Is it time to start milking penalties???

[2026]

Seems like every other team is doing it.

Our good sportsmanship combined with the customary lopsided penalty count is giving most teams a 10 point start every game.

We played last years preliminary final in the correct spirit of the game and look how far it got us.

[BUDDY]

It's time refs send players to be tested if they are unable to get up. That will stop the milking.

[2026]

It's time refs send players to be tested if they are unable to get up. That will stop the milking.

In some cases there is no concussion, however a penalty should be awarded for high contact..You shouldn't then lose a player for 15 minutes.This is rewarding the other team.

[BUDDY]

If a player can't get up then aren't they supposed to put them through a test now? If they are hit high and aren't concussed they should be able to get up and play the ball. If the ref misses the high shot then the review committee won't. I put forward the case of Bargearrse vs SBW although the review committee failed in this case.

[2026]

If a player can't get up then aren't they supposed to put them through a test now? If they are hit high and aren't concussed they should be able to get up and play the ball. If the ref misses the high shot then the review committee won't. I put forward the case of Bargearrse vs SBW although the review committee failed in this case.

So should you only be awarded a penalty if the player is concussed?

[BUDDY]

So should you only be awarded a penalty if the player is concussed?

Only if one of the four officials on the field see it. Like when one of the four officials see all the penalties that we are receiving.

[2026]

Only if one of the four officials on the field see it. Like when one of the four officials see all the penalties that we are receiving.

Agree.

The vidoe ref should not be used if a player stays down and it's missed by the other 4 muppets.

It doesn't help our cause though as the window is ajar and rules won't be changed this season

Where not the same team as 2013 that could blow the opposition away. 1 or 2 extra penalties a game could make all the difference.

[roosterproud]

Seems like every other team is doing it.

Our good sportsmanship combined with the customary lopsided penalty count is giving most teams a 10 point start every game.

We played last years preliminary final in the correct spirit of the game and look how far it got us.

don't just set the standard be the standard

[Bigchook]

Seems like every other team is doing it.

Our good sportsmanship combined with the customary lopsided penalty count is giving most teams a 10 point start every game.

We played last years preliminary final in the correct spirit of the game and look how far it got us.

No.

[2026]

No.

Can i put it another way then Bigchook.

1) Continue playing in the correct spirit of the game and finish 2nd or 3rd 4th - Walk with your head held high knowing you've done the right thing, However no lollies.
or
2) Stay down and receive the penalty that your rightfully entitled to for high contact. Therefore competing on a level playing field and increasing your chances of winning the comp.

[Guest]

I have a suggestion how about a few of the bro's here in the Pen go to the referee school or get their kids to be refs. Short term pain long term gain I say.. 😉

[alex0063]

Yes Yes Yes and Yes this is a must i believe is a reason we do not get as many Penalties

[Guest]

[Guest]

Yes Yes Yes and Yes this is a must i believe is a reason we do not get as many Penalties

Do you prefer the superman dive, swan dive, or should we recruit some Souffs vermin?

I don't think our bro's have it in them to dive.

Glenn Stewart perfect fit for that scummy football club.

[Guest]

K-F-I-L, Filthy Ralph pretending to be Beguurk inspired by Kegs. Nice one bro'!