Carney no longer wanted by smith

[bondi-boy]

Willie and Todd strolling thru the French Riviera...and Monte Carlo. :-)

How much that might please many at the Roosters, I want Todd kept at Bondi.

[me_wantee]

I've think I've worked it out - you either own a tatt shop or a bottle shop.

[bondi-boy]

We can't he just be the carnage of 2010 and change his ways farken kills me

He got injured, he's young, he made a DUI mistake [having gone home to bed and was caught at .05 the next day]...Hadley admitted on air to being a drink driver when younger...and people are not robots.

He drank when recovering from an injury...nothing Wests Tigers players and players at other clubs didn't do.
He drank [legally, no breach of NRL's code of conduct] during the club's 2 week alcohol ban that should never have been.

And so he's to be sacked from the Roosters.

Oh puhlease! It's ridiculous!

He should've been fined and the money put into the Steggles Charity Nest.


Has Manly sacked Watmough?
Answer: No.

They're managing him.

The only perfect person who ever walked on earth was the man with the holes in his hands and feet.

[Big Poppa Pump]

The only perfect person who ever walked on earth was the man with the holes in his hands and feet.

Yep and even he got in trouble for hanging around the Cross.

[Guest]

Consider that argument debunked.

The club always hold power over employees and rightfully so. Smith may well tell Carney "he doesent want him at the club next year but That decision will not be made by Smith, The club does'nt even trust Smith to coach the team without an overseer, if he had the power to sack, he'd sack Elliott..

[Kingbilly]

He got injured, he's young, he made a DUI mistake [having gone home to bed and was caught at .05 the next day]...Hadley admitted on air to being a drink driver when younger...and people are not robots.

He drank when recovering from an injury...nothing Wests Tigers players and players at other clubs didn't do.
He drank [legally, no breach of NRL's code of conduct] during the club's 2 week alcohol ban that should never have been.

And so he's to be sacked from the Roosters.

Oh puhlease! It's ridiculous!

thats putting it all a little too simply and missing a few crucial bits...

[Chook Norris]

He drank when recovering from an injury...nothing Wests Tigers players and players at other clubs didn't do.

how about he drank when he was supposed to be out with the team in Gosford and was originally excused so he could visit his mom? Yes now it all sounds a lot worse doesnt it

[Guest]

I'd chop Smith before Carney.

[sretsoor]

Yep and even he got in trouble for hanging around the Cross.

Classic

[bondi-boy]

how about he drank when he was supposed to be out with the team in Gosford and was originally excused so he could visit his mom? Yes now it all sounds a lot worse doesnt it

Not when it's know that when the time came to drive home to visit mum the weather was horrendously bad.

[novice chook]

Not when it's know that when the time came to drive home to visit mum the weather was horrendously bad.

From memory it had been bad weather for a number of days so why arrange the visit in the first place if he didn't want to drive in the wet?? Why not just support your team mates in Gosford.

I drove up to Gosford in the same weather and sat there in the rain that night and got wet and cold to watch the boys and I'm just a supporter, as other supporters also did. I would expect the same if not more from a team mate.

NC

[supermario]

Not when it's know that when the time came to drive home to visit mum the weather was horrendously bad.

Considering he was in trouble from his DUI earlier in the year (licence would have been suspended due to the BAL and his Provisional licence) you would have thought Jumping on a train to goulburn would have been the smarter option regardless of the weather.......unless going to goulburn was not his intention.......

[bondi-boy]

Anything is possible.

If the club wasn't happy with him it should've fined him and put the money in the Steggles Charity Nest, say $10,000 for a first offence.

He wouldn't be the first person or player to think they were ten feet tall, bulletproof, and more important than they were.

[Kingbilly]

Not when it's know that when the time came to drive home to visit mum the weather was horrendously bad.

Here some more straws for you to clutch at ...

[bondi-boy]

Considering he was in trouble from his DUI earlier in the year (licence would have been suspended due to the BAL and his Provisional licence) you would have thought Jumping on a train to goulburn would have been the smarter option regardless of the weather.......unless going to goulburn was not his intention.......

You don't know the mental pressure/depression he was and still is under...as I tried to explain the the locked thread.
Grief-loss...and the mental pressure/depression suffered by the young men waiting to find out if they'd been selected.
It's the 'same' the mental anguish...[not a soldier and his job the same thing at all].
The 'pyschiatric' side of the 'depression'.
Ask an expert and they will tell you.

He exhibits classic signs...does everything to avoid deep thought of any kind.