JWH Charged

[Chook2]

Your stretching it there to say the Tigers would have won had Keary played half / Manu 5/8 and Suaalii at centre - it's not fantasy league.

Wooden spoon name written all over it - yeh sure - gees no chance of that happening

Walker was dropped for a reason as he was playing poorly as the KPI's show - it wasn't going to be long term - the injury prevented an earlier return to NRL.

No problem with Manu at 5/8 based on other performances when he played 5/8 - vs Dragons last year which was the start of the 8 game winning streak - I recall how folk on here wanted him retained as 5/8 in place of Keary who was out that game.

Suaalii at centre was not a poor call either especially based on what centres were available for possible selection - Billy Smith and Paul Momirovski were unavailable - noting the site went into melt down when either Allan or the Hutchinator played centre.

In hind site Coach Robinson's mistake was not playing the Hutchinator at half when Walkers injury prevented a return to NRL.

Walker still has a lot to work on to become an established 7 - Structure , Game Management and kicking game is not NRL standard at this stage

Walkers dropping was down right stupidity
the others it wasn’t the try to see if it will work, it’s that’s is didn’t and they were kept there for months reducing their impact on the team and weakening the positions they should have been in
fair enough give things a go but learn when you have made a mistake and move on

hutch was horrible for most games bar 1 or 2 for walker so no I don’t agree there that he should have been the replacement for walker
walker should never have been dropped in the first place