For all you Mini haters;

[Arties Pie]

He drops way to many passes for my liking and he isnt the pinball machine of old bouncing off defenders that mini is gone, but he's good under the high ball.

[melon....]

For cam cherry.

Mini has cost us plenty of games this year and should have retired last year. He is one of the main reasons we missed the finals this year.

That is all.

[Andrew Walker]

When did he come good????

Great clubman, Great bloke, unfortunately he is now stifling more than our attack, he is delaying the development of Sheck and others with his selection in 1st grade.

He tries his butt off, unfortunately these days he is so far off the pace it isn't funny.

Personally I have no issues whatsoever with Shek on the wing for next season. Some of you here forget he has played the game for less than one year 20 games of Rugby League in his life. Yet most here are calling for him to be put in straight into a posiition which is one of the most testing postions on the field. I am not saying he isnt up to it. But another season on the wing will do him no harm at all Mini also spent his 1st two seasons on the wing which didnt do his development any harm

Just a thought

[stsae]

I reckon we have been pretty lucky this year. Any coach doing their homework could surely see how Mini will attack any ball in the air but will let any rolling ball go past him and he then circles to get behind it to pick the thing up and then he is ready to run the ball. Problem is the defence is in his face and usually the opposition gets a repeat on us, from memory he's given up a few tries this way.

Why would anyone bomb to Mini??? I'd grubber at him all game.

That said, The Postal kid showed how to field a rolling ball in goals, slip twice, still regain his feet and step thru the defence to run 1/2 way up field to set up a try.

There once was a time Mini did such things. He just lacks pace. Great bloke blah blah blah. Lost his only asset. Pace.

[Guest]

I reckon we have been pretty lucky this year. Any coach doing their homework could surely see how Mini will attack any ball in the air but will let any rolling ball go past him and he then circles to get behind it to pick the thing up and then he is ready to run the ball. Problem is the defence is in his face and usually the opposition gets a repeat on us, from memory he's given up a few tries this way.

Why would anyone bomb to Mini??? I'd grubber at him all game.

That said, The Postal kid showed how to field a rolling ball in goals, slip twice, still regain his feet and step thru the defence to run 1/2 way up field to set up a try.

There once was a time Mini did such things. He just lacks pace. Great bloke blah blah blah. Lost his only asset. Pace.

That's it, put in a grubber and mini shits himself. He cannot bring himself to attack the ball let alone the defensive line.

Chook.

[kurtsherlock6]

For cam cherry.

Mini has cost us plenty of games this year and should have retired last year. He is one of the main reasons we missed the finals this year.

That is all.

To blame Mini, or to say he is one of the main reasons we missed the finals, is such a ridiculous comment on so many levels it's not even worth going into.

That is all.

[kurtsherlock6]

Personally I have no issues whatsoever with Shek on the wing for next season. Some of you here forget he has played the game for less than one year 20 games of Rugby League in his life. Yet most here are calling for him to be put in straight into a posiition which is one of the most testing postions on the field. I am not saying he isnt up to it. But another season on the wing will do him no harm at all Mini also spent his 1st two seasons on the wing which didnt do his development any harm

Just a thought

Fair points Andrew.

I notice the Mini haters have no response to this.

[Guest]

Fair points Andrew.

I notice the Mini haters have no response to this.

The guys a legend but he is now a bumbling fool and is tarnishing his reputation with the club the longer he goes... Time to move over there's a new kid on the block
!!!!!!!!!!!!

[melon....]

To blame Mini, or to say he is one of the main reasons we missed the finals, is such a ridiculous comment on so many levels it's not even worth going into.

That is all.

So you don't count the comedic running around the football whilst the opposition score or the pathetic positioning and soft defense as a problem. He has cost s plenty as have thers like Anadta who just doesn't care.

You probably also like the way he jumps into the backline and screws the flow of attack. What about not being able to take a pass through the ruck that any other fullback would take all the way under the sticks.

That's great Kurt. It's great you love mediocrity, while the rest of s want the team to succeed. Especially when the forwards do the work only for backs line mini to screw things up. He is way past his use by date.

I know the truth hurts, but that's the truth. He s the worst fullback in the game these days.

[melon....]

Fair points Andrew.

I notice the Mini haters have no response to this.

I also don't have any problems with shek on Wing or fullback. As long as the moth is not in the team costing us.

[Guest]

I also don't have any problems with shek on Wing or fullback. As long as the moth is not in the team costing us.

Agree, I think he's been shocking thus far, good for a few crucial mistakes every game

[kurtsherlock6]

So you don't count the comedic running around the football whilst the opposition score or the pathetic positioning and soft defense as a problem. He has cost s plenty as have thers like Anadta who just doesn't care.

You probably also like the way he jumps into the backline and screws the flow of attack. What about not being able to take a pass through the ruck that any other fullback would take all the way under the sticks.

That's great Kurt. It's great you love mediocrity, while the rest of s want the team to succeed. Especially when the forwards do the work only for backs line mini to screw things up. He is way past his use by date.

I know the truth hurts, but that's the truth. He s the worst fullback in the game these days.

This is complete bullsh!t, just because someone dares to have a different opinion to you, you pull out this old chest nut. I want the team to succeed as much as anyone.

I also dont think Mini is anywhere near as bad as you make out, but thats just my opinion.

Anyway why dont you just go off and start on one of your other agenda's.

[Vasco]

I reckon we have been pretty lucky this year. Any coach doing their homework could surely see how Mini will attack any ball in the air but will let any rolling ball go past him and he then circles to get behind it to pick the thing up and then he is ready to run the ball. Problem is the defence is in his face and usually the opposition gets a repeat on us, from memory he's given up a few tries this way.

Why would anyone bomb to Mini??? I'd grubber at him all game.

That said, The Postal kid showed how to field a rolling ball in goals, slip twice, still regain his feet and step thru the defence to run 1/2 way up field to set up a try.

There once was a time Mini did such things. He just lacks pace. Great bloke blah blah blah. Lost his only asset. Pace.

He has also lost his ability to break a tackle. In fact that happened about 6 years ago.

[Guest]

He has also lost his ability to break a tackle. In fact that happened about 6 years ago.

Really?
http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/nrl/statistics
click" busts" and "runs"

[Andrew Walker]

Really?
http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/nrl/statistics
click" busts" and "runs"

You should know by now STATS mean fcuk all Especially 69 of them