Cock fight delight

[rented tracksuit]

lol you called them a disgrace last week.

I can't keep up.

He wasn’t wrong tho.

[Eggspert]

You can't seriously call out the team and coach as being hopeless and clueless one week and then change your tune a week later.

You serious? Off course you can.

it's called a subjective view on what you see at the time....not just blind love or hate one total way.

Have you ever had a shocker or been bad at something one week & then improved or made it better a week later......you ever changed your view on anything or just blindly followed one way?

[Rooster_6]

He wasn’t wrong tho.

Robbo doesn’t offer anything and needs to be sacked?

On tonight’s evidence Robbo just keeps improving these kids… they’re a young team who have struggled to close off the last 20 minutes of their last 3 games. Tonight they showed that improvement and maturity.

They’re hardly a disgrace but if you agree then don’t backtrack.

[On the Nose]

You can't seriously call out the team and coach as being hopeless and clueless one week and then change your tune a week later.

A headless chook could see how hopeless the team played against the Rabbitohs, and big reason for the defeat, the coaches' persistence with a weak halves pairing. The only person who doesn't change their opinion on here week to week is King Salvo, and he's a bore, who does not react to the emotion of a big win, or big loss for that matter.

[BTRD]

We should of belted Souths in the second half last week.

We MUST beat Penrith next week - no excuses.

[Eggspert]

Robbo doesn’t offer anything and needs to be sacked?

On tonight’s evidence Robbo just keeps improving these kids… they’re a young team who have struggled to close off the last 20 minutes of their last 3 games. Tonight they showed that improvement and maturity.

They’re hardly a disgrace but if you agree then don’t backtrack.

Your a real goose....very convenient of you to take a whole thread/ post out of context....you take a snippet of my post to try highlight a single issue

The disgrace comment was on the Souffs debacle.

My stance on Robbo has always been consistent in the fact his coaching is in decline & he has been here too long & we will never win another premiership under him......what's yours fence sitter? Only know how to gloat after a .one win & can't see a bigger picture.

Wow...Robbo's got them to play for a full 80 for a 2-4 record so far....stirring stuff.

[Eggspert]

A headless chook could see how hopeless the team played against the Rabbitohs, and big reason for the defeat, the coaches' persistence with a weak halves pairing. The only person who doesn't change their opinion on here week to week is King Salvo, and he's a bore, who does not react to the emotion of a big win, or big loss for that matter.

Spot on.

The team lost 3 winnable games because it was clear as day that Townsend wasn't up to it & after dropping him suddenly Robbo is a genius...lol

[Rooster_6]

Your a real goose....very convenient of you to take a whole thread/ post out of context....you take a snippet of my post to try highlight a single issue

The disgrace comment was on the Souffs debacle.

My stance on Robbo has always been consistent in the fact his coaching is in decline & he has been here too long & we will never win another premiership under him......what's yours fence sitter? Only know how to gloat after a .one win & can't see a bigger picture.

Wow...Robbo's got them to play for a full 80 for a 2-4 record so far....stirring stuff.

I’ve been very clear on the fact that I think Robinson is the right man for the job

He just got a bunch of kids up to beat one of the most stacked rosters in the comp and you want to limit that achievement “he got them to play for a full 80”.

[Rooster_6]

A headless chook could see how hopeless the team played against the Rabbitohs, and big reason for the defeat, the coaches' persistence with a weak halves pairing. The only person who doesn't change their opinion on here week to week is King Salvo, and he's a bore, who does not react to the emotion of a big win, or big loss for that matter.

That’s the thing, they weren’t hopeless their defensive effort was immense. 42 tackles inside the 20 the Rabbitohs had in the first half and we went in down only 8-6.

Sure we paid for that in the end with fatigue and didn’t have the class to overcome that fatigue but plenty on here saw the effort and knew how close we were. So this week doesn’t come as a massive surprise unless you’re reacting emotionally to the results rather than the performance.

[Eggspert]

I’ve been very clear on the fact that I think Robinson is the right man for the job

He just got a bunch of kids up to beat one of the most stacked rosters in the comp and you want to limit that achievement “he got them to play for a full 80”.

'Right man for the job" You've really gone out on a limb there.

For how long? This year, next 2, 5, 10yrs? Job for life?

Whats going to be acceptable to extend his role from currently 13yrs to 15 18 or 20....being a consistent top 4, top 8 or fringe top 8 team.

These feel good wins are great but imo i can see the bigger picture & believe that he will never get back to his glory days of 2013-2019.

The last 6yrs has shown that...its just life...everything has an expiry.


i

[Bates]

Skyrockets in flight.
Cock fight delight.

[HunchoRooster]

A team performance can definitely be branded disgraceful and then be praised the following week. It’s part of elite sport where everything is results oriented. So many deficiencies in last weeks performance and it’s clear that Robbo agreed as he made the necessary changes and we sure improvement last night, justifying his decisions.

It is frustrating that it was so obvious Townsend wasn’t up to the task basically from Rd1 and it took him 5 weeks to get dropped but we can only look forward. The change has been made and we back the club and the continuous development of the young blokes this season. Still not sure we make the 8 but I’d much rather lose games or see our young guys make errors but gain vital experience, then see a passenger come for a swansong and stifle the potential of the side.

Onwards from here. Huge task next week. Riff will be desperate and they’ve been so poor I can’t see them getting any worse, only way is up for them and we need to be prepared for it.

[Rooster_6]

A team performance can definitely be branded disgraceful and then be praised the following week.

Sure it can, free speech.

But it could also just be a wrong opinion… something worth considering.

[HunchoRooster]

Sure it can, free speech.

But it could also just be a wrong opinion… something worth considering.

Not making it about free speech, that goes without saying. I’m saying it can be objectively correct. An example would be the Titans doing it in the reverse order. They were clinical against us the other week and have been nothing short of pathetic in their 2 games since.

I think Robinson would’ve agreed with the assessment on how poor we were last week at closing the game out hence why he made the changes that I freely admitted I didn’t think he would make, so credit where it’s due.

I don’t think Robinson is a disgrace, I still back him to get the best out of these young players but I do believe it’s fair to question him when things go array. Or even when they go well, Ie Marky Mark should’ve been in the side last night in lieu of Young. I hope was more the fact he hadn’t trained and wasn’t 100% as opposed to a tactical call.

[Rooster_6]

'Right man for the job" You've really gone out on a limb there.

For how long? This year, next 2, 5, 10yrs? Job for life?

Whats going to be acceptable to extend his role from currently 13yrs to 15 18 or 20....being a consistent top 4, top 8 or fringe top 8 team.

These feel good wins are great but imo i can see the bigger picture & believe that he will never get back to his glory days of 2013-2019.

The last 6yrs has shown that...it’s just life...everything has an expiry.

I’m more than happy with his current contract that runs until 2028.

Problem is you want to sensationalise everything and you want absolutes, I can’t give you that, not around futures.

This year the expectation has to be the growth of key talent that will see us back competing for the top 4 next year. The final ladder position is less relevant to me to the overall objective of rebuilding this roster.