Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Brian Smith eyes fullback role for Todd Carney

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Brian Smith eyes fullback role for Todd Carney

    SYDNEY Roosters coach Brian Smith has confirmed he will use the pre-season to find out whether Todd Carney is a realistic option at fullback.

    Carney, who began training with the Roosters on Monday, was expected to slot in alongside Mitchell Pearce in the halves.

    However, Smith said yesterday he was ready to trial the former Canberra half at fullback after speaking to the club's recruitment manager Peter O'Sullivan.

    "I have talked a bit about it with the coaches and I had a real good chat to Peter O'Sullivan,'' Smith said. "It was Peter who suggested we should have a think about him as a fullback. I have chatted briefly to Toddy about that so he had a chance to think about it a bit himself.''

    Playing Carney at fullback would allow captain Braith Anasta to remain at five-eighth, relieving Smith of at least one headache.


    Though it would mean a move for former NSW and Australia fullback Anthony Minichiello, the game's best No 1 before being struck down by a series of back injuries.

    O'Sullivan said of a Carney positional move: "It's worth a look. His pace, his power, his running game, along with his passing and kicking game, especially on the left-hand side of the field would make him extremely difficult to defend against.''

    The Roosters' willingness to trial Carney at the back highlights the evolution in the position. It's arguable only halfback is a more important role in modern football.

    While no one doubts Carney's ability with the ball, the bigger challenge will be acclimatising to the other demands of playing fullback.

    "The picture in my mind is certainly of the attacking aspects of the game,'' Smith said. "I couldn't see how Todd would have a problem with that. In fact, he could be made for it. There's obviously a lot of other things -- receiving kicks and defending and all that stuff.

    "We need to give him a chance to get his head around that and have a practice at it before we test him out.

    "He has a terrific, athletic body. He has speed, strength - all those items. He's done it and proven it. Being out for 18 months . . . he looks pretty good.

    "He'll look better in three or four months with a proper preparation. But he's keen, he's enthusiastic.''

    The temptation to play Carney at fullback must also be balanced against what he offers in the halves.

    In Pearce and Carney, the Roosters have two players with immense talent who can form a combination at the club for years to come. Minichiello's ability to capture his best form will also play a part in Smith's decision, although the former NSW and Australian fullback is equally at home on the wing.

  • #2
    No no no no no no no

    Comment


    • #3
      Shit.

      They get dumber every ****ing year.

      Comment


      • #4
        LOL! Dumb ass Telecrap journos reading dumbass wallster threads.

        LOL. Carney will be 5/8. Period.
        Alcohol never solved any life problems.....then again neither did milk.

        Comment


        • #5
          Perrett @ fullback

          pearce @ half

          carney @ 5/8

          Anasta @ lock

          Thats how it should be !

          Delecto Oriens est odio Meridianus
          To love Easts is to hate Souffs

          Originally posted by Bill Shankley, Liverpool FC
          At a football club, there’s a holy trinity – the players, the manager and the supporters. Directors don’t come into it. They are only there to sign the cheques.
          Originally posted by Andy Raymond Commentating Souffs V Manly 18/04/09
          The fireworks at the Easter show are making more noise than the crowd tonight

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by melon.... View Post
            LOL! Dumb ass Telecrap journos reading dumbass wallster threads.

            LOL. Carney will be 5/8. Period.
            Don't be so sure mate.

            Comment


            • #7
              Maybe the line up would be something like:

              1. Carney
              2. Minichello
              3. Perrett
              4. Graham
              5. Kenny-Dowall

              6. Anasta (c)
              7. Pearce

              8. Ryles
              9. Friend
              10. Nuuausala
              11. Cherrington
              12. Myles
              13. M.Aubusson

              14. Conn
              15. Symmonds
              16. Waera-Hargeaves
              17. Paea

              Comment


              • #8
                I'm happy for him to be tried at fullback. These days they are second five eighths anyway.

                Mini is past his best at fullback and is better for us on the wing. Even after all of his injuries he is still a better winger than Kenny-Dumb.
                Born and bred in the eastern suburbs.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Like I said, it was always going to be a tilt-a-whirl between 4 players:

                  Either

                  1. Mini/Perrett

                  3. Aubusson

                  6. Carney

                  13. Anasta

                  OR

                  1. Carney

                  3. Mini/Perrett

                  6. Anasta

                  13. Aubusson

                  Admittedly, it is good having utility value, especially in players like Perrett (who can play anywhere in the backline), Anasta (five-eighth or lock) and Aubusson (centre or lock)

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Another one:
                    http://www.smh.com.au/news/lhqnews/s...247660390.html

                    BRIAN SMITH has dropped his first bombshell as coach of the Sydney Roosters, revealing that controversial recruit Todd Carney is poised to play fullback in 2010.

