Roosters player ratings

[Guest]

1. Anthony Minichiello: 3.5. Safe under the high ball, one error i think and finally he knows how bwaif feels. 3 errors from mini.
2. BJ Leilua: 3. Definitely would have been at least a 5 if it wasnt for his errors. Okay game, 4 tackle breaks and try
3. Mitchell Aubusson: 3.5. Actually had one of his better games today, but 3 errors.
4. Shaun Kenny-Dowall: 5.5. One of our best players, a try, 6 tackle breaks, a line break and a linebreak assist.
5. TauTau Moga: 2. Shocker.
14. Daniel Mortimer : 4. Not a good game, but better than Anasta.
7. Mitchell Pearce: 4. Brain explosions stuffed up his game, cannot kick a fieldgoal for his life, but his kicking game was okay today (I thought)
8. Jared-Waerea Hargreaves: 3.5. Needs better discipine, gave away 3 penalties and was average today (I thought)
9. Jake Friend: 7. I thought he had a good game today, his short side plays are starting to work
10. Martin Kennedy: 3.5. Once again, average today. I really think he will improve though, we just need to stick with him. At least no errors today.
11. Aidan Guerra: 6.5. Good game today, looked deadly with the ball. Nice try aswell.
12. Boyd Cordner: 5.5. Also a good game. Nice hits in defence, punishing.
13. Frank-Paul Nuuasala: 4. Where was he today? Didnt really notice him.

15. Tinirau Arona: 4.5. One of his better games this season, actually has good ball skills
16. Lama Tasi: 5. Average game, like our other forwards today.
17. Mose Masoe: 3.5. Has 1 or 2 good runs and then looks really tired.
18. Nafe Seluini: 5.5. This guy is the next (better) Anthony Mitchell. Fast but very short

[Guest]

1. Anthony Minichiello: 3.5. Safe under the high ball, one error i think and finally he knows how bwaif feels. 3 errors from mini.
2. BJ Leilua: 3. Definitely would have been at least a 5 if it wasnt for his errors. Okay game, 4 tackle breaks and try
3. Mitchell Aubusson: 3.5. Actually had one of his better games today, but 3 errors.
4. Shaun Kenny-Dowall: 5.5. One of our best players, a try, 6 tackle breaks, a line break and a linebreak assist.
5. TauTau Moga: 2. Shocker.
14. Daniel Mortimer : 4. Not a good game, but better than Anasta.
7. Mitchell Pearce: 4. Brain explosions stuffed up his game, cannot kick a fieldgoal for his life, but his kicking game was okay today (I thought)
8. Jared-Waerea Hargreaves: 3.5. Needs better discipine, gave away 3 penalties and was average today (I thought)
9. Jake Friend: 7. I thought he had a good game today, his short side plays are starting to work
10. Martin Kennedy: 3.5. Once again, average today. I really think he will improve though, we just need to stick with him. At least no errors today.
11. Aidan Guerra: 6.5. Good game today, looked deadly with the ball. Nice try aswell.
12. Boyd Cordner: 5.5. Also a good game. Nice hits in defence, punishing.
13. Frank-Paul Nuuasala: 4. Where was he today? Didnt really notice him.

15. Tinirau Arona: 4.5. One of his better games this season, actually has good ball skills
16. Lama Tasi: 5. Average game, like our other forwards today.
17. Mose Masoe: 3.5. Has 1 or 2 good runs and then looks really tired.
18. Nafe Seluini: 5.5. This guy is the next (better) Anthony Mitchell. Fast but very short

No, short side plays having been killing us all year!

[Guest]

Anything over 1 for Mini and Aubbo is criminal.

[Guest]

i just want to say Pearce is a dumb footballer.
He has an option to set up a try in the first half of extra time, then has a brain explosion and tries a field goal
when the defence has ran up on him.

Way overrated, we dont need him he is not quality...

[Guest]

No, short side plays having been killing us all year!

yes they have, but they worked today,

[Guest]

Does anyone here think size determines your performance?
Say that to Bowen, Campbell, Shillington, Perret, Shillington, N.Friend, Hohaia, Soward, Hurrell and Inglis who r all short blokes

Seluini looked the goods but people bag him because he's short.

[Salvatori Grubber]

Mrihk

[The Brain]

you imposter- who is this Brian Smiths bro ?

[Guest]

you imposter- who is this Brian Smiths bro ?

why?

[rooster_booster]

Dude a much more experienced Chookpenner (The Brain) does the player ratings. Plus you gave no insight into their performances. Maybe wait a bit longer than 4 months of being a member before you post stuff like this.

[Guest]

pffft its in my opinion, if you dont like it dont read it..

[kurtsherlock6]

Dude a much more experienced Chookpenner (The Brain) does the player ratings. Plus you gave no insight into their performances. Maybe wait a bit longer than 4 months of being a member before you post stuff like this.

Why? Its an open forum isnt it?

Besides, it makes more sense than the other jibberish posted by the "more experienced chookpenner".

[ism22]

Does anyone here think size determines your performance?
Say that to Bowen, Campbell, Shillington, Perret, Shillington, N.Friend, Hohaia, Soward, Hurrell and Inglis who r all short blokes

Seluini looked the goods but people bag him because he's short.

Agreed...
Anecdote but back in high school my school put 5 BIIIG 20+ year old islanders into our team all on scholarship.

They all played 1sts and got DOMINATED by more mobile/smarter teams. Our 2nds were undefeated coz we had all the school's smaller but smarter players.

[Guest]

Agreed...
Anecdote but back in high school my school put 5 BIIIG 20+ year old islanders into our team all on scholarship.

They all played 1sts and got DOMINATED by more mobile/smarter teams. Our 2nds were undefeated coz we had all the school's smaller but smarter players.

I never said he was too small for FG because he isnt, size doesnt matter. i just said he was small!

[rooster_booster]

Why? Its an open forum isnt it?

Besides, it makes more sense than the other jibberish posted by the "more experienced chookpenner".

Its statements like that.

I only come here because I am a Roosters fan but most of the stuff posted on this forum is embarrassing, such as this guys player ratings. I yearn for a place where we can have insightful and passionate discussion about the Roosters but instead, Lemon_Goat and his cronies serve up drivel like this. Not only are his ratings way off, his analysis of the players are confusing at best, nonsensical at worst.