Rothfield defends Benji takes shots at Carney again

[Guest]

Trying to predict player punishment is harder than winning Lotto.

Because every incident is different, Einstein.

[Guest]

Notice how we can't leave a comment on this one? That wouldn't suit his agenda now would it?

I expect because apart from the brainless masses who agree with his crap he'd get an overwhelming reminder that if he thinks it's OK or excusable to punch someone in the face because you don't like what they say, Slothfield himself would shortly be lying in a hospital bed.

[Guest]

on Manly: the NRLs punishment was a ridiuclous overreaction, and dishonest as well. 4 weeks for getting drunk at a club function? **** off. It was clearly for the assault charge. Has any other player drunk, OR on an assault charge been stood down by the NRL? No. Speaking of, iirc Jake Friend remains the only player to be deregistered for drink driving.

on Carney: fair punishment for a borderline non issue.

on Benji: Should be commended for smacking a obvious dickhead in the mouth

[Guest]

Roachfield strikes again.
he is a dead set goose, talk about double standards much. Yes carney was caught being over the limit for a p plater, but nobody was injured or in danger of being injured. And Roachfield calls for sacking or suspension, while benji has every right to go smack a guy in the mouth cause he got taunted a little bit. Both benji and the taunter should both grow up, if you trying to provoke somebody dont whinge about getting hit, but if benji cant take it he should just show them his bank account and laugh at them while walking away. Id be surprised if benji even gets a fine for this, but to hear roachfield saying let him off just screams of double standards against our club.

[The Brain]

Brett Stewart is preparing a defamation case against NEWS LT so their agenda is up the shit .
I think the boy is finished

[Guest]

My favourite bit is
'What happened to Brett Stewart should never be allowed happen again'

I agree with Rothfield on this. However, Rothfield last week was saying Carney should be severley punished because Stewart got 4 weeks. Can't have it both ways Rothfiled.

[BUDDY]

My favourite bit is
'What happened to Brett Stewart should never be allowed happen again'

I agree with Rothfield on this. However, Rothfield last week was saying Carney should be severley punished because Stewart got 4 weeks. Can't have it both ways Rothfiled.

Let's get it right. Rothfield, for Carney blowing a low range reading of 0.052, said that Carney should be spending time in jail.

[Spirit of 66]

...we would like to see him as soylent green.

But Rothfield isn't made of the right stuff to be soylent green:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Sp-VFBbjpE

[Tom Verlaine's Ghost]

Like my self Marshall has to learn to turn the other cheek.

Why do you get heckled, Brain?

[Guest]

Marshall has been baited a few times.
Hit them before they hit you ?Im fine with that .
If the guy left the joint and marshall went after him then thats a premeditated assualt or what ever you want to call it.
Personally the whinger should man up and take it on the chin .If Marshal wasnt a footballer i guarantee the bloke wouldnt of went to the cops .
Like my self Marshall has to learn to turn the other cheek.
Fined by the club would do.

Some common sense finally.

[Chook Norris]

I hope Rothfield gets to be the NRL's "face of the game" next year........


here's hoping he gets hit by a truck in doing so

[Guest]

I hope Rothfield gets to be the NRL's "face of the game" next year........


here's hoping he gets hit by a truck in doing so

He'd be the "arse of the game" methinks.

[Guest]

He'd be the "arse of the game" methinks.

arse-face of the game

[Guest]

arse-face of the game

The seminal character from Preacher.

[Guest]

When braith got king hit a while back in Double Bay, he had the presence of mind to get up and not cause a further scene.

Why couldn't benji?

Adding to that, they are now saying benji was sober......Anger management issue much????

Rothfield will say that benji should not be punished, how many more incidents like this will there be before they are punished !

Carney was punished, Rothfield is pissed off that it was not to his standard.

Benji, and those with him, were far far far from being sober on the night.......




far.