Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The 'Hard Nut' Roosters Team

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • The 'Hard Nut' Roosters Team

    Okay Trewhella has named his 'softest' Roosters team based around those players who he thought showed little in the way of 'testicular' fortitude, how about the team of Roosters players you would want in your team to take part in the toughest game of their life.

    I'll get the ball rolling:

    1. Luke Phillips - All courage and no fear. Regularly put his body on the line
    2. Terry Fahey - Better known as the Redfern Express, but also played a couple of seasons at Bondi. One mean dude who would rather run over the top of his opposite than run around him
    3. Mark Harris - Harris had a face that only a mother could love. He was regularly used to scare young children when he wasn't playing football
    4. Ron Gibbs - Made his name at Manly as a back rower, but he was another Rooster poached away by that cat Fulton. Any player that would try and charge down a kick using his head is a bit different and deserving of a spot in our toughest team
    5. Bill Mullins - Built like a back rower, when most wingers weren't. Powerful runner who could sink a schooner quicker than Artie could eat a meat pie.
    6. Kevin Stevens - Not the most skilful of five eighths, but this guy was successful wherever he played. Strong defender and powerful runner.
    7. Kevin Hastings - Tough as nails and didn't know when he was beaten, club legend who doesn't need any further introduction
    8. Adrian Morely - the mad Pom....who can forget his hit on Vilisanti in the 2002 GF. It wasn't so much the hit, but the way he stood above Vilisanti afterwards....eyes spinning like poker machine reels....daring another Warrior to run at him.
    9. Simon Bonetti - Petero Civoniceva is well known as having the hardest melon in the game, Bonetti can attest to that. In the 2002 Qualifying Final Bonetti had a sickening head clash with the big guy in the opening tackle of the game and was in Disneyland afterwards. True to his character, he refused to go off and stayed the duration racking up a 1000 tackles in the process
    10. Arthur Beetson - Single handedly kick started Origin by belting a club mate. When Artie hit you, you stayed hit. A true tough man of the game, when the game was truly tough.
    11. Bunny Reilly - Beetson rates him the hardest tackler and toughest player he played alongside, thats a fair wrap and will do me
    12. Hugh McGahan - Hughie was a hard but clean player. Strong defensively, and a leading light in a dark Roosters period
    13. Ron Coote - like Beetson, played in the tough era of the 60's and 70's when swinging arms and head high tackles were commonplace. Great player who was also well known for his toughness

    I'm sure there's players I missed, and I'm sure others have a different opinion, but have a crack at naming your toughest ever Roosters 13. I've restricted mine to players I've seen play.

  • #2
    Originally posted by Headless Chook View Post
    Okay Trewhella has named his 'softest' Roosters team based around those players who he thought showed little in the way of 'testicular' fortitude, how about the team of Roosters players you would want in your team to take part in the toughest game of their life.

    I'll get the ball rolling:

    1. Luke Phillips - All courage and no fear. Regularly put his body on the line
    2. Terry Fahey - Better known as the Redfern Express, but also played a couple of seasons at Bondi. One mean dude who would rather run over the top of his opposite than run around him
    3. Mark Harris - Harris had a face that only a mother could love. He was regularly used to scare young children when he wasn't playing football
    4. Ron Gibbs - Made his name at Manly as a back rower, but he was another Rooster poached away by that cat Fulton. Any player that would try and charge down a kick using his head is a bit different and deserving of a spot in our toughest team
    5. Bill Mullins - Built like a back rower, when most wingers weren't. Powerful runner who could sink a schooner quicker than Artie could eat a meat pie.
    6. Kevin Stevens - Not the most skilful of five eighths, but this guy was successful wherever he played. Strong defender and powerful runner.
    7. Kevin Hastings - Tough as nails and didn't know when he was beaten, club legend who doesn't need any further introduction
    8. Adrian Morely - the mad Pom....who can forget his hit on Vilisanti in the 2002 GF. It wasn't so much the hit, but the way he stood above Vilisanti afterwards....eyes spinning like poker machine reels....daring another Warrior to run at him.
    9. Simon Bonetti - Petero Civoniceva is well known as having the hardest melon in the game, Bonetti can attest to that. In the 2002 Qualifying Final Bonetti had a sickening head clash with the big guy in the opening tackle of the game and was in Disneyland afterwards. True to his character, he refused to go off and stayed the duration racking up a 1000 tackles in the process
    10. Arthur Beetson - Single handedly kick started Origin by belting a club mate. When Artie hit you, you stayed hit. A true tough man of the game, when the game was truly tough.
    11. Bunny Reilly - Beetson rates him the hardest tackler and toughest player he played alongside, thats a fair wrap and will do me
    12. Hugh McGahan - Hughie was a hard but clean player. Strong defensively, and a leading light in a dark Roosters period
    13. Ron Coote - like Beetson, played in the tough era of the 60's and 70's when swinging arms and head high tackles were commonplace. Great player who was also well known for his toughness

    I'm sure there's players I missed, and I'm sure others have a different opinion, but have a crack at naming your toughest ever Roosters 13. I've restricted mine to players I've seen play.
    Chris Flannery on the bench.. He gave his left nut to play for us
    ...

