would Kevin Proctor be the right replacement for SBW

[Thirteen]

Robo obviously rates him.
SBW can't be replaced. We would only be buying Proctor to strengthen our depth.
Personally I think he is average at best.

[Rooster_6]

Proctor is not giving up a starting spot @ Melbourne to come and sign here as a depth player.

If he signs it'll be with the promise of being an integral part of our First Grade side.

[Rooster_6]

Apparently Gold Coast pulled out of the race because Proctors asking price was too high.

[Parkway_Drive]

Apparently Gold Coast pulled out of the race because Proctors asking price was too high.

And so should the Roosters..

[milanja]

Apparently Gold Coast pulled out of the race because Proctors asking price was too high.

Proctor must be laughing as hard as Steve Edmed did when the superleague war was on. No war now, which makes that supposed price even more amusing.

[mightyrooster]

I'll be gobsmacked if we sign Proctor at the expense of Moa. And disappointed.

Totally agree. Surely this signing of Proctor is way off the mark.

[mightyrooster]

I'll be gobsmacked if we sign Proctor at the expense of Moa. And disappointed.

Totally agree. Surely this supposed signing of Proctor is way off the mark.

[stephenj]

id rather save up for a genuine bid on falou!
im sure some on here want to sign benjoii to replace either of our halves?

[Rooster_6]

id rather save up for a genuine bid on falou!
im sure some on here want to sign benjoii to replace either of our halves?

I'd actually sign Benji as a centre but I suspect I'd be alone on that one

[Cockadoodledoo]

I'd actually sign Benji as a centre but I suspect I'd be alone on that one

Yeah you would.. To possibly lose Moa and then sign Proctor would be massive recruitment and retention fail.

[Johnny.]

I'd actually sign Benji as a centre but I suspect I'd be alone on that one

Hell, I've been championing the idea of Pearce being a centre. He has the skills.

[Guest]

Why is everyone acting like Proctor will be coming here for half a mill?

He can command 300-350 easily given his attributes and experience. If we get him at that price, he is a steal.

Fact of the matter is that nobody knows what he is signing for. I'm sure the current coach and management know his true value and will make a decision accordingly.

[Guest]

I'd prefer Ben Te'o who is also off contract at the end of this year plus Souths signed Stewart?

[Thirteen]

Proctor is not giving up a starting spot @ Melbourne to come and sign here as a depth player.

If he signs it'll be with the promise of being an integral part of our First Grade side.

I am not suggesting he wouldn't be an integral part of the team.

[Game Fowl]

No need for Proctor at all.

Guerra and Aubusson are better IMO.

We'd be better off upgrading the likes of Isaac Liu.

Agree back rowers are covered , up grade existing club men , no need to buy more.