SKD and Kennedy

[Guest]

kennedy made 71 m and 41 tackles

[Cockadoodledoo]

I would be moving SBW back to the left edge in attack. He looked to be building a great combo with Jennings at the start of the season. SKD is just not good enough to take advantage of the work that SBW does.

[Funky Chicken]

Sonny Bill must feel like he is playing inside Mr Bean, I really do think he needs to be dropped so he can try and learn the basics of the game. Could Oldfield be any worse than SKD? At least then we would have super fast centres on both sides of the field.

[Cockadoodledoo]

Sonny Bill must feel like he is playing inside Mr Bean, I really do think he needs to be dropped so he can try and learn the basics of the game. Could Oldfield be any worse than SKD? At least then we would have super fast centres on both sides of the field.

Oldfield is a wood duck. No positional sense, can't tackle or catch a high ball. Heaps better than SKD though.

[Guest]

Aubo is no centre. Imo whenever he played there in the past he was a total passenger.

[Guest]

Does anyone think Toups could be turned into a centre?

Any good winger would love playing outside this guy once he finds his feet in first grade.

That was a great run he made in the first half bumping off a few players like flies. (not the first time he has did it this season)

He reminds me of the 'guru'. I still have nightmares of what that guy did to us 30 years later.

[Danish]

As much as it pains me to say it because I've always supported him ever since he made the grade, I really think its time for SKD to have a stint in reggies.

He has just lost his instinct, which is honestly the best thing he had going for him. Despite all his flaws he always had the ability to find the line, but without that really there is not much holding him in first grade.

The sad part is judging by his defensive improvements this season (besides tonight) you can tell his really been working hard on his game. It can only be a confidence thing you'd suspect.

Either way, he needs a run with teh Jets and someone else promoted for a couple weeks

[Parkway_Drive]

TBH you could either promote Oldfield who is apparently a wood duck to the right wing and move RTS to the centres, or slot Maubs who apparently is a passenger when he plays centre, into the centres or a left field decision Langi. Langi will introduced to FG anyway during origin should Maloney and Pearce be the blues halves. Langi will be too good to drop back to 20s IMO, if Moga is still off the pace then slot Langi in into SKD's position.

[melon....]

Would we be worse off with :

1.Mini
2.Tupou
3.Jennings
4.Aubo
5.RTS
6.Maloney
7.Pearce
8.LOD
9.Friend
10.FPN
11.Guerra
12.SBW
13.Cordner

14.Morts
15.Tasi
16.Napa
17. Evans

with Moa, JWH and Moga to come back soon.

Even if we lost with this team I wouldn't be unhappy. I'm just sick of us having passengers in our team. It could very well be the difference between winning or losing a premiership this season.

Yes... Mini is still there. He scored 2 tries for Melbourne tonight.

We can't win a comp with mini at fullback. We've lost 3 with him there.

Forget it.

[Guest]

Kennedy needs a 1 way ticket to Newtown it's time Evans or Napa are thrown in especially as we play Parra next up this fat muppet is holding these awesome kids back.

[Guest]

As much as it pains me to say it because I've always supported him ever since he made the grade, I really think its time for SKD to have a stint in reggies.

He has just lost his instinct, which is honestly the best thing he had going for him. Despite all his flaws he always had the ability to find the line, but without that really there is not much holding him in first grade.

The sad part is judging by his defensive improvements this season (besides tonight) you can tell his really been working hard on his game. It can only be a confidence thing you'd suspect.

Either way, he needs a run with teh Jets and someone else promoted for a couple weeks

Agree Danish I can't ever recall him being dropped in his career the time has come surely the smart coaches have worked out he's our weakest link.

[Guest]

We have three weak players in the team. Kennedy, SKD and Tupou. Mini is going ok.

Kennedy needs to go. He stifles our attack with is ultra slow play the balls, gets manhandled and pushed backwards everytime he takes the ball up even given his big size. He is, slow, slow, slow.

SKD also must go. I have been very patient with this guy but can't handle any more of his brain explosions at crucial times. His skill level in regards to passing and tackling is well below first grade standard.

Tupou is just not doing it for me. He is supposed to be good in the air but he couldnt catch a cold at the moment. He gets smashed almost everytime he tries to take the ball up and he is a clutz.

I would bring Langi into the centres and Oldfield or Rokolati onto the wing. We have multiple props who can replace Kennedy. Thought Tasi went pretty good last night. Surely, Kennedy will not hold his place once JWH and Moa come back into the team.

[Burnt Rooster]

Pretty much so the whole side decided to take a holiday, I don't know why, but , their heads wasent there for most of the game, after the first 3 minutes you knew we were in for a tough night. SKD has surely played his last game in firstgrade, he is a disgrace, in everyway, we will not win a comp with him in the side.LOD and FPN, tried hard, but why FPN cant get thru one game without a play the ball penalty, I don't know, its not rocket science.Either switch SBW to centre, or bring up Langi, to play centre, which he can do. We let some soft tries in again, that's mainly what I was most disappointed about, just close in soft tries, that we have been repelling most of the year, not length of the field unstoppable ones.But the loss will be a good learning curve for the club, we are not up there yet, and wont be without a few changes in the side, but its not all doom and gloom either.

[Guest]

Kennedy is just a fat idiot soft as need a stint in newtown

Dont say that cos now ppl will tell you he had a bad injury and he has good stats haha hes a fat useless slob

[Chook Norris]

I would not be afraid to switch SBW to the centres provided we give him ball