judiciary discussion Maloney/Moa/Napa/Jennings/SST

[fletch]

there will be 5 incidents looked at on Monday concerning our players

Maloney - for sticking his leg out, best case scenario grade 1 trip and he plays with early guilty plea, worst case gets charged with kicking and misses the first final

Moa - I think he is in trouble for his shot in the opening minutes on Stewart, given his track record a careless grade 1 would result in a 1 week suspension

Napa - crusher tackle, shouldn't have anything to worry about because there wasn't a second action to put pressure on the neck, but his fete rests with the MRP now

Jennings - shouldn't have anything to worry about with his lifting tackle

SST - also some concerns over a lifting tackle, should be right but like Napa his fete is in the MRP hands now.


the verdict Moa misses next week and the rest should be right to play.

[Johnny.]

It depends on how much the NRL wants the Guppies to win the comp.

[Darkone]

In the spirit of finals time none of above will be suspended

[Tommy Smith]

*fate

My verdict: all will play next week.

Maloney will get a grade 1 tripping charge. Moa should be fine, it was soft. The biggest worry are the lifting tackles as they're going overkill on that this year. Napa 's crusher was a joke, but then they've gone overboard on that too.

They should all go to court and change their names to Burgess in time for the MRPs decision. Then they'll be fine.

[John Corey]

They were just flesh wounds.

[Jacks Fur Coat]

I don't think any of the guys should have concerns... Otherwise its petticoats and powdered noses and tickle fights.

Not Rugby League..

[Headless Chook]

Just watched it again. there is no way you could call it a kick so hopefully he will be ok

[Tommy Smith]

It hasn't been Rugby League for a few year, Jack!

I'm worried. It's been the Year of the Innocuous Charge.

[milanja]

Sams was a decent hit, given that stewart was falling, i still think he will be out.

Napa- should be dismissed without fronting.

MJ and SST, not much in that.

Maloney, not even sure what the charge will be, brain explosion.

[Vasco]

Depends on how hard Rothfield goes at us.

Especially if we play the Sharks.

[BUDDY]

Imagine the dogs supporters reaction if BBQ gets off.

[Vasco]

Just saw them on Fox.

If any miss a match then the game has become a joke.

[Hawkeye]

Just saw them on Fox.

If any miss a match then the game has become a joke.

Hate to say it, but the problem is that the game has already become a joke, that's why we all have concerns about losing some of our guys for next week !

[Burnt Rooster]

There was no force in the leg as it came in contact , with the upper legs of the Souths player, but it was still a dumb play by Maloney, just something hde has in his game, he always goves away a couple of dumb penalties every game.

[Thirteen]

Depends on how hard Rothfield goes at us.

Especially if we play the Sharks.

He wishes he was that influential.