It's official. Pearce is the new Funch.

[Andrew Walker]

Take slater and smith out, cronk has gotten smashed, and if I recall twice by Pearce during that time. Invalid argument imo.

Once again in origin he is playing behind those same blokes.

Carney is a creative player yes but can't organise the team and if he does it takes away from his brilliance, why he hasn't reached the heights he did in 2010.

1stky yes it is a team game No half can do it on there own

Organisation was not what we were initailly talking about here Natural brilliance was what Johhny 1st mentioned IMO Cronk Kelly Carney Thurston all have it Pearce does not

However take Maloney SBW out and give us back Anasta how do you think we would be going this year ? It is about as reklevant as your top paragraph The fact is these plyerrs are there For both Cronk and pearce

[Kingsgrove-Loiner]

Cronk has always done a good enough job of taking the line on with a dummy and getting through Mind you Pearce has been afforded that same apportunity now three times at state level with a NO 6 being picked from the same club to accompany him

Kelly is a natural and your comment about Carney is ridiulous Despite his obvious issues He has been around carving up other sides snice about 2006 now

Have to pick you up on that one. Did you see much of 2011?

And this season, he's having a good game every third one.

[Guest]

1stky yes it is a team game No half can do it on there own

Organisation was not what we were initailly talking about here Natural brilliance was what Johhny 1st mentioned IMO Cronk Kelly Carney Thurston all have it Pearce does not

However take Maloney SBW out and give us back Anasta how do you think we would be going this year ? It is about as reklevant as your top paragraph The fact is these plyerrs are there For both Cronk and pearce

lol funny how this argument only applies when it suits everyone. The forwards were absolutely smashed in game 2 yet pearce was at fault.

How the fark can Cronk have natural talent, when the only reason he looks good is because of those guys?? Your argument makes no sense. Where is this talent you speak of without those players??

Once again Pearce smashed cronk without smith and Slater.

[Chook Norris]

Pearce overthinks things. Plays too structured at times. He definitely doesn't have that vision or plan B when structure goes out the window. When Qld needed a big play from their halves, they got it. Thurston with his dummy and try, and Cronk with his pass to Hodges try

[Andrew Walker]

lol funny how this argument only applies when it suits everyone. The forwards were absolutely smashed in game 2 yet pearce was at fault.

How the fark can Cronk have natural talent, when the only reason he looks good is because of those guys?? Your argument makes no sense. Where is this talent you speak of without those players??

Once again Pearce smashed cronk without smith and Slater.

I ma sure Cronk would slot in at another club quite well

[Guest]

I ma sure Cronk would slot in at another club quite well

Haven't answered my question though. And I completely disgaree. Thurston was off in game 1, the pressure was on cronk and he was bad.

[stsae]

Pressure should be on Maloney. Unsighted all game. Pearce doesnt make the grade, but Maloney is even more average.

Shhh don't upset Shandy and Teabags maaaaaaaaaaaaaate.

[stsae]

Pearce overthinks things. Plays too structured at times. He definitely doesn't have that vision or plan B when structure goes out the window. When Qld needed a big play from their halves, they got it. Thurston with his dummy and try, and Cronk with his pass to Hodges try

Agree mate.

Why didn't Baloney step up then???

Afterall that's the reason he was picked wasn't it???

[Andrew Walker]

Haven't answered my question though. And I completely disgaree. Thurston was off in game 1, the pressure was on cronk and he was bad.

I completely disagree with what you said Hence why I said Cronk would have no problem slotting in to another team I know we would gain by having him as our NO7 as opposed to Pearce Souths may ven gain with him over Reynolds Cronulla as opposed to Robson Canterbury as opposed to Hidgkinson although his goal kicking in another matter Newcastle Penrith are other sides who Im sure Cronk could slot into and definately improve

[stsae]

I ma sure Cronk would slot in at another club quite well

LOL, have you seen Melbas record without Smiff???

Do you recall the 40-0 GF???

[Andrew Walker]

LOL, have you seen Melbas record without Smiff???

Do you recall the 40-0 GF???

Read my above post There are half a dozen sides I think Cronk would improve by playing for them

As for that GF Along with Smith mnissing that side was the walking wounded that day Great day that I absolutely cleaned up on Mnaly 13+ Couldnt get enough on

[Guest]

I completely disagree with what you said Hence why I said Cronk would have no problem slotting in to another team I know we would gain by having him as our NO7 as opposed to Pearce Souths may ven gain with him over Reynolds Cronulla as opposed to Robson Canterbury as opposed to Hidgkinson although his goal kicking in another matter Newcastle Penrith are other sides who Im sure Cronk could slot into and definately improve

You have not backed up your statement with cronk has natural talent!! Once again where is this talent without those players, what gives you the impression he can do it at another club??? Please explain??

[Andrew Walker]

You have not backed up your statement with cronk has natural talent!! Once again where is this talent without those players, what gives you the impression he can do it at another club??? Please explain??

For him to actually factually prove this he needs to play elswhere Otherwise it is opinion Do you honestly think Cronk would not shine at this club or some of the ones I have mentioned

[Guest]

For him to actually factually prove this he needs to play elswhere Otherwise it is opinion Do you honestly think Cronk would not shine at this club or some of the ones I have mentioned

Agree it is an opinion however it is a fact that when those players have not played Cronk has been smashed, another fact is Pearce has delivered two of those against him.

[Andrew Walker]

Agree it is an opinion however it is a fact that when those players have not played Cronk has been smashed, another fact is Pearce has delivered two of those against him.

You havent answered my question I answer yours So I expect you to answer mine In case you have trouble remebering It was Do you honestly think that Cronk would not shine at this club or any of the other clubs I have mentioned