Joe for Origen?

[Bates]

lol.

[The Marshall]

I can safely say I didn’t see this coming
suaali being talked about as nsw winger
hard to compare his form but he has been poor for us at centre and I don’t think will be on the wing for the roosters once smith is back and behind young and toops for wing but will be for nsw wtf?
he will offer a good hit up option, is tall but still yet to see him dominate in the air, but will get burnt on the outside coming up against Cobbo or Coates

I know we have had different opinions on this one. I do think he is very strong on the wing and consistent. Definitely horrible in the centres. Young is brilliant but sometimes horrible as well. I am not so sure it’s that clear cut.

[milanja]

you realised he's in centre filling in for BS/Jenning? his main role is winger

If Jo was hanging around in league next year, I’d have no problem him playing origin.

[Bansai Pipeline]

This is a reputation pick if ever there was one.

His from has never lived up to the hype.

[Vasco]

I reckon he was pretty good at right centre last week. He might actually be ready to play in this position.

It's a shame he can't renege on his rugby contract and play right centre next year.

[Chook2]

Still a player on $750k he is on the same money as Manu but brings less value then toops, young and b smith! B smith is on $250k! On $750k you should be able to fill all backline positions but this makes him an expensive winger
He is not even on our best two wingers
it’s a desperation pick from the blues wanting to rely on his yardage and toigh carries

[Chook2]

I know we have had different opinions on this one. I do think he is very strong on the wing and consistent. Definitely horrible in the centres. Young is brilliant but sometimes horrible as well. I am not so sure it’s that clear cut.

Young and suaali can both make errors but at least young can score tries, break tackles and line breaks and has speed
that makes up for the odd error unlike suaali who has a very lack of any X factor

[Thirteen]

Crichton will be right edge centre, I wouldn’t be looking at him as a winger..

Also known as centre.

[QWERTY]

Remember last year when smith came back and was the roosters best player on the field Many times
while Suaali continually fails to add anything in attack on the left centre and a liability in defence
everyone said this about Watson until he came back this year and has been out best player

People said this about Watson?

[Chook2]

People said this about Watson?

Many wanted Watson gone last year when he wasn’t on the field and he has been our best player this year
but writing off Billy smith who came back last year and was our best at the end of last year

[SupermanSupportsEasts4Eva]

Agree with most. Suaalii shouldn't be in the mix on form.

Injuries are hurting NSW even before origin has stated. This would be my backline based on current injuries, form and reputation.

1. Teddy
2. T'oo
3. Stephen Chricton
4. Latrine (love him or hate him, he is made for origin, and Qld won't want him there)
5. Edwards (chances are Teddy gets a head knock)
6. Luai
7. Hynes

14. Burton

[OMR]

Still a player on $750k he is on the same money as Manu but brings less value then toops, young and b smith! B smith is on $250k! On $750k you should be able to fill all backline positions but this makes him an expensive winger
He is not even on our best two wingers
it’s a desperation pick from the blues wanting to rely on his yardage and toigh carries

If Madge wants to win the game and the series then he will need the tough carries from the back and JS is very good at it.

[Rooster_6]

Also known as centre.

I would hate to offend someone with a Crichton surname without specifying exact position.

[Bates]

This is a reputation pick if ever there was one.

His from has never lived up to the hype.

I was thinking profile pick if true.

[mightyrooster]

What is origen?