitsis
Willie Mason
Paul Langmack
Chris Anderson
David "Diamonds" O'Donnell
Paul Green
Dane Sorensen
Kurt Sorensen
Olsen Filapina
Glenn Hall
Jeff Orford
Nat Wood
"Dancing" Dallas Hood
Jacin Sinclair
Julian Bailey
Brendan Hurst
Craig Kimmorley
Justin Holbroook
Steve Skinnon
Ned Catic
Gavin Lester
Luke Dorn
Joel "Iceberg" Monaghan
Josh Lewis
Chris Beattie
Danny Nutley
Brent Grose
Riley "Prowler" Brown

Just to name a few :-)

[Guest]

Jeff Orford

You're kidding right? Orford was the man!
Catic and Monaghan weren't too bad for us either.

[Thirteen]

Jeff Orford was very good for us.
That try v Manly on a Friday night when we beat them 6-0 at Brookvale.....

Sa
Soliola
Williamson
Tezza Hill
Mark Murray

[Thirteen]

Skinny Byrne's lack of speed cost us a premiership so he should be on the list too.

[Thirteen]

I had photos of him on my bedroom wall, next to David Bowie and Jason Donovan..

I always thought you were a bloke!

[Guest]

I had photos of him on my bedroom wall, next to David Bowie and Jason Donovan..

I had the Go-Go's and Kim Wilde. Both suffered structural damage when I matured.

[Funky Chicken]

You're kidding right? Orford was the man!
Catic and Monaghan weren't too bad for us either.

No the man we traded Orford to the Dragons for (Andrew Walker), now he was the man.

Orford reminded me a lot of Perrett, he could do some good things, but boy could he make some dumb mistakes.

But hey that is just my humble opinion.

Monaghan was ok in his last season with us, but prior to that he was pretty ordinary.

As for Catic MEH!!

[Thirteen]

No the man we traded Orford to the Dragons for (Andrew Walker), now he was the man.

Orford reminded me a lot of Perrett, he could do some good things, but boy could he make some dumb mistakes.

But hey that is just my humble opinion.

Monaghan was ok in his last season with us, but prior to that he was pretty ordinary.

As for Catic MEH!!

They both always ran/run from dummy half.
Orford was quicker than Perrett.
I think Perrett is probably the slowest full-time winger that we've had at the club since I've been following in 1987.

[Guest]

I had photos of him on my bedroom wall, next to David Bowie and Jason Donovan..

I had the Go-Go's and Kim Wilde. Both suffered structural damage when I matured.

I had random bitches in the nick.

Mum was cool...." I don't mind tits and fanny, but no pink bits"!

[redwhiteblue]

I always thought you were a bloke!

Really? We have mutual friends so I find that a bit odd but I'll try not to be offended.

[redwhiteblue]

I had the Go-Go's and Kim Wilde. Both suffered structural damage when I matured.

I still listen to The Go Go's and Kim Wilde. They are on my itunes. And Ned Catic was on my Roosters calender from 2004 so someone must have thought highly enough of him to allow him in it.

[novice chook]

I still listen to The Go Go's and Kim Wilde. They are on my itunes. And Ned Catic was on my Roosters calender from 2004 so someone must have thought highly enough of him to allow him in it.

I still listen to them as well RWB. I am a sucker for 80s music. I should be embarrased to name some of the songs I downloaded from iTunes over the weekend. Most of them one hit wonders.

And is your calendar the 16 month calendar that covered 04 and 05? Because if it is I just foraged it out of my bottom desk draw at the office (yes I have kept it all this time, over many moves) and Ned's definitely there as Mr November 2005.

It's a real trip down memory lane looking through it again.

One of my fave photos I've taken over the years is one a friend and I had taken with our Ned in either the 03 or 04 annual dinner. A really nice bloke.

And for the record, the Wanka Mason would have to go down as my top flop, although definitely not a fave of mine (thought I'd best get back on topic).

NC

[Guest]

Ned Catic was not a flop and he would walk in to the current team!

Brett Finch and Braith Anasta are two of the biggest duds to ever grace this great club but none will top Paul Vautin.

[Guest]

!

Brett Finch and Braith Anasta are two of the biggest duds to ever grace this great club but none will top Paul Vautin.

Finch was never mythologised as the saviour, the next Freddy.
Finch was never payed Marquee $$$$$$$$$$.
Finch was never handed the captaincy.
When Finch was bad he was dropped.
When he was really bad he was shown the door.
Finch never publicised contract negotiations mid season in a bid to leverage public outrage against the club.
Finch never won the wooden spoon.
Finch never kept out more talented players from his position.
Finch never had a canine tatoo.

[Guest]

Wow , where do I start?

In recent times probably :

Bwaiff, or Mason.(Value $$$$$$)

Kouparitsas, Riddell (Just crap).

Last 20 years,

Probably Vaughtin. He still despises our club. I remember in that footy show grandfinal episode when the rooster chant went up and todd, braith and mitchell came to the stage, he said something like: "Wasn't much of that in the 90s".I've never seen a more celebrated imbecile than that man.