Groundhog day for the softcocks yet again!

[Guest]

Why won't you answer my question?
Do you think the try should have been awarded?...(3rd time i have asked you)

Greeds, what are you on?

I said I think Graham knocked it dead with his forearm, so obviously I don't think a try should have been awarded

[Guest]

I missed watching this game.

Can someone please explain something to me.

The general consensus is that the ball went dead..Yet, many here seem to think he should have played at it...How does that work??

If he knocked it dead, wouldn't the same people be blaming Graham if the Warriors scored in the next set from the drop-out for playing at the ball that was going dead..??

Can anyone clear this up for me....??

it was way too close for him not to make a play at it before he did

if he'd knocked it dead properly, or picked it up earlier and tried to get back into the field of play, no-one would have had a problem with that

except maybe Greeds and his left nut

[Guest]

Hindsight is a wonderful thing..

These guys make a decision on the spot..

SKD's try was an insanely risky play on the last tackle..It came off for him and he gets the pats on the back. Imagine the threads this morning if he was held up..
I just watched the highlights and I was in agreement with the video ref that the ball was short of the deadball line when Locke got his hand to it.

A definate mistake from Phil Graham. Had it rolled another 1cm, it would have been a great decision to leave it..

agree that there would have been a tonne of threads about it, but only because it was skd
in reality it would be turning over posession 100m away from your try line, which is a better result then the countless grubbers or bombs that give away 20m taps

[Guest]

Greeds, what are you on?

I said I think Graham knocked it dead with his forearm, so obviously I don't think a try should have been awarded

Nothing Unfortunately!!
I gave up the wacky tobaccy a few months ago actually!
I understand what your your saying about taking the risk, but i think we can all agree that this is a game of inches.People take risks like that all the time.He was just UNLUCKY that the man in the box was a rooster hater.Like i said before...If there was ANYONE else in that box and it was dis-allowed, people would be calling him a genius!
P.S Lefty says G'day!!!