                    In his first interview since taking over at Bondi Junction, Smith indicated Carney could take over the custodian role most recently shared between former Golden Boot winner Anthony Minichiello and New Zealand international Sam Perrett.

                    ''I've talked with coaches, in particular [recruitment manager] Peter O'Sullivan, and he suggested we might have a look at Toddy at fullback and let him practice there in the off-season,'' Smith said yesterday. ''That's one of the things that have come up. Braith [Anasta] has played at lock and a bit of fullback. They are probably the two that are the most flexible and versatile - as well as being amongst the two most important - players in our group.

                    ''It's something we need to sort. We may not sort it by saying, 'This is how it will be for the rest of the year', but it could be a weapon we use as we go on, to use their versatility. A lot of it will hang on if Toddy adapts and has the fullback thing covered.

                    ''A bit of it will depend on how 'Mini' goes and what he's open to. By the way, he looks fantastic at the moment. If he's on song for the early part of the season, we'll look at him playing there again as well. He's done it big time in the past. Whether he's up for that, and what is best for the team, will unfold as we practice and play some pre-season games.''

                    Carney has alternated between the halfback and five-eighth roles throughout an interrupted career but has almost no experience in the No.1 jersey. However, Smith's ploy would allow Anasta and Mitchell Pearce to remain in the halves, while Minichiello could be shifted to the wing.

                    ''It's possible,'' Smith said. ''I saw one of the games [Minichiello] played last season … on the wing and he was awesome. That's what he was initially, a winger. They're the two positions I'd like him in most. In pre-season we'll look at all that.''

                    Carney said he would be happy to play ''anywhere in the 17'' in order to revive his career. ''If it was front row, I'd take that because I just want to be back in the NRL,'' he said.

                    Smith addressed his troops for the first time at orientation last week. There were two clear messages - that off-field misbehaviour will not be tolerated, and that any talk of their disastrous wooden spoon season was banned.

                    ''There is a mini in-house rule: there is no reference to 2009,'' Smith said. ''There's not much to be gained by looking back. I'm not wanting it to be a focus. It's not about the horribilities - if that's a word - of 2009 or of any other time earlier in their life.

                    ''Anything that was some sort of an issue was dealt with by individual players and head coach [at orientation]. We're now all looking ahead.''

                    The Roosters lurched from one crisis to another last season. Smith, a noted disciplinarian, made it clear that a repeat of that behaviour would not be tolerated.

                    ''I'm going to be extremely tough on anything that we, as a staff, see as a disruption to our momentum,'' Smith said. ''Quality of performance in training is all we can do until mid-March. That's the only thing we can do right now. We can't mess it up. So my job is, if I see anybody messing it up, to right that as quickly as possible.''

                    There are still lingering questions about the make-up of Smith's squad for 2010. Former Dragons prop Jason Ryles is expected to officially join the Roosters in coming days. However, the future of Willie Mason remains unclear. Asked about Mason, who is in Japan exploring potential rugby deals, Smith said: ''Right now, all I want to say about that is that Willie is exploring other opportunities.

                    ''When he's done that and all of that is resolved, after that - not before or during that - I'll talk about it and give you some answers on that.''

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      1. Carney
                      2. Perrett
                      3. Williamson
                      4. Graham
                      5. Minichiello
                      6. Anasta
                      7. Pearce

                      Ill be satisified with that to be honest.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by Vasco View Post
                        I'm happy for him to be tried at fullback. These days they are second five eighths anyway.

                        Mini is past his best at fullback and is better for us on the wing. Even after all of his injuries he is still a better winger than Kenny-Dumb.
                        If Carney moving to fullback pushes that idiotic kiwi out of our team then at least something good has come from the move.

                        But I still would rather him at 5/8

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          I guess this is what we have trials for but realistically cannot see Carney playing Fullback.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            This is the dumbest club in the country. No matter who becomes our coach, he becomes instantly ****ing stupid. At last !! We had ALL our halves problems solved with signing of Carney. Finally we had a decent 5/8, the first since Fittler. What does our dumbarse club do ? Instead of playing him in his best spot, we pick him at fullback. FFS, nothing changes. And i honestly thought we were going places this year. I honestly thought top 5 was not out of the question.

                            FFS Another spoon coming up.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              You do realise that they've barely started training yet? A coach has got to have his options.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X