6-year Penalty Analysis

[Tommy Smith]

Do you plan to send it to Easts HO?

Perhaps I should.

[TheLoneRooster]

The graphs are just so good at painting the sorry picture. Seriously, as a guppy or vermin supporter, you'd have to be happy with how they're handled by the refs.

[Guest]

Tommy these need to be sent to the media

[tri-hard]

This needs to be sent to all the media outlets. I would do it myself only I don't know how.

[bondi paul]

well done yet again tommy. thanks for your time and care.

[Guest]

Before it gets sent more analysis needs to done ie avg penalties given away per game per team vs penalties given away by each team when playing the roosters. Hopefully this will show that teams are penalized less against our team then they are on average.

[bondi paul]

just gives further weight to the NRL refs etc who have a socio demographic hang up about the eastern suburbs.

[Guest]

just gives further weight to the NRL refs etc who have a socio demographic hang up about the eastern suburbs.

My god. That's a new one....

[Andrew Walker]

My god. That's a new one....

Instead of ridiculing others

Would you care to give an explanation to the damning statistics that have been shown

I eagerly await to hear your expanation on not only that of why we have been so heavily penalised But more importantly why we have received so few penalties

[Guest]

I can't on here as the file is too big. But i'll try and post it to a file share site and provide the link.

Thanks. You have done some great work here. I reckon we need to perfect it to give it the best chance of going viral prior to the big game. I've got something in mind and will give it a crack when the data comes through.

[bondi paul]

My god. That's a new one....

just another reason madrooster and one of many.

[Tommy Smith]

Pens Less than 4 Received Stats.jpg

Pens Less than 4 Received.jpg

Pens More than 6 Received at Home Stats.jpg

Pens More than 6 Received at Home.jpg

Who are the Sharks ****ing?

[Guest]

Instead of ridiculing others

Would you care to give an explanation to the damning statistics that have been shown

I eagerly await to hear your expanation on not only that of why we have been so heavily penalised But more importantly why we have received so few penalties

Mr. Walkout, Firstly didn't even look at the stats, have been aware of our glaring discipline issue for five years on and off the field. If you want me to speculate I'd say 90% of the results as our own fault (being ill disciplined, being unfit, being inexperienced, being poorly coached and tactics etc) and 5% poor officiating and 5% of 'that's the way the game goes'.

Why do you think it happens? Here I'll make it multi choice.
A) NRL want Souths to win this year, (Dragons 2010 etc )so they penalised us heavily each of those years based on who they want to win.
B) Martin Kennedy solely responsible.
C) Refs don't like Roosters because it's an affluent area LOL
D) Daily Telegraph, told the NRL, who told the refs not to let us win.
E) All of the above and because you take part in self appreciation/interference.

[tri-hard]

Mr. Walkout, Firstly didn't even look at the stats, have been aware of our glaring discipline issue for five years on and off the field. If you want me to speculate I'd say 90% of the results as our own fault (being ill disciplined, being unfit, being inexperienced, being poorly coached and tactics etc) and 5% poor officiating and 5% of 'that's the way the game goes'.

Why do you think it happens? Here I'll make it multi choice.
A) NRL want Souths to win this year, (Dragons 2010 etc )so they penalised us heavily each of those years based on who they want to win.
B) Martin Kennedy solely responsible.
C) Refs don't like Roosters because it's an affluent area LOL
D) Daily Telegraph, told the NRL, who told the refs not to let us win.
E) All of the above and because you take part in self appreciation/interference.

Discipline has what exactly to do with not receiving penalties?

[Cockadoodledoo]

Mr. Walkout, Firstly didn't even look at the stats, have been aware of our glaring discipline issue for five years on and off the field. If you want me to speculate I'd say 90% of the results as our own fault (being ill disciplined, being unfit, being inexperienced, being poorly coached and tactics etc) and 5% poor officiating and 5% of 'that's the way the game goes'.

Why do you think it happens? Here I'll make it multi choice.
A) NRL want Souths to win this year, (Dragons 2010 etc )so they penalised us heavily each of those years based on who they want to win.
B) Martin Kennedy solely responsible.
C) Refs don't like Roosters because it's an affluent area LOL
D) Daily Telegraph, told the NRL, who told the refs not to let us win.
E) All of the above and because you take part in self appreciation/interference.

So basically you don't have an answer. I asked the same question the other day.. It is the question which continues not to get a logical or coherent response.