BJ Soliola

[Guest]

It will take Smith another year to work out he is the worst centre in the NRL.

[Guest]

He's had two games there, he's only young, farking hell

[Guest]

And that is the problem. Smith will agree with you and give him a full season at centre before he realises what most of us already know. The guy does not have the speed or mobility to be an outside back.

Even Glen Stewart stepped him with ease.

[Guest]

You know what, I'm sick of that excuse.... this guy has been missing tackles, coming in when he should stay out, staying out when he should come in since last year... hell, he handed Nightingale 2 tries in the GF last year.

I'm not saying get rid of him but he needs be moved closer to the action, somewhere where he can just tackle without having to make too many decisions... he just doesn't have it in defence.

[Guest]

He's been playing out of f*cking position his whole first grade career, i will judge him next year when hes at centre and not in the worse team in the comp

[Chook Norris]

time to stop defending this bloke. Undoubtedly, he has the talent.. but its time to get out of the backline

[Guest]

He's been playing out of f*cking position his whole first grade career, i will judge him next year when hes at centre and not in the worse team in the comp

He is still playing out of position. He should be in the 2nd row for Newtown.

[Guest]

And who takes his position? Naughton? J Carney?

[Guest]

I would have said Linnett, but apparently we don't need him because BJ is going to be a superstar one day.

Graham, Carney, Maubs, Symonds, anyone is better than BJ. FMD even Masoe is quicker than BJ.

[Guest]

Grahams playing on the wing.
To suggest Carney/Symonds over BJ on current form is laughable

[bondi-boy]

He's had two games there, he's only young, farking hell

Correct.

Coach him!

[Guest]

Smith has fallen asleep again.

Leilua could be a very good centre.

Unfortunately he will not receive proper coaching until next year at the earliest.

[Guest]

it will take smith another year to work out he is the worst centre in the nrl.

you're an idiot

[Game Fowl]

If he is half as good as some of you make out then the answer is simple- a decent coach would take the decision making out of his hands, get him to go forward and early hit the player with the ball as hard as you can, let the line adjust behind you cause they know what he is doing. He currently gets caught flat footed after holding a straight line and waiting for someone else to commit, another idea would be to communicate who you want to tackle then at least you get some one. Between him and Braith they let in at least 5 tries today alone.

[Rocky Rhodes]

He's had two games there, he's only young, farking hell

Here is a scoop champ, half the NRL is friggin young so get over that friggin old young excuse. Half the NRL is young but not friggin useless like this pretender. BTW, he has played 4 games as centre so get ya facts right.....

His defensive reads where appauling like in the GF which turned that game. Linnett is twice the player than this baffoon. At least Linnett has a brain.