Manly

[milanja]

If we would meet Parra in the prelim, it would remind me of 2013 against the Knights, same result I hope

More so if we play the cowboys.

[stringaz]

Ha what the Robert "it touched his forearm and went forward, but that's not a knock on" Lui? Or the "Keep talking and you'll go - go where?!" Cowboys?

[rented tracksuit]

Manly were rorted but anyway stiff sh*t lol....

robbed? I would say violated in a way that would make Ron Jeremy proud.

[Ray Stehr]

Manly like the Dragons are rubbish. Losing to them was embarrassing.

[Thirteen]

Can't disagree with anything that Barrett said in the press conference. He is right. Decisions being made by the bunker are a disgrace. Maybe they should consider X players to do the job. I don't know if that would make the difference, but something needs to change. There is too much at stake to have some idiot in a box ruin someone's season.

[HEGtheROOSTER]

Still hate them for stealing all our players in the early 80's so I always love it when they lose. Particularly a final....

[Hawkeye]

Just on the bleating on whether Peachey touched it or not. Only he really knows if he touched it or not, looks like he probably just grazed it BUT funny how things take time (sometimes years) to even out.
Go back several years, same ground, same weekend and remember Manly beating the Cowboys and the winning try Keiran Foran got a hand to a ball that everyone could see he knocked forward (all except the video ref) and Manly were awarded the try and won the game and ending the Cowboys season.

[HBK]

there was no clear evidence either way so they had to stick with the onfield call. if they had sent it to the bunker as no try then it would have remained as a no try.

but if you're stuck in a 6v7 matchup, and are needing a 50/50 call to go your way then you don't deserve to win the premiership

[The ticket]

Barrett is a whining turd, pinhead cheery-evans is the most hateable footballer since vautin and dylan walker is a tool

just three reasons that the video ref got it 100% right

[The ticket]

Just on the bleating on whether Peachey touched it or not. Only he really knows if he touched it or not, looks like he probably just grazed it BUT funny how things take time (sometimes years) to even out.
Go back several years, same ground, same weekend and remember Manly beating the Cowboys and the winning try Keiran Foran got a hand to a ball that everyone could see he knocked forward (all except the video ref) and Manly were awarded the try and won the game and ending the Cowboys season.

Two thumbs up hawkeye

[Bmw06i]

Did you all catch the post interview with DCE saying he saw with his own eyes and swears Peachy touched it with his fingers, when you look at the reply DCE is behind Peachy and couldn't be in a view to see, therefore he is a lying turd.


Another example why he is one of the biggest disliked players in the NRL.

[elo]

It was a dud call but nowhere near as bad as Foran's hand of god as Hawkeye mentioned.

As soon as Peachey motioned to catch the ball with his left hand and it propelled forward off his torso it's a knock on for me, 100/100 called a knock on anywhere else on the field whether it touches the hand or not, but slow motion from The Bunker and well we get that joke of a try.

[easts4eva]

For some reason they managed to find an angle where you can definitely see Peachys hand touch the ball only 12hrs late lol.

[roosterproud]

remembering the similar call against canberra i think. The ball was passed to the chest of the winger and knocked forward. he picks the ball up and ruins down the line to score. knocked on if played at or not should remain a knock on. except unless its against manly silver spoon chokers

[Spirit of 66]

For some reason they managed to find an angle where you can definitely see Peachys hand touch the ball only 12hrs late lol.

Did they? That must explain why Peachey has changed his story - in an on-field interview he said he didn't touch it, but has since said he doesn't know if he touched it.

No "conspiracy theory", but I do wonder if officials might be subconsciously influenced by the speculation about a possible Manly's salary cap breach. It would be a disaster for the NRL if Manly advanced and then were found to have cheated.