BJ no try

[Guest]

There was no seperation -the ball did moved but under the current rules its a try . I was surpirised a benefit of the doubt wasnt given .Like to hear Mr Harrigon...he has all day to think of an excuse

They partially squared it up by ruling that SKD dropped ball a knock back

[Guest]

theyve been ruling it a try all year, all last year too. 9 out of 10 times; green light.

[Muffdaddy]

They partially squared it up by ruling that SKD dropped ball a knock back

Yeah, I'd like to see that again because I thought that was a knock on watching it live at the game.

[Vasco]

There was no seperation -the ball did moved but under the current rules its a try . I was surpirised a benefit of the doubt wasnt given .Like to hear Mr Harrigon...he has all day to think of an excuse

That is the key point.

[Guest]

You're wrong, watch the replay, it was no try.

PMSL@rorters

[Vasco]

You're wrong, watch the replay, it was no try.

PMSL@rorters

Come on darque you are better than that.

[Guest]

Come on darque you are better than that.

I am being serious, it wasn't a try. His hand slid down the side of the ball, at no stage was there downward pressure because he lost it.

[Guest]

Contact is deemed as downward pressure. A try any day of the week except for a certain team

[Guest]

I am being serious, it wasn't a try. His hand slid down the side of the ball, at no stage was there downward pressure because he lost it.

Nonsense. The camera angle from BJ's right showed him grounding it, not a doubt in the world. The head on didn't look as good, but I thought the vid ref was looking at that one to make sure his legs didn't go into touch.

I don't buy into the constant whinging and conspiracy theories around every 50/50 call, but good lord that one was a try for your life

[Guest]

Dead set they have ****en called that a try all year.

No kidding anyone on here, its a conspiracy against us,

ERVERY ****ING week there is always some sort of 50/50 decision that will go against us.
We are hated, the refs hate us.

I still cant forget about what happen with brisnane a month ago.

"ROOSTERS BALL"
NO
"BRISBANE BALL"

PLAY ON - (brisbane dont even play the ball for a nerw set of six but just gets straight up and runs with.

Last week the forward pass by oearce to moga ? another decision that went against us.

EVERY ****ING WEEK

[Guest]

I am being serious, it wasn't a try. His hand slid down the side of the ball, at no stage was there downward pressure because he lost it.

You say it was not a try but the commentators say it was a try. A couple of them are ex international league players who have no connection with Souths or the Roosters.

[bondi paul]

Sometimes I get the feeling the NRL don't want us in the comp.

you are dead set right - politis has got here nose out of joint as too news limited dont like us.chips on the shoulders too due to a hang up on
eastern suburbs

[Guest]

Sometimes I get the feeling the NRL don't want us in the comp.

you are dead set right - politis has got here nose out of joint as too news limited dont like us.chips on the shoulders too due to a hang up on
eastern suburbs

that being said, when are we goin back to Easts and turfing the Sydbey moniker? Surely it has to happen sooner rather than later.

[kurtsherlock6]

They partially squared it up by ruling that SKD dropped ball a knock back

From where i was sitting souffs were a mile offside from the play the ball, it looked like the refs thought about blowing a penalty but didnt, so i'd say it was a bit of a square up. Others sitting near me thought the same.

Apart from that, i would hardly say that call made up for a fair try being disllowed.

[Spanner in the works]

It is even worse when we can agree on something

It's even worse when the Souths fans who were sitting in front of me thought it was a try, and looked rather bemused when it wasn't awarded.