A win for the true believers, and egg on the face of the perpetually negative fans

[Batemans Bay Rooster]

Yes a very good win against the odds and a good side in a hostile environment… but this is also a silly post… you just can’t help yourself Steakface

Robbo will get a pat on the back next week when we beat the Storm… that will be par for the course… beat Penrith and make the GF after that then he will have done his job to a very good level

All this talk about people having eggs on their face for criticising the coach this year? Well he’s had egg all over his face since Round 1… just look at Walker last night… why the f*ck would anyone ever drop him but still play Hutchinson in the side?

Show some dignity… having to play sudden death football five weeks out from the finals with the best list in league is nothing to applaud… getting the side to where it should be will earn the plaudits

your weakest ever post Les Miserables. Every win we have, you sound like more of a dribbler..."This win proves nothing!!! we need to do blah blah farkin blah!!!"

You're just a fool. And a miserable one at that.

[King Salvo]

Not even close??? Hahahahahah come on..
At full strength we are equal to both Brisbane and Penrith when it comes to team lists,no question..

Not the best Squad

Full Strength you say - tell me again when the Roosters had a full strength squad this season ?

Round 1 for instance the following players were unavailable from the 28 player squad

• Sitili
• Billy Smith
• Crichton
• Watson
• Toia
• Manu
• Momirvovski

Your dislike of Coach Robinson clouds your judgement as it does Les Tricolores, Water Boy, and On the Nose, whom I think are the same poster with different profiles as they say the same things

[Lydon]

Not the best Squad

Full Strength you say - tell me again when the Roosters had a full strength squad this season ?

Round 1 for instance the following players were unavailable from the 28 player squad

• Sitili
• Billy Smith
• Crichton
• Watson
• Toia
• Manu
• Momirvovski

Your dislike of Coach Robinson clouds your judgement as it does Les Tricolores, Water Boy, and On the Nose, whom I think are the same poster with different profiles as they say the same things

If you read the original post,the argument is based on our team list not being anywhere close to Brisbane or Penrith this year..
So that opinion is based on the team at full strength as no timeline or Round was given..

Your dislike of Sam Walker and preference to have Hutchison as our halfback has indeed made you look like an absolute fool hahahah

I remember you pushing the same agenda when Lachlan Lam was playing..

It must hurt you to see Sammy developing into a potential superstar of the game,whilst your favourites are always being moved on to other Clubs!

[Les Tricolores]

You keep harping on about this 'best list in the league' stuff like it's true. We're not even close to the Panthers or Broncos

There’s a difference between talent and performance… because you should know the sum of the parts doesn’t necessarily equal the whole… sometimes it’s less… sometimes it’s more

Watching the Knights go for 10 in a row… this is the same lineup that was dead in the water earlier in the year… so what’s the difference now?

Panthers are a very good team… great system/great coach… but they’re not a super squad anymore… their core has lost 3 out of the last 4 Origin series… so it’s hardly generational

Broncs have a lot of talent for sure… but it’s still young and raw

We’ve got the best list… that was the case in preseason… that’s the case now… it’s a widely held opinion… everywhere except the Chookpen that is… I’m not sure what the denial here is about but I find it very strange… and suggests a very weird allegiance that is very much misplaced

[Rooster1908]

There’s a difference between talent and performance… because you should know the sum of the parts doesn’t necessarily equal the whole… sometimes it’s less… sometimes it’s more

Watching the Knights go for 10 in a row… this is the same lineup that was dead in the water earlier in the year… so what’s the difference now?

