Should we re-sign FPN?

[Thirteen]

Simple.
Yes or No?

[milanja]

Yep. Max 2yr deal.

[BUDDY]

He can come up with a blinder but they are few and far between.
If he got some consistency in his game then Yes but I can't see that happening. Probably the last of the lazy blokes in the team who survived the culling.

[Guest]

Since surviving the culling he has been okay IMO. I actually think we have missed him. He is one tough ombre. I say 2 more years.

[Guest]

depends of course on how much he'd cost

but overall, no

[Guest]

depends of course on how much he'd cost

but overall, no

thanks rothfield for your comments keep them for the sharks forums

[Arties Pie]

Obviously depends on how much he thinks he's worth.

[Guest]

Yes.

[Guest]

thanks rothfield for your comments keep them for the sharks forums

gibberer

[chook 56]

With the time invested so far it is worth another shot to see if he can be a regular.

Yes to 2 more years for the butterball.

[Guest]

Last year I would've said no, but this year he looks to have pulled his finger out.

At his best, he offer something that others in the club can't, a big bullish agressive body with a bit of skill thrown in. At his worst, he is a fat lazy slug. With Robinson coaching, pressure from young guys coming through and his 'mentor' fitzy on the coaching staff, I think they can get the best out of him. For us to compete with the big packs, we need FPN and we need him firing.

I would sign him to a two year contract weighted heavily with incentives.

[Spanner in the works]

No. Too much talent coming through, too inconsistent, too much money.

[Jacks Fur Coat]

I say yes just so we can hear jimmy smit say f....rank Paul the wrrrreckkking balllllll!!!! At the games.

[Guest]

The answer to this question also depends on whether SBW will be sticking around and how quickly the young blokes doing their apprenticeship in the Jets develop

[Darkone]

If Robbo wants him, YES!