Is SBW really progress or another mistake?

[John Corey]

We just had 40 points put on us by an NYC team and you guys are questioning SBW's signing???????????

I'd eat a yard of his shit right now and complain if it was an inch short if it meant getting him here next week!

LMAO. I ....sort of agree

[Guest]

I look at yesterdays game and i question whether SBW would of made an iota of difference. Every time our wide players got the ball, they had no space to operate in. Our halves halved (hehe) the space for our wide men the whole game.

No doubt, under a solid coaching structure, SBW would be a gamebreaker. However, in yesterdays conditions he would of failed to make a dent. Look at Inglis with no space last year - bubkus. Great players still need space to operate.

Whatever money is going to SBW, i'd rather it go toward a coach like Bellamy. He will get the kids firing as well as recruit nuffs for peanuts who will doa good job filling in.

[Guest]

It's not just SBW's ability to take into account here.

We have a good crop of youngsters coming through and they will all grow a foot taller knowing they're running out next to Sonny Bill every week.

[stephenj]

i watched sbw closely in the all blacks ireland test, he really is a handfull for any opposition, but hes no monster!

[Guest]

It's not just SBW's ability to take into account here.

We have a good crop of youngsters coming through and they will all grow a foot taller knowing they're running out next to Sonny Bill every week.

How many weeks will that effect last for ?

What if SBW does not make an impact many expect due to our team being in dissaray each time they are on the field ?

I'd love SBW at the Roosters, but in the current conditions, he would just be another problem (how long will it take him to start taking it to the media ?)

[Guest]

i watched sbw closely in the all blacks ireland test, he really is a handfull for any opposition, but hes no monster!

Stephen, lets remember who he is playing with as well.


However, it is a great compliment to say that he does not look out of place in that team.

[FAZ]

I would vote YES for SBW to come to our club. We need a match winner, a player with an x-factor.
Would we knock back a player like Hayne, Slater, Inglis, DCE, Foran, Carney (again) , Gallen or Tamou ????????

[Guest]

It's not just SBW's ability to take into account here.

We have a good crop of youngsters coming through and they will all grow a foot taller knowing they're running out next to Sonny Bill every week.

How many weeks will that effect last for ?

What if SBW does not make an impact many expect due to our team being in dissaray each time they are on the field ?

I'd love SBW at the Roosters, but in the current conditions, he would just be another problem (how long will it take him to start taking it to the media ?)

He'll have an impact before he even pulls on a red, white and blue jersey imo.

The bloke is a serious professional and just the way he trains will open the younger boys eyes up a bit.

[ROC181]

How many weeks will that effect last for ?

What if SBW does not make an impact many expect due to our team being in dissaray each time they are on the field ?

I'd love SBW at the Roosters, but in the current conditions, he would just be another problem (how long will it take him to start taking it to the media ?)

26 rounds + finals

[novice chook]

Everyone keeps saying that Scummy Bill is a "winner" but apart from a premiership in 04 and a very minor bit part in the NZ world cup win, what has he actually won, apart from a few very dubious boxing contests??

Like most players he looks good when he has quality players around him, as he did in 2004 and when he plays for NZ. But if he comes to the Roosters, he won't have that luxury.

I suspect he will crash and burn at the Chooks, and if Nick P has his way, I have no doubt we will witness the carnage.

Like all other other overpriced Scumdog imports, he will disappoint.

NC

[Guest]

Everyone keeps saying that Scummy Bill is a "winner" but apart from a premiership in 04 and a very minor bit part in the NZ world cup win, what has he actually won, apart from a few very dubious boxing contests??

Like most players he looks good when he has quality players around him, as he did in 2004 and when he plays for NZ. But if he comes to the Roosters, he won't have that luxury.

I suspect he will crash and burn at the Chooks, and if Nick P has his way, I have no doubt we will witness the carnage.

Like all other other overpriced Scumdog imports, he will disappoint.

NC

So whats your solution to becoming a competitive team??
Oh thats right the youth policy its fine we'll keep rebukding like weve been saying for years.
Our youth sont save us look at us in 02. We bought Fitzy and Fittler and it was successful.
Have fun rebuilding

[Guest]

So whats your solution to becoming a competitive team??
Oh thats right the youth policy its fine we'll keep rebukding like weve been saying for years.
Our youth sont save us look at us in 02. We bought Fitzy and Fittler and it was successful.
Have fun rebuilding

Time to put some more coins in your spell checker again goat!

[Guest]

Time to put some more coins in your spell checker again goat!

Ipad spell check is annoying unlike my Toshiba.
If I type in NRL. com then it cums up as nil.
And whats wrong wit goat

[Guest]

Ipad spell check is annoying unlike my Toshiba.
If I type in NRL. com then it cums up as nil.
And whats wrong wit goat

I like goat, especially in a curry!

[Guest]

I like goat, especially in a curry!

Ilike Indian Butter Chicken.
Never heard of goat curry.
Are you Indian??????
They invented The number zero which is equivalent to your IQ