2010 vs 2013 - which is the better team?

[Guest]

Minichiello
Perrett - Tuivasa-Sheck
Kenny-Dowall
Linnett - Jennings
Graham - Tupou
Carney - Maloney
Pearce
Hargreaves
Friend
Ryles - O'Donnell
Anasta - SBW
Myles - Cordner
Nuuausala

Kouparitsas - Mortimer
M Aubusson
Conn - Moa
Kennedy/Guerra

Reserves:

Masoe - Napa
Paea - Liu
Leilua - Oldfield
J Aubusson - Seluini

[Hawkeye]

Each one of those 2013 players you've highlighted you'd have to say is a better player than their 2010 counterpart ...with debateable exception being Maloney for Carney.
On that basis you'd have to say the 2013 team is superior.

[chook 56]

Each one of those 2013 players you've highlighted you'd have to say is a better player than their 2010 counterpart ...with debateable exception being Maloney for Carney.
On that basis you'd have to say the 2013 team is superior.

No question imo.

[Vasco]

2013.

[Guest]

Would prefer SKD and MK form of 2010

[Guest]

It must also be noted that players such as Jarred Waerea Hargreaves, Aiden "Che" Guerra and Martin "Marty" Kennedy are better in season 2013 than they were in season 2010.

[Guest]

Minichiello
Perrett - Tuivasa-Sheck
Kenny-Dowall
Linnett - Jennings
Graham - Tupou
Carney - Maloney
Pearce
Hargreaves
Friend
Ryles - O'Donnell
Anasta - SBW
Myles - Cordner
Nuuausala

Kouparitsas - Mortimer
M Aubusson
Conn - Moa
Kennedy/Guerra

Reserves:

Masoe - Napa
Paea - Liu
Leilua - Oldfield
J Aubusson - Seluini

The 2013 team is much stronger, with the exception of Maloney in for Carney. However Maloney is much more consistent than Carney and is a better fit for our side. Also Myles is arguably stronger than Cordner, and before people rip into me I do rate Cordner highly by Myles was at his peak whereas Cordner is still getting better as a player.

Plus Pearce, JWH and Friend are all playing much better football than what they were in 2010!

[chook 56]

Debatable with Anasta/SBW.

[Tommy Smith]

2013 by 20.

I wish this team played the 2010 Dragons in the GF!

We'd beat them as well.

[Guest]

2013 by the length of the straight.

[Guest]

Debatable with Anasta/SBW.

Flip of a coin between them two lol

[Guest]

Debatable with Anasta/SBW.

Candice F has an opinion no doubt

[Spirit of 66]

2013, of course.

The list also highlights the number of players in our squad with GF experience - 11, I think.

[Guest]

Any team with SBW in it will inevitably be better. Seriously though the current squad would destroy the 2010 squad imo. Way classier across the park.

[roostersrule2]

SBW can't kick field goals, Anasta can.

2010 by a mile.