Should we re-sign FPN?

[stephenj]

a two year extension

[roostwin]

If Robbo wants him, YES!

My thoughts exactly.

[Guest]

FPN s a classic case of a guy who should be on 1 year at a time contracts..

He plays his best footy when he is up for renewal..

My problem with Frank is that the gap between his best footy & his worst is huge..

He's got all the talent in the world,he just gets too comfortable with long term deals..

1 year deal for Franky IMO..

[Renman]

If Robbo wants him then yes as longs it is an affordable price. The problem is he is worth much to to some other clubs eg Cronulla. and he may be over the odds.


Wait and see.

[davos]

Absolutely not.

Reasons:

*As predicted, Cordner has played him out of the lock position he has unrightfully been starting in over the last few season.

* He is not just a lazy footballer but a stupid one also.

*His bad attitude can become infectious. Had we torn up his contract when we axed Myles, and Toddy, then we could have saved ourselves a lot of heartache.

*We have some prospects in the 20s and in Newtown that are almost ripe for the picking. Napa and Martin come to mind. Both are backrowers who play tight like a prop and both are evidently gifted players. I would hate to lose either one of them so that we can keep a man who has demonstrated a bad attitude in the past.

[Guest]

No...unless its at the expense of Kennedy

[Guest]

Absolutely not.

Reasons:

*As predicted, Cordner has played him out of the lock position he has unrightfully been starting in over the last few season.

* He is not just a lazy footballer but a stupid one also.

*His bad attitude can become infectious. Had we torn up his contract when we axed Myles, and Toddy, then we could have saved ourselves a lot of heartache.

*We have some prospects in the 20s and in Newtown that are almost ripe for the picking. Napa and Martin come to mind. Both are backrowers who play tight like a prop and both are evidently gifted players. I would hate to lose either one of them so that we can keep a man who has demonstrated a bad attitude in the past.

Good points Davos and I agree with most but I'd sign him on the Sonny Bill 1 yr deals. Should keep him nice and focused. Those you mentioned will push him hopefully if they aren't already doing so now