Panthers are a very good team… great system/great coach… but they’re not a super squad anymore… their core has lost 3 out of the last 4 Origin series… so it’s hardly generational

Broncs have a lot of talent for sure… but it’s still young and raw

We’ve got the best list… that was the case in preseason… that’s the case now… it’s a widely held opinion… everywhere except the Chookpen that is… I’m not sure what the denial here is about but I find it very strange… and suggests a very weird allegiance that is very much misplaced

Give it up Les . Just because he likes of Fitler , Gould, Johns and co predicted us the be grand finalist . Just because we were favorites . Surely that doesn't mean we had a top squad

[Les Tricolores]

your weakest ever post Les Miserables. Every win we have, you sound like more of a dribbler..."This win proves nothing!!! we need to do blah blah farkin blah!!!"

You're just a fool. And a miserable one at that.

Well I’m obviously not a fool… as you’ve attested yourself… so are you bipolar?

I do hate to say it but I see now that you are indeed the most miserable prick here… wearing your pants on your head after we beat the Bulldogs by 2 while spitting curses at anyone who dare not kiss Robbo’s arsehole like you?

Clearly there is not much satisfaction in your life Mrs Robinson

[King Salvo]

If you read the original post,the argument is based on our team list not being anywhere close to Brisbane or Penrith this year..
So that opinion is based on the team at full strength as no timeline or Round was given..

Your dislike of Sam Walker and preference to have Hutchison as our halfback has indeed made you look like an absolute fool hahahah

I remember you pushing the same agenda when Lachlan Lam was playing..

It must hurt you to see Sammy developing into a potential superstar of the game,whilst your favourites are always being moved on to other Clubs!

The argument you and others put up that it's supposedly the best squad is irrelevant in any case when a host of players are unavailable throughout the season.

I back the Coaching Staff and players 100% through thick and thin.

The Hutchnator deserves some praise, though, for 2021 , 2022 and even this season, as the winning streak started when he was selected at 7.

In hind site it was a mistake by Coach Robinson not to play the Hutchinator at 7 when Walker's injury became long term.

Last night the attack wasn't flowing, which is a continuing issue with neither Walker nor Keary being organising halves, and this then has a flow-on effect with Tedesco having to do more for an example

Until that is sorted there will always be question marks over the Keary and Walker Combination.

That's not knocking Walker at all; it's just the facts that he has things to work on in his game - Structure . Game management , Kicking game and D for an example.

Too late for Keary to be turned into an organising / game management type half.

Best to let Walker develop at his own pace and not put labels and expectations on him.

The term superstar is used way too often - Phil Blake was rated this and it didn't pan out that way for him.

Lachlan Lam was a good player in my view and not the only one to think or say this.

[SupermanSupportsEasts4Eva]

Great defensive effort last night. There is no stats for determination and guts which was that second half.

[Les Tricolores]

Give it up Les . Just because he likes of Fitler , Gould, Johns and co predicted us the be grand finalist . Just because we were favorites . Surely that doesn't mean we had a top squad

Best squad in league bar none… and it will likely be the same next year… Robbo better make the most of it because Teddy is not going to be here forever

[Rooster1908]

Best squad in league bar none… and it will likely be the same next year… Robbo better make the most of it because Teddy is not going to be here forever

If knights loose can we get Some Young early.He is playing well for the Knights

[King Salvo]

Give it up Les . Just because he likes of Fitler , Gould, Johns and co predicted us the be grand finalist . Just because we were favorites . Surely that doesn't mean we had a top squad

Was this opinion based on all players being available and not having main squad players miss the amount of games they did and have this season.

[King Salvo]

Best squad in league bar none… and it will likely be the same next year… Robbo better make the most of it because Teddy is not going to be here forever

Nonsense give up your anti Coach Robinson crusade and get on board the Robbo Express

[Rooster1908]

Was this opinion based on all players being available and not having main squad players miss the amount of games they did and have this season.

Well you would need to ask the ones who gave the opinion I reckon

[Batemans Bay Rooster]

Best squad in league bar none… and it will likely be the same next year… Robbo better make the most of it because Teddy is not going to be here forever

Your madness knows no bounds.

[BTRD]

We have a fantastic squad; I truly believe this.

It is time to beat Melbourne. And we will.