Jwh

[Guest]

Correct me if wrong but JWH should have no carry over points or loading as he used those in his lengthy 5 week break.
Surely if you use those points then they are gone. He will be missed even for one game.

You lose 5 points per game, so he should only have around 20 left.

They were saying last night even a Grade 1 would be a minimum 2 weeks but I think that could be wrong.

It will come down to what loading he gets.

[fletch]

if he gets charged the club will have to seriously consider fighting the charge on the basis initial contact was with the chest and more a defensive action rather than a striking action.

a two week suspension could be enough to see JWH miss the rest of the season.

[Rocky Rhodes]

You lose 5 points per game, so he should only have around 20 left.

They were saying last night even a Grade 1 would be a minimum 2 weeks but I think that could be wrong.

It will come down to what loading he gets.

Where did you get that info from? So he had 45points? Seems a strange system to me, the loading gave him a longer than average rest last time. I thought once you used them (points) then they are gone and you start fresh.

[Guest]

if he gets charged the club will have to seriously consider fighting the charge on the basis initial contact was with the chest and more a defensive action rather than a striking action.

a two week suspension could be enough to see JWH miss the rest of the season.

Mate I think we could get him off but if he gets 1 weeks we will cop it.

Do you know how the loading works? I think a few of his last charges from 1 and 2 years ago might be gone now.

[Guest]

Where did you get that info from? So he had 45points? Seems a strange system to me, the loading gave him a longer than average rest last time. I thought once you used them (points) then they are gone and you start fresh.

Mate 100 points = 1 week suspension. Sometimes there are carry over points, for every game completed without a charge 5 points gets taken off.

What I don't fully understand is the loading, I don't know for sure but I think a few of his previous charges might be gone now.

[Andrew Walker]

The loading he carried over from the last suspension should be gone As it was in August 2011 I read on here that it goes after two years I read that here before his last suspension

[Guest]

The loading he carried over from the last suspension should be gone As it was in August 2011 I read on here that it goes after two years I read that here before his last suspension

Also I think he had 2 Grade 1's v the Sharks last year but they only carry over for 12 months.

I think with another Grade 1 charge he might only cop 1 week.

[Hollus]

If he gets a grade one his minimum suspension will def be 2 weeks, the base is 125 + 80% loading and carry overs is about 210. Looking at the replay today there is absolutely no way he should be charged!

[Guest]

If he gets a grade one his minimum suspension will def be 2 weeks, the base is 125 + 80% loading and carry overs is about 210. Looking at the replay today there is absolutely no way he should be charged!

Where does 80% loading come from Hollus?

I think he only has one current charge on his name now.

[Hollus]

Where does 80% loading come from Hollus?

I think he only has one current charge on his name now.

4 non-similar offences each worth 20%. Plus the 25% guilty plea discount is only applied to the original amount and not the loading.

[Vasco]

Just watched the game again.

Burgess raises his arm in every carry.

[Guest]

Just watched the game again.

Burgess raises his arm in every carry.

They all do it mate.

Burgess did it from the tap after the penalty and still got belted by JWH.

[Vasco]

Yeah I know.

Burgess should be facing charges for the eye gouge and the kick on JWH.

Realistically he shouldn't play another game this season.

But of course he will play all.

I haven't despised a player as much as Burgess since Wayne Bartrim!

[chook 56]

Yeah I know.

Burgess should be facing charges for the eye gouge and the kick on JWH.

Realistically he shouldn't play another game this season.

But of course he will play all.

I haven't despised a player as much as Burgess since Wayne Bartrim!

Yep.....all two of them.

[Guest]

Penalty at worst, fair enough he lifted his elbow a bit too high hence the penalty.

It's a contact sport you have to try defend yourself I don't see it being much worse then that. I think he will get a week due to carry over points.