I cannot see how Carney can stay

[bondi-boy]

Not really.....the telegraph are idiots.

What has though is looking through our results with him in this attitude, and he did more damage to us on the field wearing our jersey than he could do wearing someone elses.

You didn't mind basking in his glory last year.

[Guest]

You didn't mind basking in his glory last year.

Who cares.

We owe him nothing.

[melon....]

You didn't mind basking in his glory last year.

Who didnt?

Seriously.....he is damaged goods this year...what guarantee have you got he will come good for us? You dont have one. Why keep him when he is causing more damage to the team.

Do you expect him to come good?? I did too. But then I woke up and realised the little turd doesnt want to be here.

Great player when he wants to play. Problem is he didnt want to all season, and screwed our preparation and results followed.

I want nothing more than to have a player with Carney's superior skill. Nothing more. But not if he wont use it.

You can keep the love affair going if you like.

For the record Im not angry that he went drinking. Im angry that it shows he doesnt care. he is exactly what Mason was to us. He'll end up the same.

[novice chook]

You just have to look how poor we were travelling last season until Anasta was replaced by Carney at 5/8th.

That was a good year compared to the one currently being experienced so don't whinge.

From memory, we had a bright start to 2010, even with Braith having virtually no preseason due to his ankle injury.

NC

[bondi-boy]

Who didnt?

Seriously.....he is damaged goods this year...what guarantee have you got he will come good for us? You dont have one. Why keep him when he is causing more damage to the team.

Do you expect him to come good??

Yes, with proper management from the Club.

It needs to be established first, by asking him a series of serious questions, if he really, really, really wants to be here and nowehere else...or not.

If he does...then keep him.
If he doesn't, then bid him farewell.

He was injured all this year.

[novice chook]

Yes, with proper management from the Club.

It needs to be established first, by asking him a series of serious questions, if he really, really, really wants to be here and nowehere else...or not.

If he does...then keep him.
If he doesn't, then bid him farewell.

He was injured all this year.

And you reckon he would be honest with the Club - that'd be a first for 2011.

The bloke has bare faced lied to everyone from magistrates, to the board, to team mates, to sponsors, the NRL, the list goes on.

And suddenly you expect him to tell the truth and bare his soul - go figure.


NC

[Spanner in the works]

People ask a lot of questions. People say a lot of things. But actions speak louder than words.

[bondi-boy]

And you reckon he would be honest with the Club - that'd be a first for 2011.

The bloke has bare faced lied to everyone from magistrates, to the board, to team mates, to sponsors, the NRL, the list goes on.

And suddenly you expect him to tell the truth and bare his soul - go figure.


NC

Lies?

Or made promises that he broke?

[Chook Norris]

Enough is enough. I don't understand why people still want to help him when the bloke himself refuses to be helped. I can't stand to go through another season like this especially with the time bomb that is our five eighth

[novice chook]

Lies?

Or made promises that he broke?

I would class them as lies, I don't remember hearing the word 'promise' in any of his declarations to get his act together.

NC

[Spanner in the works]

Lies? Broken promises? Does it matter? No matter which way you look at it he should not have being on the sauce...

[bondi-boy]

Lies? Broken promises? Does it matter? No matter which way you look at it he should not have being on the sauce...

Lies and broken promises are two different things.

The sauce ban was ill-advised.

[bondi-boy]

I would class them as lies, I don't remember hearing the word 'promise' in any of his declarations to get his act together.

NC

The declarations were basically promises.

Being perfect is like trying to lose weight.

[mightyrooster]

Lies and broken promises are two different things.

The sauce ban was ill-advised.

The alcohol ban was probably a blessing in disguise rather than ill advised. If he's been carrying on like this all year and it's been kept behind closed doors, imagine how it's been affecting the team. Well you don't have to imagine, just look at the results. Getting it out in the open (even if the way the Telecrap did it was disgraceful) has forced the club to deal with it with more force than they obviously were befire.

[bondi-boy]

The alcohol ban was probably a blessing in disguise rather than ill advised. If he's been carrying on like this all year and it's been kept behind closed doors, imagine how it's been affecting the team. Well you don't have to imagine, just look at the results. Getting it out in the open (even if the way the Telecrap did it was disgraceful) has forced the club to deal with it with more force than they obviously were befire.

If that's the case the club should've done something about it a lot sooner...like put him on a 'leash' with an older mentor/bodyguard on the end of it.
That doesn't seem to have happened.

Myles from "The Leadership Group" was out drinking with him during the ban, spent the whole afternoon and night with him and another player.