    Comment


    • #3
      Fitzgibbon somewhere in the 17.
      Born and bred in the eastern suburbs.

      Comment


      • #4
        Flannery and Crocker for mine both would get a run on the bench

        Comment


        • #5
          Can't agree with McGahan. Now there was an overrated player.
          What about Terry Regan and Royce Ayliffe.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by Rooster Cogburn View Post
            Can't agree with McGahan. Now there was an overrated player.
            What about Terry Regan and Royce Ayliffe.
            McGahan overrated? Geez...
            Born and bred in the eastern suburbs.

            Comment


            • #7
              Paul McCabe

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by BUDDY View Post
                Paul McCabe
                Also nobody has mentioned Freddy.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by Rooster Cogburn View Post
                  Can't agree with McGahan. Now there was an overrated player.
                  What about Terry Regan and Royce Ayliffe.
                  Seriously? He carried us for years.
                  ...

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by Vasco View Post
                    Fitzgibbon somewhere in the 17.
                    Should be in the thirteen without doubt.
                    ...

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Ray Stehr was reputedly one of the toughest blokes to pull on a jersey - though I never saw him play (as I assume no one on this forum has!).

                      How is this for his Wikipedia entry:

                      Raymond Ernest Stehr (24 January 1913 – 2 June 1983) was an Australian rugby league footballer, a state and national representative player whose club career was played at Sydney's Eastern Suburbs club. He has been named as one of the nation's finest footballers of the 20th century.

                      Early life
                      Stehr was born in the country New South Wales town of Warialda in 1913. As an eight-year-old child, he was diagnosed an incurable cripple after developing blood clots at the base of his spine. He was unable to walk for two years and spent twelve months strapped to a stretcher, completely immobilised with his back encased in a plaster cast. His family moved to Sydney in search of some kind of miracle cure and, following a visit to a Chinese herbalist, the clots began to disappear. Nevertheless, Stehr was told not to contemplate playing contact sport. Stehr defied medical opinion, becoming one of rugby league's toughest front rowers.

                      Club career
                      First recruited as a schoolboy from Randwick Boys High School by the Eastern Suburbs club in 1928, Stehr made his first-grade debut in a trial match against Newcastle ahead of the 1928 season when he was aged just 15. The following season aged just 16 years and 85 days he made his regular competition debut - still the youngest ever first-grade Australian player.

                      In 1934 Stehr joined the Mudgee club in rural NSW as a captain-coach and also captained Country in their annual clash against a Sydney representative side. Midway through the 1934 season he rejoined Easts who were defeated by Western Suburbs in the premiership decider that year. Over the next three seasons, Stehr was a member of the Eastern Suburbs side that lost just one match, winning premierships in each of those years - 1935, 1936 and 1937.

                      In 1940 Stehr was captain of the Easts side that captured its 8th premiership. Regular captain-coach Dave Brown pulled out on match day with a leg injury and Stehr led the side to a victory in the final over Canterbury-Bankstown. Following WWII in 1945, he led Eastern Suburbs to further premiership glory.

                      All told he played in 184 matches for Eastern Suburbs a then record


                      To play in the era he did, start at the age he did, WITH his medical history and STILL be considered one of the toughest men to play the game should be enough to get him in the run on side despite no one on this forum seeing him play!!!

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Honerable mention for Trevor Gilmeister despite ending his career as a dirty Bronco.

                        Honerable mention for Tony Rampling - though more thug than tough. That would have been a result of his days with the rabbits.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by Cockadoodledoo View Post
                          Should be in the thirteen without doubt.
                          Absolutely. The only player that had a go in 1990. I remember against Norths at Henson when he stayed at half way waiting for the team to come and kick off. It was about 30-0 before half time at this stage. He was filthy.
                          Born and bred in the eastern suburbs.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            no Freddy? carried us for 9 years?? remember him???

                            what was that goal kicking backrowers name...Becraft??

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by Assyrian_Pimp View Post
                              no Freddy? carried us for 9 years?? remember him???

                              what was that goal kicking backrowers name...Becraft??
                              Dennis Beecraft.

                              Was a handy goal kicker at Archies on Wednesday nights also.
                              Born and bred in the eastern suburbs.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X