Cummins

[bondi paul]

nice work rooster - 6. I recall i posted after our sfs loss to the sharks that refs will smother the penalty bias by actually allowing the opposition to play offside and with niggle tactics as evident of the sharks and drizzle style of game. i think cummin$ gave us one second half penalty in fridays semi.

[Johnny Tobin]

In the past 24 months.

Win Percentage without Ben Cummins = 77.3%
Win Percentage with Ben Cummins = 14.3%

Penalty Counts won = 0%
Penalty Counts Drawn = 0%
Penalty Counts Lost = 100%
Penalties received = 34
Penalties Against = 59

Thanks.

I put it in on Twitter with #SackCummins.

I would not be surprised if Souffs is exactly the opposite.

[The Axe]

In the past 24 months.

Win Percentage without Ben Cummins = 77.3%
Win Percentage with Ben Cummins = 14.3%

Penalty Counts won = 0%
Penalty Counts Drawn = 0%
Penalty Counts Lost = 100%
Penalties received = 34
Penalties Against = 59

Thanks R^.
Just shared this with J Gibbs for tomorrow night's show. Worth listening to. Johnny always publishes my posts
Axe

[The Axe]

Can I suggest for someone on twitter to share this with Rothfield.
He does not publish email addresses.
Beetroot was a supporter of our referee bias earlier this year. Keep feeding him please

[Thirteen]

In the past 24 months.

Win Percentage without Ben Cummins = 77.3%
Win Percentage with Ben Cummins = 14.3%

Penalty Counts won = 0%
Penalty Counts Drawn = 0%
Penalty Counts Lost = 100%
Penalties received = 34
Penalties Against = 59

How many of our games has he refereed in past 24 months?

[Andrew Walker]

No offence but If we are going to do this lets do it properly The part saying we havent won a penalty count under Cummins in the last 24 months is false We won the penalty count in the Grand Final of 2013 which is within the last 24 months Maybe you meant since the start of last season To answer someone elses question of how many games Cummins has reffed in that period with the percentage stats of wins and losses I would say it has to have been 7 games of which we have won just 1 I worked this out myself yesterday what the win loss ratio was when JT said we had won 1 out of our last 7 under him Mind you I am sure if we waited another 3 weeks or a little more then it would be precisely true

[Johnny Tobin]

Can I suggest for someone on twitter to share this with Rothfield.
He does not publish email addresses.
Beetroot was a supporter of our referee bias earlier this year. Keep feeding him please

Rothwit blocked me ages ago.

[Andrew Walker]

The whole second half Harris was marking Fergo. Yet Jake and Maloney kept taking the ball left. The one time it comes to Hastings on the right and they give it to Fergo he scored. They should have been doing it the whole second half.

I sat behind the goals where Melbourne ran to in the 2nd half and I would say every single kick they put in the 2nd half except maybe 1 or two was to the Jennings side of the field Meaning we were working it off our line from the side of the field that we wanted to (or should have been) running it to This does make it a little difficult to shift the ball to that side when we are pinned in that corner In fact the one I am sure of that went to the other corner Im pretty sure thats when we scored

This is where players like Smith and Cronk are very smart they knew they had a weakness but pinned us in the corner where the weakness was making it hard for us to exploit the weakness

[2026]

No offence but If we are going to do this lets do it properly The part saying we havent won a penalty count under Cummins in the last 24 months is false We won the penalty count in the Grand Final of 2013 which is within the last 24 months Maybe you meant since the start of last season To answer someone elses question of how many games Cummins has reffed in that period with the percentage stats of wins and losses I would say it has to have been 7 games of which we have won just 1 I worked this out myself yesterday what the win loss ratio was when JT said we had won 1 out of our last 7 under him Mind you I am sure if we waited another 3 weeks or a little more then it would be precisely true

He was the pocket ref in the 2013 GF so Hayne could over rule any of his BS decisions.

His other specialty is offering free coaching to the opposition during the game rather than penalising them.

[Andrew Walker]

He was the pocket ref in the 2013 GF so Hayne could over rule any of his BS decision.

His other specialty is offering free coaching to the opposition during the game rather than penalising.

Sorry it doesnt work like that I saw the pocket ref over rule Cummins the other night early in the 2nd half when he called knock on against Melbourne As I said if we are going to do this we need to do it properly the minute we falsify things our credibility on this goes out the window AS i said its only a matter of weeks till the 24 months will be true

[darcy]

In one of the games earlier this year, when they did the pre-game Captain's coin toss, with Cummins as ref, the handshaking and pleasantries took place afterwards...

Anyway, Pearce and the other captain shook hands, the opposition captain shook Cummins hand and Pearce - intentionally or not - just turned away from Cummins, who then gave the most awkward look. I distinctly remember this incident.

You could just sense the tension between the camps. I think it's clear we don't like him and he certainly doesn't like us.

And he's basically the NRLs secret weapon to torpedo our boys.

Time to sue the ref, the NRL and the ARL Commission.

The trial would be very interesting.

It's the only way to stop them.

[darcy]

No chance Cummins will referee another game this year after seeing the brand of footy played tonight with normal ruck speeds.

He'll referee our game against the Dogs Fri night.
He, or one of his clones.

[ROC181]

We can whinge all we like about cummins but what have we learned about it? Is the team going to go into next game where he's the ref like lambs to slaughter or is Trent going to put pressure before the game on him to get him to officiate the game on our terms? No point having another whinge after another loss. I have a strong feeling he will be second ref to Sutton on the GF.

[The Axe]

We can whinge all we like about cummins but what have we learned about it? Is the team going to go into next game where he's the ref like lambs to slaughter or is Trent going to put pressure before the game on him to get him to officiate the game on our terms? No point having another whinge after another loss. I have a strong feeling he will be second ref to Sutton on the GF.

What, ROC181, to reward Cummins they'll give him the pocket in the GF?? Bring in the "Integrity" Unit...

[ROC181]

What, ROC181, to reward Cummins they'll give him the pocket in the GF?? Bring in the "Integrity" Unit...

Wasn't he the pocket ref in last years gf? He was probably 'in the pocket ' as well... 😏