MERGED: Todd Carney Discussion Thread, refer all comments on TC's signing here

[Guest]

lol first time i read that i missed the 1. I thought u were implying mini at 5/8 carney at 7, pearce at hooker and friend at 13...thought ud been taking coaching advice from freddy fittler

LMFAO, if I was taking coaching advice from freddy I would have had;
1. Anasta 6.Mini 7. Friend 9. Carney 13. Pearce

[stsae]

LMFAO, if I was taking coaching advice from freddy I would have had;
1. Anasta 6.Mini 7. Friend 9. Carney 13. Pearce

Thats it.

Freddo IS sirgaydickhead, im convinced now.

[Guest]

Todd Carney

Hey everyone, Just wanted to get your thoughts on this signing, So what does everything think about it?

[stephenj]

excellent signing, just what our club needs, the spark to light the fire!

[Guest]

$1 million for a three-year deal... They dont come cheap...

I feel Anasta will be rendered redundant when Carney plays 5/8, I dont see him being an effective lock

[Guest]

Hey everyone, Just wanted to get your thoughts on this signing, So what does everything think about it?

It's official?
Link please.

[Guest]

It's official?
Link please.

Something drastically wrong would have to happen for it not to be finalised in the next few days.

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/spo...-1225764961609

And while we are at it... another article says the Tigers are favoured for Lote. Says he would need to be on no more than 200k. I'd pay that.

[Guest]

YESSSSSSSSSSSSSS. Now cut Zoolanders pay or piss him off to spare some cash for a strong prop or some outside backs. And you know we are on the right track when Bennet wanted him. Good Times Ahead.

[Guest]

$1 million for a three-year deal... They dont come cheap...

I feel Anasta will be rendered redundant when Carney plays 5/8, I dont see him being an effective lock

How do you know about the $1 Million on a three-year deal??? Proof plz

[Guest]

Oh Sorrry nvm, I read article and it said Silly me!

[Guest]

Should be our points scoring saviour!

[Guest]

Something drastically wrong would have to happen for it not to be finalised in the next few days.

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/spo...-1225764961609

And while we are at it... another article says the Tigers are favoured for Lote. Says he would need to be on no more than 200k. I'd pay that.

Seems a lot for Carney in my view. 333 a season or so?
He'd better do a good job... anybody know how he's going up in QLD? *guessing he's carving up*

To me Lote at "more than 200k" seems a better deal. On the other hand, Carney's young and could develop into something really amazing. If he's nailing 40/20's all day and kicking our backs into shape, then who knows?

[Guest]

Yes infact he is. Everytime i checked (like 4 times for the game) it said he got like 6 out of 6 goals and like 4-5 trys. Nearly every game

[Guest]

How quick we are forgetting the man who basically carried our team in the last 3-4 years.

It's exactly like getting rid of the 3 year old dog to get a new puppy because it looks cuter.

Anasta has done nothing wrong and without him we would be dwindling down the bottom every single year. Been a great clubman as well. Yet some people are quick to write him off to be replaced by a bloke who might not even last half a season and with that bring the club into disrepute.

[witty92]

How quick we are forgetting the man who basically carried our team in the last 3-4 years.

It's exactly like getting rid of the 3 year old dog to get a new puppy because it looks cuter.

Anasta has done nothing wrong and without him we would be dwindling down the bottom every single year. Been a great clubman as well. Yet some people are quick to write him off to be replaced by a bloke who might not even last half a season and with that bring the club into disrepute.

Carried our team? Mate he's carried our team to one finals appearance in 4 years. I'd keep him at lock just because of his leadership and love for the club and i'd keep him as captain, but i don't think he's as good a 5/8 as carney