SKD detractors

[Guest]

It's rather simple. The only thing you can rely on him to do, is something amateurish or stupid.

Just like your post fool.Why dont you mention Pearce kicking out on the full and turning the match manlys way.How about Maloney he was rubbish,SKD makes one error and you jump on it.

[Guest]

It's rather simple. The only thing you can rely on him to do, is something amateurish or stupid.

Just like your post fool.Why dont you mention Pearce kicking out on the full and turning the match manlys way.How about Maloney he was rubbish,SKD makes one error and you jump on it.

[Andrew Walker]

He had a good game skids. The time of the error was very costly but I think the Pearce kick out on the full was worse for the time and where we were at in dominating the ruck.

They scored the next set.

I agree But **** me he makes that error to often at that stage of the game when we are in that position

[liver1971]

Just like your post fool.Why dont you mention Pearce kicking out on the full and turning the match manlys way.How about Maloney he was rubbish,SKD makes one error and you jump on it.

I made comments about those players in other post idiot. I commented that skd is unreliable.What, you think he is? .Those other players don't make as many howlers as him Think before posting reactionary dribble Casper

[Guest]

He does one good thing for 4 bad things. He cost us badly tonight. Not the game because Pearce, Maloney and others helped, but really he has to go.

[kurtsherlock6]

I agree But **** me he makes that error to often at that stage of the game when we are in that position

When was the last time he did that and how many times has he done it this year?

Not excusing the mistake but just trying to put a bit of perspective on here.

[Andrew Walker]

When was the last time he did that and how many times has he done it this year?

Not excusing the mistake but just trying to put a bit of perspective on here.

Well Im sure he made an error aginst Mnaly early this year late in the game when 6 behind which led to them getting the final 2 points Last year aginst Warriors he not only bombed a try which would from of memory oput us in front with abouyt 15 to go which saw Warriors score But then with 10 to go an elemenatry error from hom saw Vatuvei swoop and go 85 metres for the match winning tery The previous week against Melbourne in the late stages with us trailing narrowly with a long attacking raid on the cards saw SKD drop the ball and **** the attacking raidf up ending our chances of winning

Now when You think about it there haven been that many games when we were losing by narrow margins very late in the game over the last two seasons but I HAVE POINTED OUT 4 GAMES WHERE THESE ERRORS HAVE OCCURRED IN THAT POSITION

I find it disturbing and something SKD needs to mentally apply himself to fix I dont expect him to score and win us the game Just holding the ball is astart and who knows wherwe we end up

[kurtsherlock6]

Well Im sure he made an error aginst Mnaly early this year late in the game when 6 behind which led to them getting the final 2 points Last year aginst Warriors he not only bombed a try which would from of memory oput us in front with abouyt 15 to go which saw Warriors score But then with 10 to go an elemenatry error from hom saw Vatuvei swoop and go 85 metres for the match winning tery The previous week against Melbourne in the late stages with us trailing narrowly with a long attacking raid on the cards saw SKD drop the ball and **** the attacking raidf up ending our chances of winning

Now when You think about it there haven been that many games when we were losing by narrow margins very late in the game over the last two seasons but I HAVE POINTED OUT 4 GAMES WHERE THESE ERRORS HAVE OCCURRED IN THAT POSITION

I find it disturbing and something SKD needs to mentally apply himself to fix I dont expect him to score and win us the game Just holding the ball is astart and who knows wherwe we end up

And he played most of the GF with a busted jaw & scored the go ahead try in the 2nd half, i doubt we would of won had he come off and we lost our starting centre.

And most of what you refer to is from the 1st half of last year when his form was horrid, but since then his form has been very solid.

I'd also be curious too see where he would stand in the NRL as far as number of errors go, compared to other players? He's does alot right out there and i find it a bit sad how some on here only want to focus on the negatives. Each to there own i suppose.

[Andrew Walker]

And he played most of the GF with a busted jaw & scored the go ahead try in the 2nd half, i doubt we would of won had he come off and we lost our starting centre.

And most of what you refer to is from the 1st half of last year when his form was horrid, but since then his form has been very solid.

I'd also be curious too see where he would stand in the NRL as far as number of errors go, compared to other players? He's does alot right out there and i find it a bit sad how some on here only want to focus on the negatives. Each to there own i suppose.

I am focusing on a concerning pattern that needs to be adressed You asked I answered

[kurtsherlock6]

I am focusing on a concerning pattern that needs to be adressed You asked I answered

I personally think your'e over analizing again but i'll just agree to disagree and leave it that.

[Andrew Walker]

I personally think your'e over analizing again but i'll just agree to disagree and leave it that.

How is pointing out all the errors a player has made late ina game when we are behind over analysing ? I think you are ignorant on this

[kurtsherlock6]

How is pointing out all the errors a player has made late ina game when we are behind over analysing ? I think you are ignorant on this

No i'm not, but i just try too put a bit things in a bit of perspective, which i know is too much for some of the hysterics on here.

[Tommy Smith]

I love SKDs rushing in defence which always leads to a try.

His defence is tragic at times.

[kurtsherlock6]

I love SKDs rushing in defence which always leads to a try.

His defence is tragic at times.

Actually Manly's last try came from a very poor misread in defence from Maubs, but it probably wasnt noticed because it wasnt SKD.

[Tommy Smith]

Im talking about their 2nd try in the 1st half.

SKD, as usual, rushed up like a maniac which left RTS stranded.