Who will be 2012 Rookie of the year?

[TDK]

Henry
Moga
Sezer
Hurrell
Reynolds
Mansour
?
My guess Reynolds.

[Guest]

Ross windshuttle

[Guest]

Reynolds for sure. Has benefitted from a dominant forward pack and a pretty simple game plan. Give it to G.I as much as possible.

[TDK]

Henry
Moga
Sezer
Hurrell
Reynolds
Mansour
?
My guess Reynolds.

Add
Taufua from manly
Ken Sio
Everingham

[Guest]

Reynolds and that aint a question

[Guest]

Reynolds and that aint a question

But this is... Are you retarded?

[Guest]

Braith Anasta.

[Guest]

Reynolds would be the favourite, Josh Mansour at Penrith goes alright as does Hurrell. Pretty dissapointed with Moga I know he's young) when you see what kids without his size and talent are doing at other clubs. He needs to kick on next year.

[Chook Norris]

Reynolds from souffs. Although statistics suggest that comparative to other rookies from previous years, he is actually very average

[Guest]

Ross windshuttle

Where the hell did you pull that from, my brother went to school with him! Great bloke actually, should've played more FG, he was lightning fast.

[Geohood]

Reynolds from souffs. Although statistics suggest that comparative to other rookies from previous years, he is actually very average

I agree I don't rate him that highly. Plays his role well and is a great goal kicker but other than that he doesn't seem to be a very dangerous player.. His first instinct is to kick. Some may say I might be talking about Pearce saying that, but Pearce always had a decent all round game from the beginning.

[Gary Worthless]

Daniel tupou no doubt

[Guest]

Brett Papworth..

[Guest]

I agree I don't rate him that highly. Plays his role well and is a great goal kicker but other than that he doesn't seem to be a very dangerous player.. His first instinct is to kick. Some may say I might be talking about Pearce saying that, but Pearce always had a decent all round game from the beginning.

I think you are overlooking one of his main strength -his defence. Not afraid to take on the big blokes heead on when necessary.

[Guest]

Reynolds has done a great job in his first year but he has benefitted from there forwards and GI no doubt. The true test will come semi final time if they get behind and there forwards are not dominating. It will be interesting to see how he copes then. Him being mentioned as Junior replacement at origin was very premature. If there still winning in 2 years and he is playing consistent then we could see him replace Junior but if we get the right coach who can help him then he has no hope