If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Dont cave in to the woke PC brigade.
Be you, be courageous, don't be afraid to speak your mind and express your beliefs in a reasonable manner.
Of course if people are belligerent or derogatory then that's another matter however, we shouldn't have to hesitate and consider if what we're about to say will offend precious petals.
Interesting - So we will have more Archie Bunker types frequenting the site than we do now
I think it’s just about respect, if you told me I was pronouncing your name wrong and told me how to pronounce your name I would do my best to try and pronounce it that way.
True however, I believe some commentators feel they'll be unfairly scrutinised if they don't get it right.
Rabbits Warren would often get it wrong despite best efforts and just get on with it without explanation or apology.
It's not hard to find out how to pronounce someone's name correctly, though. Obviously, folk don't see the comments from family members of the players on NSWRL TV when commentators pronounce the players names incorrectly.
You may not care how your name is pronounced or think it's a big deal, but people do, as, after all, it's their family's history.
To say it's PC based is ridiculous
My Wife's Maidan name was Sharapova as in Maria Sharapova
It's pronounced Sha - Ruh - Pow - Vuh not Shara - Pova
The Pow is pronounced as Poe
Thus Maria Sharapova is pronounced as - muh·ree·uh sha·ruh·pow·vuh
This pronunciation saga is most likely a product of the good ship inclusivity as it sails the sea of exclusivity. I have spent most of my life working and living abroad. In every country my name was pronounced very differently to how it is here. I found that slightly entertaining and never ever insulting or uncomfortable. I never once expected others to adopt an Australian accent when conversing with me, because that would have been selfish, misguided and arrogant to do so. When in Rome, and all that.
I highly doubt that the driving force behind this fad is from the players that carry Oceanian names. It is probably the media that is the main instigator, confusing natural cultural pride with the pedantic crossing of t's and dotting of i's. Let's Call the Whole Thing Off (You Say Tomato, I Say Tomato).
True however, I believe some commentators feel they'll be unfairly scrutinised if they don't get it right.
Rabbits Warren would often get it wrong despite best efforts and just get on with it without explanation or apology.
Oh for sure but there’s 5% of idiots in every single argument. Like you said intent matters, people are going to get it wrong from time to time and we shouldn’t ever make anything more of it than that.
I just imagine as a family, as a father seeing your son run out onto the NRL field and hearing your family name below out over the TV must be one of the proudest and most fulfilling moments anyone can feel so there’s more reasons than just PC culture to get it right. Out of respect for those families and the individuals a far more compelling argument for mine.
It's not hard to find out how to pronounce someone's name correctly, though. Obviously, folk don't see the comments from family members of the players on NSWRL TV when commentators pronounce the players names incorrectly.
You may not care how your name is pronounced or think it's a big deal, but people do, as, after all, it's their family's history.
To say it's PC based is ridiculous
My Wife's Maidan name was Sharapova as in Maria Sharapova
It's pronounced Sha - Ruh - Pow - Vuh not Shara - Pova
The Pow is pronounced as Poe
Thus Maria Sharapova is pronounced as - muh·ree·uh sha·ruh·pow·vuh
We can tell with some of the horrendous things you let go around here
We do our best to moderate.
The thing i find is those who whine are often themselves culprits or antagonists.
Swings and roundabouts......
If you're unhappy or disillusioned my friend there's other more feral and horrendous platforms for you to frequent like reddit or leagueunlimited. Trust me....they make our forum seem tame and friendly.
Anyway, nobody's twisting your arm to tune-in champ!
This pronunciation saga is most likely a product of the good ship inclusivity as it sails the sea of exclusivity. I have spent most of my life working and living abroad. In every country my name was pronounced very differently to how it is here. I found that slightly entertaining and never ever insulting or uncomfortable. I never once expected others to adopt an Australian accent when conversing with me, because that would have been selfish, misguided and arrogant to do so. When in Rome, and all that.
I highly doubt that the driving force behind this fad is from the players that carry Oceanian names. It is probably the media that is the main instigator, confusing natural cultural pride with the pedantic crossing of t's and dotting of i's. Let's Call the Whole Thing Off (You Say Tomato, I Say Tomato).
It's a piss take on the calibration/pronunciation of Islanders surnames......political correctness gone crazy IMO.
I could be mistaken but Josh Papalii must have started the correctness about 3 years ago bc up until then his surname was always simply pronounced Papa-lee.
Then all of a sudden I noticed the commentators pronouncing it Papa-lee-ee.....really?
I just find it pedantic.
There's no offence if someone mispronounces a name or surname if they're genuinely have a go and not doing it deliberately.
I wish I had a dollar for every time my surname was pronounced or said in dozens of different ways.
Toughen up people FFS.
I think it was Charnze Nicoll-Klokstad.
I still can’t work out how your get ‘Klookstar’ from it?
Dont cave in to the woke PC brigade.
Be you, be courageous, don't be afraid to speak your mind and express your beliefs in a reasonable manner.
Of course if people are belligerent or derogatory then that's another matter however, we shouldn't have to hesitate and consider if what we're about to say will offend precious petals.
Mate, no joke, this is the post of the year and why you are the most respected Mod on this site.
It's not hard to find out how to pronounce someone's name correctly, though. Obviously, folk don't see the comments from family members of the players on NSWRL TV when commentators pronounce the players names incorrectly.
You may not care how your name is pronounced or think it's a big deal, but people do, as, after all, it's their family's history.
To say it's PC based is ridiculous
My Wife's Maidan name was Sharapova as in Maria Sharapova
It's pronounced Sha - Ruh - Pow - Vuh not Shara - Pova
The Pow is pronounced as Poe
Thus Maria Sharapova is pronounced as - muh·ree·uh sha·ruh·pow·vuh
Comment