Smh exclusive "JWH to be charged"

[easts4eva]

My mate said something today when we were watching the storm. And this is why the above comment rings true, start a fight every tackle. So they have to pull it up & review it.

[Guest]

That's it, so much of our game unfortunately these days is about the reaction.

If Maloney goes down holding his eye and a few of the boys come rushing in and a push and shove escalates 1) I bet you it gets put on report, 2) I bet you it's in every newspaper in the city and 3) I bet you he cops a long stint on the sidelines.

No longer are we a game that rules on intent or carelessness but instead on reactions, it's sad.

I have a huge amount of respect for Robbo telling the boys to never lie down because they should be proud of the jersey they're wearing but I do wonder how much it's actually hurting us. I saw Skidsy get clipped high on Friday night but he got to his feet, that could've easily been a crucial penalty if he stayed down. In saying that you can't ask players to be soft and play for penalties and then play tough when it comes to the crucial moments in the game, it's a fabric of our culture now... we're a proud side.

JWH was kicked and pushed in the head and wasn't even given a penalty. Why would you think Maloney staying down would warrant any action??

[milanja]

That's it, so much of our game unfortunately these days is about the reaction.

If Maloney goes down holding his eye and a few of the boys come rushing in and a push and shove escalates 1) I bet you it gets put on report, 2) I bet you it's in every newspaper in the city and 3) I bet you he cops a long stint on the sidelines.

No longer are we a game that rules on intent or carelessness but instead on reactions, it's sad.

I have a huge amount of respect for Robbo telling the boys to never lie down because they should be proud of the jersey they're wearing but I do wonder how much it's actually hurting us. I saw Skidsy get clipped high on Friday night but he got to his feet, that could've easily been a crucial penalty if he stayed down. In saying that you can't ask players to be soft and play for penalties and then play tough when it comes to the crucial moments in the game, it's a fabric of our culture now... we're a proud side.

No point being proud when we get no benefit from it 6. No other supporters or commentators say "good on the roosters for not staying down" if everyone else is getting away with it, then unfortunately we are falling behind in that department and may be the reason we get less penalties than the rest of the league.

[Tommy Smith]

According to an article I just read, a grade one striking charge will be him face a one game ban.

A grade two will be a three game ban.

Imo they can get ****ed if it's even a grade one. A grade two will see world war III from our end.

[roosterproud]

I am convinced Paul Kent spells his last name wrong.

???paul bent

[Thirteen]

According to an article I just read, a grade one striking charge will be him face a one game ban.

A grade two will be a three game ban.

Imo they can get ****ed if it's even a grade one. A grade two will see world war III from our end.

What are u going to do? Type about it on your keyboard!?

[The Brain]

Sam Burgess will eye gouge and knee incidents is now going to the match review committee.

My opinion Semis is like SOO let it all go and get on with the job of footy.

[Guest]

According to an article I just read, a grade one striking charge will be him face a one game ban.

A grade two will be a three game ban.

Imo they can get ****ed if it's even a grade one. A grade two will see world war III from our end.

He will cop a grade 1 and we will probably take the week.

It's not ideal we could probably challenge it, we are due some luck from the judiciary.

I still can't believe LOD got suspended. I thought he stopped Simona from injuring himself who contributed to the tackle by walking off the mark.

[Johnny.]

Well Dave Smith can be a carnt so yes, yes it is.

I thought he was a Welsh prick not a Kent.

[Guest]

Interesting to hear Gallen on triple m come out and say JWH should have no case to answer.
Although i hate the git its nice to know he speaks the truth and supports our man!

[Johnny.]

Interesting to hear Gallen on triple m come out and say JWH should have no case to answer.
Although i hate the git its nice to know he speaks the truth and supports our man!

He probably doesn't want the arclight put on foul play.

[Vasco]

the problem with the eye gauge, was that Maloney didn't carry on like a good sort ...like McQueen, who'd you'd swear was hit in the jaw with a cricket bat.

LOL

What is it with players resembling Argentinian soccer players these days.

[Johnny.]

LOL

What is it with players resembling Argentinian soccer players these days.

It's in the training. The Ref's are so terrified of missing something that everything is treated like a Les Boyd special.

[Hawkeye]

LOL

What is it with players resembling Argentinian soccer players these days.

Unfortunately that's it ....... we've been reading recently that players are coached to stay down, trainers on the field are telling players to stay down, so as video ref's will review an incident and get a penalty.
It would seem that the next level now is players jumping in and reacting to an incident so that the ref's have no alternative than to assume something bad has happened and that they must award a penalty.

[tri-hard]

Grade 1 - a week, Grade 2 - the Season.