judiciary discussion Maloney/Moa/Napa/Jennings/SST

[Andrew Walker]

Felch has always been a troublemaker. It's one of the reasons I like him.

lol Felch Good one johnny hahaha

[The Axe]

I just watched the full replay. We have nothing to fear. Both incidents deserve to be on report but should not attract charges

[fletch]

Mate only Napa and Maloney were placed on report.

And yes i know this is an open forum and it probably wont make a scrap of difference, but why highlight incidents that haven't even rated a mention anywhere else??

lol you might want to go back and watch the channel 9 coverage, it was Rabs that made sure he highlighted the Moa hit and Sterlo was the one that mentioned the SST tackle looked ugly, I'm sure they hold much more weight in the media spotlight than a nobody like me.

I still think Moa will cop a grade 1 careless charge and miss week 1 of the finals, we only have to go back to 2013 to see the stupid piss weak elbowing charge that ruled JWH out of the first final against the Eagles as a precedent.

obviously will be happy if we miss no one, not sure why some get so upset when possibilities of potential outcomes are discussed.

[Tommy Smith]

Moa will be fine. Hodges did worse Thursday night. Not that that should make us feel at ease.

It's still the lifting tackle and the crusher that worry me the most. Not because there was anything in them, but because of my lack of faith in Michael Buettner.

[kurtsherlock6]

lol you might want to go back and watch the channel 9 coverage, it was Rabs that made sure he highlighted the Moa hit and Sterlo was the one that mentioned the SST tackle looked ugly, I'm sure they hold much more weight in the media spotlight than a nobody like me.

I still think Moa will cop a grade 1 careless charge and miss week 1 of the finals, we only have to go back to 2013 to see the stupid piss weak elbowing charge that ruled JWH out of the first final against the Eagles as a precedent.

obviously will be happy if we miss no one, not sure why some get so upset when possibilities of potential outcomes are discussed.

Gee you really are a miserable paranoid so and so. We've just won our 3rd straight minor premiership and all you,ve been doing is talking negatives. Anyway enjoy the rest of your weekend...... if you can.

[Thirteen]

lol you might want to go back and watch the channel 9 coverage, it was Rabs that made sure he highlighted the Moa hit and Sterlo was the one that mentioned the SST tackle looked ugly, I'm sure they hold much more weight in the media spotlight than a nobody like me.

I still think Moa will cop a grade 1 careless charge and miss week 1 of the finals, we only have to go back to 2013 to see the stupid piss weak elbowing charge that ruled JWH out of the first final against the Eagles as a precedent.

obviously will be happy if we miss no one, not sure why some get so upset when possibilities of potential outcomes are discussed.

As much as I can't stand old fossil Warren, I don't think he is responsible for editing footage and deciding what gets shown.

[Vasco]

Gee you really are a miserable paranoid so and so. We've just won our 3rd straight minor premiership and all you,ve been doing is talking negatives. Anyway enjoy the rest of your weekend...... if you can.

I don't think fletch is being miserable at all.

We are in trouble if Maloney is suspended.

[milanja]

I don't think fletch is being miserable at all.

We are in trouble if Maloney is suspended.

Really wonder who would be in the halves if maloney got a week, sheck and hastings? Who plays fullback then?

[2026]

Really wonder who would be in the halves if maloney got a week, sheck and hastings? Who plays fullback then?

Hastings and Friendy with Maubs at 9

soz

[Tommy Smith]

Under no circumstances would RTS move from fullback.

It'd probably be Maubs and we'd try to bash the opposition into submission. Or as a smokey play Fergo there as a running 5/8 with Elliot at centre.

[Guest]

Imagine the dogs supporters reaction if BBQ gets off.

Reynolds had 3 offenses before he even got suspended, billy skaters karate kick to the chest was 10 times worse, Maloney has nothing to worry about

[Hawkeye]

If Maloney is missing, w e don't have a ready made replacement, so then obviously Trobbo wont want to be blooding anyone new to first grade at this stage of the year.
Sheck would be the best fit in at 5/8 but it would be ridiculous to move him from the back, then to me the next best fit at no.6 would be Friend. has a bit of a kicking game, and his role at dummy half can be filled by McIlrick and Maubs.

[GC6]

Most likely it would be Maubs in at 5/8 with RTS playing 5/8 in attack then fullback in defence and Maubs basically being another forward out there.

[GC6]

But fingers crossed everyone gets off!!!

[mightyrooster]

Brad Walter is reporting that Jimmy will be charged with a grade 1 tripping charge and will be free to play. I have no idea if he's just speculating or has inside info. Hope he is right though. I thought with no Monday game this week they may have put the charges out earlier than usual but guess not.