Round 23 Sydney Roosters Vs Manly Sea Eagles Disccussion thread.

[melon....]

Manly have dropped Williams - out of form. Lyon moves to centre and some nuffy is now on the wing. The nuffy will still score 3 tries against SKD.

[elo]

Farrar was moved to the wing and is no nuffie melon.

They look 15 times more solid with Tony dropped, shame Freddy doesn't realise we would be as well if SKD was dropped, Pez to wing, Mini to fullback and Jones starting......but well I still give us a big chance in this one as Manly have Aweford in their side.

[Vasco]

Why is Shackleton playing first grade?

Surely we should be playing someone that WILL be at the club next year.

The same goes for Soliola.

Shackleton's form of late hardly warratns selection in first grade anyway. As for Soliola, well his form hasn't warranted selection since 2005!

[Guest]

i seriously thought skd would have been dropped....

[melon....]

Farrar was moved to the wing and is no nuffie melon.

They look 15 times more solid with Tony dropped, shame Freddy doesn't realise we would be as well if SKD was dropped, Pez to wing, Mini to fullback and Jones starting......but well I still give us a big chance in this one as Manly have Aweford in their side.

As long as we smash that young tool Foran, ill be happy. i hate those 2 idiot brothers and their craop influence on hair brained Pearce who seems to follow their every idiocy.

[Cockadoodledoo]

It's no worse than the team Fittler has selected this week.

And I realise Earl is not NRL standard but he's not the only one!!!

So what would you do Lucky?

Towers is horrible as is Earl.. Neither should be anywhere near First Grade no badly how we are playing.

[Guest]

Towers is horrible as is Earl.. Neither should be anywhere near First Grade no badly how we are playing.

towers isnt horrible he's a great player
ive said ages ago he should play first grade. theres no reason why he shouldnt get go in first grade

[melon....]

Towers is horrible as is Earl.. Neither should be anywhere near First Grade no badly how we are playing.

Towers, behind Shack is the most over rated player at the club. He puts on a step or catches teh ball and all of a sudden he's friggen Billy Slater.

[Guest]

Towers, behind Shack is the most over rated player at the club. He puts on a step or catches teh ball and all of a sudden he's friggen Billy Slater.

the most over rated at the club, i dont think so...

[Vasco]

towers isnt horrible he's a great player
ive said ages ago he should play first grade. theres no reason why he shouldnt get go in first grade

Are any of the U20s duds? They concede 50 points every week!!!

[Johnny Tobin]

[QUOTE=Luckyman333;21042]

Can't see that team running on the field.

Surely SKD has done enough to warrant a run at Henson Park.[/QUOTE

It proves Fittler either loves Kenny-Dowal or sees some "spark" in him!

I would like to see some "spark" in him - attached to a bomb.

[Guest]

It's no worse than the team Fittler has selected this week.

And I realise Earl is not NRL standard but he's not the only one!!!

So what would you do Lucky?

1. Sam Perret
2. Iwi Hauraki
3. Mitchell Aubusson
4. Setaimata Sa
5. Anthony Minichello
6. Ben Jones
7. Mitchell Pearce
8. Frank-Paul Nuuausala
9. Jake Friend
10. Lopini Paea
11. Shane Shackleton
12. Willie Mason
13. Craig Fitzgibbion

14. Martin Kennedy
15. Stanley Waqa
16. Nick Kouparitsas
17. Riley Brown

Before u start questioning it. I put Nick there coz noone better eles availble. I believe most players in Under 20's will struggle so yeh...

[Guest]

We just have to convince BlindFreddy now mate.

Maybe Lucky is BlindFreddy???

I'm not that bad

[Guest]

for **** sake freddy some common sense mate. u tried mini at 6 last week and he achieved nothing, just put mini at 5, ben jones at 6, kouparitsis on the bench and skd ****s off to newtown

Sooo true! little wonder we are where we are..this has been no accident.

We have been relegated to the dregs of wooden spoon contenders by bad design and mismanagement..

[Guest]

I can't make it this weekend and I'm not too shattered about it.

Ah how times have changed.