Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Benji admits that Saints are coached to stay down

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Benji admits that Saints are coached to stay down

    T’S the unwritten law that seems to be being broken more and more by NRL players to gain an advantage.
    Plus, why is one Kangaroos forward uncertain about his selection in the national side?
    Catch all the latest rugby league news in Media Watch!
    THE RULE PLAYERS ARE EXPLOITING
    St George Illawarra halfback Benji Marshall has made the extraordinary admission NRL coaches are telling their players to lay down in the hope of earning a penalty.
    The Dragons have been accused of milking penalties in the wake of a heated Anzac Day match against Sydney Roosters on Monday in which four of Trent Robinson’s men were placed on report.
    When questioned about the tactic Marshall initially pointed to the cases of teammates Mitch Rein and Taane Milne who were both forced from the field genuinely injured, and Roosters opponents reported in the aftermath.
    But the Red V playmaker went on to concede players are being told to take advantage of the flaw in the system which allows the new bunker to watch slow-motion replays immediately during games.
    “The rule is if you make contact with the head you are more than likely going to get a penalty,” Marshall told NRL 360.
    “The coaches will say it, they say if you get hit in the head stay down because you know it’s going to go up (to the bunker).
    “I don’t know if I’ve done it.
    “It’s within the rules, and until they take it out it will be there forever. Every team is guilty of it.”
    Cronulla veteran Michael Ennis denied Sharks coach Shane Flanagan had ever instructed his players to milk penalties.
    “Shane Flanagan never coaches us to stay down. It’s a personal thing,” Ennis told the panel.
    But Ennis says the players may be shooting themselves in the foot if they do lay down after a tackle.
    “I’m seeing a lot now the referees telling the players to play the ball if they do stay down,” he said.
    “You run the risk of losing that momentum if you are starting to gain some and you get a clip, thinking do I stay down and get a penalty here?
    “If I stay down and don’t get one the defensive line freshens up then you lose the momentum you just gained.”
    http://www.foxsports.com.au/nrl/nrl-...1419dfc3a5d563

  • #2
    This is the direct influence of soccer.

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by Braith Anasta's Wallet View Post
      This is the direct influence of soccer.
      It's also the (focus on the subject now) the direct influence of our coach Robbo raising it at the presser. Well done Robbo!

      Comment


      • #4
        No it's not as he has been saying the same thing since season 2013

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by Braith Anasta's Wallet View Post
          No it's not as he has been saying the same thing since season 2013
          I realise that but in 2013 did he raise it in a provocative press conference on a big game day where the media is forced to actually report it in detail? A press conference where we are heavily fined and the media is forced to report it thoroughly thus generating LOTS of discusiion.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by Braith Anasta's Wallet View Post
            This is the direct influence of soccer.
            Ironically soccer is clamping down on this behavior.

            Born and bred in the eastern suburbs.

            Comment


            • #7
              Soccer has a few things right.

              -Yellow card and foul against a player deemed to be 'simulating' in attempts to draw a foul
              -If a player stays down and requires treatment, they are moved out of play, adn not allowed to come back on till the next break in play. Leaving them down to 10 men, unless a sub is used. Imagine if this was applied in Rugby League, if a player stays down to draw a penalty they are either; taken off with an interchange, or moved to the side of the field and play will commence for a few minutes until the next break in play.
              This would stop players laying down 'needing treatment' attempting to draw a penalty

              The fact that players cop a knock and beapparently knocked out, but then can resume play without a concussion test really bugs me

              Comment


              • #8
                its not just about the penalty its about a free interchange as well
                The Internet is a place for posting silly things
                Try and be serious and you will look stupid
                sigpic

                Comment


                • #9
                  Dragons players definitely , and I think the worst is in the league is Darius Boyd.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    it cost us two interchange v merge because we didnt lay down. Jayden early in the game and then maubs,
                    1911 1912 1913 1923 1935 1936 1937 1940 1945 1974 1975 2002 2013 2018 2019 2020

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by roosterproud View Post
                      it cost us two interchange v merge because we didnt lay down. Jayden early in the game and then maubs,
                      And Aiden. That one was so bad the player is copping two weeks.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by Johnny Tobin View Post

                        And Aiden. That one was so bad the player is copping two weeks.


                        JT, was that one even put on report at the time or was it picked up by the MRC ?

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by Steven Hickey View Post
                          Soccer has a few things right.

                          -Yellow card and foul against a player deemed to be 'simulating' in attempts to draw a foul
                          -If a player stays down and requires treatment, they are moved out of play, adn not allowed to come back on till the next break in play. Leaving them down to 10 men, unless a sub is used. Imagine if this was applied in Rugby League, if a player stays down to draw a penalty they are either; taken off with an interchange, or moved to the side of the field and play will commence for a few minutes until the next break in play.
                          This would stop players laying down 'needing treatment' attempting to draw a penalty

                          The fact that players cop a knock and beapparently knocked out, but then can resume play without a concussion test really bugs me
                          Spot on. It should be exactly the same in league.

                          Soccer is putting league to shame.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by Game Fowl View Post



                            JT, was that one even put on report at the time or was it picked up by the MRC ?

                            MRC - because Aiden got straight up and played the ball. Joel Thompson is on twitter moaning about it and I replied saying I can't even remember it because our player didn't dive.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by mightyrooster View Post

                              I realise that but in 2013 did he raise it in a provocative press conference on a big game day where the media is forced to actually report it in detail? A press conference where we are heavily fined and the media is forced to report it thoroughly thus generating LOTS of discusiion.
                              He raised it on Anzac Day one season.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X